The Changeup

"Do you remember Carmen?" Claire asks me looking over from her laptop as we sit on the couch.

I reach over and pause the episode of

Star Trek

I've been watching. "Let me see. Who was she again? Was she the one I fucked while she ate you out?" I say, pretending like I don't remember.

"You don't remember?" Claire asks and looks at me with confusion and surprise and perhaps a little bit of hurt.

"Of course I do. I was joking," I say and she sighs in relief. "How could I forget that night? That's what started our whole sexual revolution...for lack of a better term."

"Oh good. I was going to be so mad at you if you had forgotten like you've forgotten our first date."

"It is not my fault we saw like a hundred movies when we were dating. I worked at the movie theater. We could see any that we wanted. How am I supposed to remember which was the first? Besides, we looked up the movies that came out that year and you weren't even sure which one it was."

"I might not remember the movie, but I remember the date," she says and gently kicks me to let me know she isn't mad.

"Why did you ask about her?" I ask, returning to the original question.

"She found me on Facebook."

"A year later?"

"She sent me a message and said she was moving to the area."

"That doesn't make sense. She would have had to have known we lived out here before she found you on Facebook and messaged you."

"Who knows?" Claire says and shrugs. "Maybe she's been lurking on us ever since."

"I guess I might do that too if I'd had a threesome with somebody," I say.

"Yeah. I tried to find her before, but I couldn't. She must have been private."

"What did she want?"

"Recommendations on housing," Claire says.

"Oh," I say, trying not to sound disappointed. I love fucking Claire and we'd had the best sex of our lives since that first night with Carmen, but I had had a fleeting fantasy where we'd do it again.

"And she wanted to meet up. With both of us. If you want."

"I'd be okay with that," I say.

"Try not to sound too enthusiastic or I might get jealous," Claire says playfully.

"I only have eyes for you."

"But your cock is thinking two," she says and gives me another light kick.

A few short weeks later, Claire tells me that Carmen has found an apartment and has begun to move in. Of all the strange coincidences that happen in a person's life, this might be the strangest one. Claire and Carmen are apparently friends now because they exchanged numbers. So a few days after Carmen moves to town, she calls Claire and asks if we want to go out to dinner. We agree and suggest our favorite Mexican restaurant in town. That night we get ready to go out and beat her there. I'm eating chips and salsa when I look up and see the unmistakable figure of Carmen walking into the restaurant. She recognizes us and starts to walk over. Her hips are a little fuller than I remember. Her black hair is longer and frames her cute face nicely. The shirt she is wearing is pretty tight and outlines her tits nicely. I look away and mentally tell my cock to behave itself when Claire notices her too and waves. Carmen slides into the booth seat across from us.

Claire and Carmen do most of the talking throughout the meal. Apparently she is originally from the area and is just moving back home. She has a job as a masseuse, and Claire kicks me under the table as soon as Carmen says it like she thinks I'm getting funny ideas which I was. Carmen directs a few questions at me with regards to what I teach at the college and things like that. The meal is comprised of small talk and no one mentions the fact that we've all seen each other naked or the fact that we had a super hot threesome. However, as we're standing by our cars getting ready to leave the conversation shifts.

"What made you look us up?" Claire asks.

Carmen looks around to see if anyone is near and then whispers, "I saw your video online and it reminded me of how great that night was. I wanted to see what you were up to."

"Video?" I ask startled and Claire makes surprised eye contact with me as well. I guess she didn't know either.

"Well, you know...I was..." she starts to say and trails off before continuing. "Why am I embarrassed? We had a threesome. I was watching porn online and found a video of you two."

"What video?" I ask again.

"You didn't know?" Carmen looks surprised and embarrassed now. "There's no way anyone would know it was you two unless they knew you. I wasn't sure if it was you at first but I recognized your assets." She looks from Claire's chest to my crotch.

"What was the video of?" Claire asks.

