Parts of this story are based on true events, others are purely fantasy. Hope you enjoy.
Katie and I were high school sweethearts. We dated all four years and then went off to college together. She has beautiful blonde hair, long sexy legs, a perfect ass, and perky tits. She drew attention everywhere she went. I, on the other hand am a very average guy in just about every way. When we went out together I knew that people wondered why we were together.
We got married after college and have been together since. We both came from conservative families and had it drilled into our minds growing up that we were supposed to wait until marriage before having sex.
We didn't make it. We were off on our own at college we couldn't resist any longer and we finally slept together. Katie is way out of my league. If we hadn't gotten together in high school I doubt she would've given me a chance.
Another thing you should know is that since neither of us had been with anyone else, we didn't really have any frame of reference for sex. Everything we did we were experiencing for the first time together. In fact, I'm the only man she's ever seen naked, except for one drunken incident at a party.
We never really did anything too adventurous in college. But one night during our junior year when we were back home from school on a break our friend Cameron invited a group of us over. There weren't going to be too many people and the house was big enough that we could all stay overnight.
The party was fun as we all sat around drinking, catching up and reminiscing. After a while our friend's older brother, Alex, and his girlfriend, Nikki showed up.
Alex and Nikki were a couple years older than us, but we all knew them well. Or at least knew of them. Alex was the quarterback of the football team and went on to play college ball. Nikki was the prom queen that every guy had a crush on.
It was clear that Alex already been drinking and was being loud and obnoxious. It really killed the vibe and before long Katie and I made our excuses and left the group.
Katie always got pretty frisky when she drinks. We got to our room and she immediately pulled me in for a kiss. I felt her hand reach down and start rubbing my cock outside my pants.
I was already rock hard and couldn't wait to fuck her. I pulled her shirt off over her head and immediately took mine off as well. We were young and inexperienced so foreplay was out the window. We both took off our pants and underwear and I climbed on top of her.
I slid my cock into her pussy and she let out a moan. Within a few minutes I was cumming. I collapsed on the bed beside her and pulled her in close to me. We pulled a blanket on top of us and held each other close.
Then suddenly the door opened and the light came on. It was Alex. He ran into the room, Nikki standing behind him with a resigned look on her face.
"It smells like sex in here" he shouted, "are you guys done already?"
He came over to the bed and ripped the blanket off of us. Katie moved to cover herself up. With one hand I grabbed for the blanket, and with the other I tried to cover myself up.
As I said before, I am very average. Most of the cocks I've seen in locker rooms or dorm showers have been as big or bigger than mine, and so I have always felt a little subconscious about the size of my dick.
Unfortunately both efforts to cover myself failed.
"Look how small his dick is"
Alex said, turning to Nikki who had walked into the room and was trying to get him to leave. She turned and looked at me and stifled a laugh. Katie had heard enough and stepped in to defend me.
"Fuck you Alex," she said, "like your cock is so much bigger"
Then Alex did the last thing either of us expected.
"You think so?" He asked. "Take a look yourself."
Then, before we could respond, he pulled down his pants and showed us his dick. He took it in his hand and started to stroke it.
"This is a real cock" he said.
Nikki turned and finally succeeded at pushing him out the door but the damage was done. He was right, his cock was significantly bigger than mine. He wasn't fully hard but was still very clearly longer and thicker than me.
I got up, locked the door, and turned off the light. Then I walked back to the bed and climbed back under the blanket.
"Don't worry about him," Katie told me, "He's just an asshole."
"I know," I told her, "let's go to sleep".
I turned away from her and closed my eyes, but couldn't fall asleep. I was feeling a crazy range of emotions and couldn't face her. Jealousy, anger, resentment, humiliation were all swirling within me. I could not get the image of Nikki holding back laughter when she saw my dick and the look on Katie's face when she saw Alex's dick out of my mind.
I wondered what Katie was thinking but was too afraid to ask. I told myself to just forget it ever happened and we would never speak of it again. Eventually I drifted off to sleep.
Katie must've come to the same conclusion I did because the next morning we got up and didn't say a single thing about Alex and Nikki's intrusion into our room. In fact, we never spoke about it and went on living like it never happened. Sometimes I wondered if it actually did happen or if it was a dream. But I never forgot it. Almost every time I had sex with Katie after that night, I wondered if she wished my cock was bigger. I wondered if she ever thought about how good it would feel to be fucked by a man with a big dick. I wondered if she would wake up one day and decide I wasn't good enough for her.
But she never said anything about it. We finished school, got married, and moved away. We had a great life, even if our sex life was merely adequate. We loved each other deeply.
Then, one day, Katie came home with some unexpected news. She had run into Alex and Nikki. They had gotten married too and moved to the same town as we lived in a few months before. I wasn't sure what to say or feel. But since we'd gone several years without mentioning the incident, I just acted like I would have with any of our other friends from back home. I asked how they were doing, what made them move, all the expected questions.
Katie told me what she had learned and then we changed the subject. It was a pretty normal night for us until we got into bed.
I initiate sex about 95% of the time, but that night Katie got in bed next to me and started running her hands over my chest and stomach. My cock stiffened as she moved closer and closer to the waistband of my boxers. I ran my fingers through her hair, waiting in anticipation.
She slowly and methodically worked her way down. Her finger slid inside my underwear and she took me in her hand. I exhaled at her touch. I moved to touch her breasts but she stopped me.
"Not yet" she told me.
"Okay," I said, obediently.
She continued to tease me, building up the anticipation.
"There's something I didn't tell you about today," she said. "Something I think you should know"
"What?" I asked.
