The Confession Pt 1: Unfaithful
Author's Note: I am updating this story and the others in this series because I don't feel the original versions did the story justice.
Preface: This story is true. Names have been changed to protect the innocent and the guilty. The theme of this story and others I will share, is that sexuality doesn't have to mean guilt, and being naughty doesn't have to mean humiliation or degradation. And memories of real events can be contaminated by unwarranted guilt.
"I've got a confession," Donna looked away from me. We were sitting in a diner that wasn't the one she worked at. She looked like she was ready to run and my heart ached.
We'd fallen head over heels in love, less than three months before. She was a widow with four kids. Her husband had been a violent dirt bag by all accounts and had died of an accidental self-inflicted gunshot to his leg.
My wife and I had separated with extreme prejudice and were heading towards a divorce. We had two kids she wouldn't let me see even though I paid child support. My time with Donna made me want to keep living.
Donna and I were in our early thirties. On the weekends she worked as a waitress at the diner on the 10 PM to 6 AM, "bar crowd", shift, but once in a while she would have to be the grill cook. Since the grill was right behind the counter in the front of the diner, her denim clad ass would be gyrating in front of the customers as she cooked. I always sat at the counter right behind the grill.
I had fallen in love with Donna. I didn't mean to. Fifteen years in my soon-to-be-ex-wife's twisted reality had left me gun shy. But Donna was different. Maybe because she actually liked me? I don't know but she'd become the best part of my day and night. The sex was great too.
Now she's giving me the 'We-gotta-talk' scene where she dumps my ass out in the cold again. And I didn't want that. We'd had three months of knee knocking, ball rocking sex. Like we were teenagers, except I'd never got to have sex like that as a teenager. She was eager and willing in bed. I was clumsy but I let her do what she wanted. She seemed to like it.
I reached across the table and held her hands. "Whatever it is, it doesn't matter."
"You don't know anything about me." Donna flashed an angry look at me, earned by talking and not listening. She'd been working herself up to tell me something.
"I know you're a dedicated mother. You're strong. And you are hella sexy in bed." I squeezed her hands and thought about how her eraser shaped nipples seemed to be connected directly to her clit. She would get so excited when I sucked on them she would almost cum.
"Yeah, well, I'm not that good." She looked me in the eyes as she hesitated. Then the words rushed out so low I could barely hear them. "I cheated on my husband."
I sat back, a wave of relief washing over me. She wasn't trying to dump me. I said the first things that came to my mind from the stories she'd told me about him.
"He cheated on you with two of your sisters, his stepmother and a teenage girl. Your marriage was dead a long time before he was." I stroked her face. She had tears making streaks on her cheeks. "When was this?"
"About six months before he died."
"Were you in love with this guy?" This was my first fear. Then I thought about straight laced little Miss Donna sneaking off to fuck some guy and a frisson of excitement shot down my spine. My Donna could be a bad girl. "How many times did you see him?"
My secret fantasies had always included my significant other having sex with other men. The idea that Donna had done it once thrilled me like she had just come back from a triste. Now, I wanted to know all about it. I wanted details.
"We only did it once. He was a friend of the family and used to listen to me talk." Donna looked as though she was willing me not to run away from her.
"And what's so bad about that?" I was torn between wanting to comfort her and assure her that her actions didn't bother and wanting to know how many other times she'd been bad.
"I'm just a slut like he always said I was." She looked away again, tears forming in her eyes.
"I don't think having an affair when you're in a loveless marriage makes you a slut. I don't think having sex with someone you're attracted to makes you a slut." Maybe, if I supported her and made her feel better about herself, I could get her to tell me what they did. That would be almost as good as seeing it.
Donna got quiet and stared out the window. While she drank her coffee, I visualized this unknown man on top of her with her legs wrapped around his back as he stroked his cock in and out of her throbbing pussy. She had been a bad girl, and it excited me.
"I guess I wanted to do something for myself, for a change." The look of yearning she shot my way made me want to pull her across the table and sit in my lap. "Do you really love me?"
"I do." And no it wasn't just sex or the thrill of being bad that made me say that. Donna herself was special. This revelation was just icing. "I don't know where this train is going but I'm on for the ride."
"You say so now, but there is more but I won't tell you here. No one can know." She finished her coffee. "Let's go back to your place."
I tried not to let my excitement show. She had been bad and I wanted to know all the lascivious details.
***
My place was a trailer, in a nice trailer park, if there is such a thing. I bought it because I didn't want to live in my parent's basement after leaving my wife. I had an old couch, a card table for the kitchen and a waterbed. Dad had made some end tables and a coffee table. It was spartan and efficient.
She stripped coming in the door, and was naked by the time we reached the bedroom. She arranged herself on the bed and said, "Are you ready?"
I went for it. After some quick fumbling with titties and pussy I had her sitting on my cock and riding up and down its length. I alternated with sucking on her tits and guiding her rhythm. I held back my orgasm while she slowly built to her climax. I tried helping her by playing with her clit but she pushed my hand away. She picked up her pace until we pounded each other's pubic mounds frenetically.
I froze. I had to cum so hard it hurt. While I pulsed stream after stream of jizz into her, she made a small squeak as she came. "I'm sorry honey. I tried to hold it."
"It's fine. Not your fault." She climbed off me and went to the bathroom to clean up. She came back to bed and cuddled me.
I'm a voyeur. Aside from peeking in windows which is generally frowned upon, hearing stories is the next best thing. The idea of hearing Donna's stories excited me. I had no idea she had had any adventures. I'd thought she'd never been with anyone but her husband who she had married very young. I wondered how many other stories there were.
"So tell me about your affair? Who was it? Who started it? What did you do?" I pulled her naked body against mine.
"What do you want to know that for?" She drew circles around my nipples.
"I like to watch." This got a look of disgust from her. "Hey, you tell me your secrets and I'll tell you mine."
"But it makes me feel dirty," she whispered.
"I like it when you're dirty." I kissed her thoroughly.
After a bit she relaxed again and spoke. "He was a soldier. A neighbor, Chet. Holly babysat for him and his wife."
I resisted asking any more questions. She would get to it. "He used to come into the diner during my shift. We'd talk when things quieted down."
####
Donna:
He'd tease me a little when I grumped about Mac. He said my husband didn't deserve a wife like me. That made me feel pretty good.
I was fed up with Mac. He was abusive. He ran around with teenagers nearly the same age as his daughter. I was so sick of him. Chet was nice. He suggested we should go out.
I thought about it for a while. I confided in my friend Kathy, who thought Mac was a complete asshole. She was OK with me cheating. She didn't even call it cheating. Of course, her husband used to be her best friend's husband. I didn't want to take Chet from his wife. Pretty sure he wasn't interested in more than a friendly fuck. Guys are like that. Most would fuck anything with a pulse.
I liked Chet. He was a good guy, and he complimented me. I know it sounds shallow but just being talked to like you matter as a person is sexy as hell. That's when I realized I really wanted to do something for myself. So, Chet and I made some plans.
If Mac found out, he'd kill me. But I was tired of being used by men. I wanted to have my own fun. When everything was set, Kathy called my house telling me I had to work that night.
I couldn't dress up because I was supposedly going to work so I put on my white knit shirt and black pants. That didn't matter because I didn't expect to wear anything once we got to Chet's house. I felt so naughty.