"Looked like a webcam show actually. Someone was telling you what to do and you did it. It was really hot. I've definitely watched it more than once."

Claire and I exchange nervous glances and tell Carmen that we didn't record that or upload it. The woman who paid for the show must have done it. Carmen apologizes, but we tell her it isn't her fault. It's nice knowing she liked it. She looks up the video on her phone to show us, and I memorize the name of the video. I plan on requesting the site take it down as soon as we get home. Carmen looks disappointed, but she understands. Just as we are saying good bye again, another strange coincidence occurs. The other person in the entire world that Claire and I have had a threesome with parks his car next to ours.

Jack says hi to Claire and me before saying, "Who is your gorgeous friend here?"

"Jack this is Carmen. Carmen this is Jack," Claire says.

Jack reaches out his hand to shake hers and I watch as he eyes never break from hers. He's obviously enthralled with her.

"We know Jack because of..." Claire starts to say but Jack interrupts.

"That's not important," he says.

However, Carmen senses something and pushes it by asking how they know each other. Jack starts to make a lie about it, but I interject to the surprise of everyone.

"We had a threesome with him too," I say.

All three of them stare at me. Claire shocked that I even said something at all. Normally, she does all the talking. Carmen and Jack are both shocked by the word "too."

"Wait. What?" Jack asks, recovering first.

"Before we had our encounter with you," Claire says pointing at Jack. "We had one with her." She points at Carmen next. "Actually, it's because of her we met up with you."

"Well then," Carmen says and looks at her feet clearly embarrassed. She was comfortable with us, but she doesn't know Jack.

"Well then, indeed," Jack says. "I guess I should thank you Carmen for allowing me to have a wonderful experience with these two."

Carmen looks up and smiles. Her shyness slipping away and giving way to her generally confident personality. We all talk for a little while longer and by the time we leave Carmen and Jack are getting along well. She even goes back into the restaurant with him. Claire and I leave feeling like we've just set them up on a date on accident. It turns out that is exactly what we've done. That night after I've successfully gotten the website to take down our video, Claire gets a text from Carmen and Jack both individually thanking us for introducing them to each other. A few days later, Claire tells me that their Facebook statuses have updated to being in a relationship with each other. I feel happy for them, but also a little disappointed. My chance for being with Carmen again seems to have drained down the tubes. Not that Claire doesn't please or satisfy me. I'm perfectly content with her. I just had the fantasy of doing it again with Carmen. I'm sure if I asked, Claire would feel the same way about Jack. Then one night Claire and I are laying in bed. I ask her what she is thinking about.

"I was thinking about that night with Carmen," she says.

"What about it?" I say and roll to my side to look at her.

"I think what I liked best about it wasn't what she was doing with me, but watching you with her. It turned me on so much."

"I can see that. It was hot seeing you with Jack. So hot that I joined in and I never would have thought I'd have a threesome with another man. Or anyone before Carmen."

"Really?" she asks and sits up to look at me.

"Sure," I say and sit up too.

"If you could, would you fuck Carmen again?" she asks.

I hesitate for a moment before saying, "Only if you wanted me to."

"Let's say I didn't care. Would you want to?"

"Yes," I say perhaps too enthusiastically and she kicks me playfully under the blankets. "But, she's with Jack now so this is all irrelevant."

"Not entirely," she says coyly.

I wait for her to follow it up, but she doesn't. "And?" I ask.

"Carmen and I talked and she had a thought. She was going to see if Jack was okay with it, but she was pretty sure he would want to.

"Want to what?" I say. "Just spit it out already."

"Well, we thought we could maybe get over some of the sexual tension surrounding our relationships if we just let it happen."

I stare at her waiting for her to elaborate.

"We don't want to put any extra stress on our relationships knowing about the past and thinking too much about it. So rather than you pretending to not fantasize about Carmen, you can just have her one more time and stop pretending."

"What about you?"

"Oh it turns me on a lot to think about watching you with her."

