"So, are you going to fuck Sherry or not?" my wife snapped at me. She immediately covered her mouth with her hand and started to laugh.
To be fair, this wasn't the first time she had asked me, it was just the most direct. We were not this type of couple. We weren't swingers, we hadn't opened our marriage, this was special.
My wife, Tina, and Sherry had been friends forever. Growing up together, they did everything together, shared everything together. For years they had this fantasy of having kids at the same time. They wanted their kids could grow up together the same way. Tina just found out she was pregnant. This immediately sparked a problem; Sherry wasn't in a relationship and not likely to be preggers anytime soon.
I have no idea what discussion took place the first time, I only know when Tina first broached the subject.
We were sitting in front of the fire; I was enjoying a nice glass of wine. Tina wasn't enjoying her hot chocolate.
"Would you ever consider getting Sherry pregnant?" Tina suddenly asked out of the blue.
I just about spit my wine. Tine went on to give a summary of the conversations she had been having with Sherry.
It started with Sherry complaining that Tina had 'sperm on demand' and she couldn't even get a date.
This part I didn't understand, Sherry was hot. On the petite side standing only 5'2", had a slim body and nice little A cup tits. Her hair was a dirty blonde and flowed past her shoulders. She wasn't as hot as Tina, but a super close second. Tina was a little taller at 5'7", long dark brown hair, and had more of the classic pin-up body, curvy hips, and topped off with a set of Cs.
They felt their dream of having their kids grow up together was starting to fall apart making them both upset. You can imagine it was only a small hop to one of them suggesting I fill in the missing piece. This seemed a better idea than anything else suddenly, their kids would be half siblings. Once that idea was on the table the discussion took off, they talked through all their issues, challenges, and concerns in one afternoon.
"Here is what we thought would work," Tina had started ignoring the fact I hadn't said anything yet, "We would want it to feel natural for everyone, so no turkey baster shit. We don't want it to feel like a process or a medical procedure. I would want you to treat her like you treat me. You would make love to her. How does that sound so far?"
I felt I had to be careful, 'how did it sound?' terrific. However, my first concern was my wife. I didn't want her to feel jealous or have any negative feelings about this.
"How does it sound to you?" I asked her.
Tina looked at me thoughtfully for a moment, "I love and trust you; I love and trust Sherry, I know she would be delighted to have a baby. I have given this a lot of thought; I have imagined it in my head. All I see is two people I love sharing a special gift."
"I would be happy to do my part" I tried sounding as stoic as possible.
"Fuck off!" Tina snapped at me, "You would love to fuck Sherry, I know you would, what man wouldn't. I am asking you if you are ok with being a father to Sherry's child?"
"So how does that part work?" I continued remaining serious.
"You would be the cool Uncle," Tina said thoughtfully, "we would probably have an age-appropriate conversations as they grow up; 'Daddy sperm and Mommy egg' and all that. They would know you are the biological father."
I had spent most of the week avoiding the question and answering with questions of my own. I didn't want to appear too eager to jump into bed with Tina's best friend. I also didn't want Tina to feel uncomfortable in any way. I was super excited, but it wasn't worth our marriage and their friendship.
Back to this evening and the question that had been put to me so bluntly.
"Yes," I answered, "I would love to fuck your best friend."
Tina smiled a loving smile at me. She was going to be fine with this. Everything she was doing; she was doing out of love for me and Sherry. This was going to be ok.
She came over and gave me a very passionate kiss.
"I love you," she started, "I love you are willing to do this for Sherry. I get there is more to it than a roll for you, Sherry will be thrilled. I am going to call her and give her the news."
From the other room I heard only Tina's part of the conversation except for a couple of squeals I heard from the other end.
"Yes, he is happy...," I heard Tina say, "we discussed it all in detail. I told him to treat you nice...... Tuesday? Are you sure? Ok, why don't you come over around 7 and we will do supper... first."
Tina came back into the room to let me know Sherry was delighted. She also explained some science around ovulation that I didn't really pay attention to, but Tuesday was the right time to start.
