Chapter 2: We Try Craig's List
She said no, it was a one time thing with my brother, but that incredibly sensual night the three of us spent together worked like a worm in our brains. We still looked at the photographs all the time: I took over a hundred that night. Not all of them were worth keeping; we did keep about twenty. But it was the videos that really turned us on: his cock sliding into her pussy, her sucking my cock, her riding his manhood cowgirl style. By the time it got to that little pearl of jizz nestled in her pussy, we would be fucking like rabbits. Needless to say, our sex life had gone into warp drive.
"So, do we want to do it. Again?" she asked one evening while we were in the jacuzzi a month or so later. We were fucking. I was sitting on the step and she was riding me, her firm tits pressed hard against my chest.
I didn't answer. My focus was feeling her hips grind against me with my cock buried deep in her pussy.
"You really got off watching me with him, didn't you?"
I grunted.
"Had you ever thought about it before that night?"
I looked at her. She laughed. "You did, didn't you! You'd thought about watching me have sex with another man!" She playfully slapped my face. "You bad boy!"
Her eyes closed as an orgasm swept through her.
"Did you imagine me with your brother?" she asked when it had passed.
"No" I replied quickly, "it was always with a stranger, some guy we met at a bar or something."
"Did you ever imagine me watching you fuck another woman?"
That thought had never entered my mind. "No. Have you?"
"All the time, since that night." Her hips moved faster. I was really close to an orgasm.
"Do you think you'd like to watch me?"
She kissed me before she answered, our tongues dancing. "You liked it so why do you think I wouldn't? I mean, it felt so good, so intense, you touching me, taking pictures, taking video. Like we were porn stars or something. I think I'd like it."
"Would you want me to cum in another woman's pussy?"
"Your brother came in mine and it really got you off, didn't it," a statement more than a question. "And I know he sure got me of!," she said wistfully, "Jeez, that night was magical."
It was as if that thought, the sensual magic of that lusty evening caught us both almost by surprise. We both came hard, white strings of semen soon swirling in the water as we got out.
We talked a little more about it during the following weeks. Going to a bar? Nah, we'd have to be seeking out couples and we had no idea how to do that. Besides, neither one of us liked just 'going to a bar'. Get on an adult dating site? So we tried that for a month but found it populated by weirdos and hard core swingers that looked like too many pairs of worn out shoes.
We finally settled on Craig's List. We could join without having to put our profile out there and it was free. Then we could pick and chose from the list. And there were lists, hundreds of names. We narrowed it down to Napa and Sonoma with couples around our age, maybe a tad older. We were especially aware of things in their profiles like, "First time..." or "Experimenting with...". We culled out people with heavy tats, morbid obesity, or others that just looked sleazy. Very subjective.
We'd narrowed it down to a handful and were going through a few more pages when I heard a quick intake of breath and Amy's eyes riveted on the screen.
"Eleven inches," she hissed, "Eleven fucking inches." Funny. Size had never mattered until she fucked David. It wasn't long after that that we measured me, just for the hell of it: seven inches. But I digress.
Their ad was a panel of five photographs with an introductory paragraph and brief description of the pair in the field below. "Sensual interracial couple looking to experiment with another couple."
Description of her was: Hispanic, 5'4", 110#, brown eyes, black hair, petite, 34-21-34, butterfly tattoo on abdomen.
Description of him was: African-American, 6'0', 185#, brown eyes, black hair, athletic, 11".
The pictures were amateur but good. First was a selfie of the two smiling into a cell phone. It looked like it had been taken at a county fair or amusement park. The other four were more intimate, more graphic. Two of her laying naked on the bed- a full frontal and another of her on her stomach showing off her curvy ass; a full frontal of him lying on the bed with an erection that reached almost to his navel; and another on the bed together having sex.