At that moment, her phone vibrates with a text message.

"Jack's in," she reads off her phone. "But under one condition. Oh."

"Oh what?"

"Jack won't agree unless we do a trade for the night. You and Carmen. Jack and I."

"You don't want that?" I ask.

"Sure I would, but I figured you wouldn't."

"If I get to have fun, it only makes sense that you can too if you want."

It doesn't take much convincing until Claire agrees. She texts Carmen back and forth a few times and they decide this upcoming weekend would be a good time. We're going to split the cost of two hotel rooms. When they book it, they'll request ones with adjoining doors. If anyone wants to stop at any time, we will with no questions asked. The more Claire thinks about it the more I think she likes the idea. She'd told me before that she wasn't into swinging, but this is somehow a little different. It's more like sharing and she seems okay with that at least this once.

The days go by and its finally the weekend. Claire and I arrive first and settle in our room. We packed a small suitcase because we actually do spend on staying the night. There's a knock on the door from the other hotel and Claire opens it cautiously. Carmen and Jack are settling into their room and everyone is a little bit excited and nervous at the same time. We decide to go out to eat first. During the meal we avoid any conversation remotely about sex. Mostly Jack and Carmen talk about how things have been going with them since we introduced them to each other. Once we return to our hotel rooms, we take a moment to freshen up. We all shower and the women do their hair and makeup. The door between hotel rooms is open and we are each sitting in robes on our beds awkwardly waiting for some unknown signal to start. Even though we've all seen each other naked this is new territory for everyone. Finally, Carmen stands up and walks into our room. I'm sitting on the edge of the bed and she walks over to me. She puts her hands on my knees and kisses me lightly on the lips. She breaks off the kiss and I look to see Claire getting up and walking into the other room. She starts to close the door, but then leaves it open just a little bit.

As soon as Claire is out of the room, Carmen kisses me again much more hungrily. Her lips part and she kisses me more passionately than I would have ever imagined. Soon she breaks off the kiss again and steps back from me. She undoes the belt on her robe and pulls it open before letting it slide off her shoulders and onto the ground. She's gone all out, and I wonder if she wanted this to happen more than anyone. She's taller than Claire and thinner, but still not disgustingly skinny. Her tan Latina skin seems to shimmer in the light from the lamp. Her long black hair falls to her shoulders and cascades to cover her breasts just enough to cover her nipples. She has on a green lingerie set that makes my cock twitch with anticipation. She has on black lace stockings that are cinched with garters. Underneath this she has on a pair of crotchless green panties that reveal her neatly trimmed bush in the shape of a little landing strip that ends in a triangle pointing directly at her luscious pussy lips. Instead of a bra, she has sexy silver body jewelry draped across her shoulders. It dips between her breasts and circles underneath them. The thin chains of the jewelry dangle gently against her skin.

She steps toward me again and bends back down to kiss me. As she does, she undoes the belt around my waist and slowly pulls the robe from my shoulders. Still kissing, she pulls me to my feet and the robe falls all the way to the ground. I'm a lot less sexy than her, but as she steps back to look at me she smiles at the black thong hugging my swelling cock. She loops one finger around the tiny string around my waist and pulls it down to expose my junk to her view. I've shaved completely and she runs her other hand over my smooth skin. She lets the strap snap back into place and I'm once again covered. She pulls me into another kiss and grabs my ass as she does. She pushes me into her and my hard cock rubs against her pussy through our clothes. She kisses her way to my ear.

"I know you've fantasized about having me again," she breaths into my ear and I stifle a moan. "I've fantasized about having you all to myself ever since you fucked me with Claire watching. I knew the first thing I'd do if I ever got the chance was to put that big yummy cock of yours in my mouth."

She kisses her way down my chest and then kneels in front of me. She nibbles softly on my dick through my thong until finally she pulls it down with her teeth. My hard cock flops free and lightly hits her in the face and she giggles so cutely I could almost cum then. She pulls my thong all the way down with her hands and as she does so her soft hair tickles my cock sensually. She looks up at me from her knees and smiles before swirling her tongue on the tip of my cock. She runs her tongue all the way down the base of my shaft and then sucks on my balls. She licks her way back to the tip before wrapping her lips around me. She swirls her tongue around my head some more before sliding her mouth all the way down my cock. She stops at the base and deep throats me for a moment before sliding back up. She takes me out and uses her hand to stroke my cock a few times before putting me back in her mouth. Then she really goes to work. Her head bobs as she sucks me off. With one hand she alternates squeezing and massaging my balls. With the other hand she caresses the sensitive area between my balls and asshole before lightly fingering the outside of my asshole. The extra sensation is overwhelming and I'm soon close to coming. Without thinking I put my hand on her head to signal I'm close just like I would with Claire. I realize she might not get it and start to say something when she picks up speed and sucks harder. I can't get any words out as I feel my balls tighten. She must know too as she stops sucking and instead wraps her lips around the head of my cock and pumps her hand up and down my shaft slick with her spit. In a moment, I'm exploding into her mouth and she keeps pumping. She doesn't take her lips off me and I shoot every last drop of my load into her mouth. Once she's sure she has every last drop she pulls away and smiles at me before swallowing. There's a little bit of cum left on my tip and she licks it off which makes me shudder. She licks her lips and swallows the rest of it.

"Fuck," I say. "That was good."

"I knew you'd taste delicious," she says to me while climbing onto the bed. She lays on her back and spreads her legs wide. "Now, it's your turn."

I scramble onto the bed and think about diving right into her wet pussy but decide to take my time. I start by kissing her perky tits and sucking on her puffy nipples. I gently run my fingers along the jewelry that adorns her body. I kiss my way down to her hips and linger there a moment before also kissing her inner thighs. I trace the outside of her mound with my tongue and listen to her breathing get heavier. I nuzzle the landing strip she's made for me before licking her slit. As I tease her, I become aware of moans coming from the room next door. The familiar sound of Claire in ecstasy reaches my ears and my cock twinges even in its softened state. From the sounds of it, Jack must be eating her out. I'd thought I'd be jealous hearing someone else with my wife, but it just makes what I'm doing even more hotter.

I return my attention to Carmen's sweet pussy and spread it with my fingers. I lick her clit gently at first and relish the jolts it sends through her body. She's not as wet as Claire and her juices are somehow just a little thick and creamier. Her pussy tastes entirely different than Claire's and its like learning how to eat pussy all over again. I swirl my tongue in circles around her clit and she moans for me. I suck on each of her lips and nibble them and she moans louder. I push my tongue into her pussy as far as it will go and lap at her tangy juices before pulling away.

"Your pussy tastes so good," I tell Carmen.

"Fuck it feels fantastic," she tells me and pushes my head back down.

I resist long enough to tell her, "I want you to scream for me. I want them to hear you."

She moans loudly in response as I return to licking her pussy. I adjust my positing just a little bit so I can insert a finger into her tight hole while I lap at her clit. Her body convulses with each flick of my tongue. Her moans crescendo into screams of my name. Soon she's announcing that she is going to come for me. I curl my finger and massage her most sensitive spot while my tongue works faster and faster on her clit. Her pussy grips my finger and I feel her come all the way through her body. She screams and moans as she rides wave after wave of pleasure and I keep eating her out. Claire normally makes me stop, but she Carmen doesn't and instead I keep tasting her pussy as she comes down from her orgasm. She shudders and shudders as I continue to drink from her well. She moans more softly now and finally I break off away from her. I sit up in a kneeling position and look at the satisfied glow on her face. Her eyes are closed and lips slightly parted in deep breaths. I look toward the door and see that it is open with Claire and Jack standing in the door way. They both have large grins on their face.

"Too loud?" I ask and they shake their heads.

"That was so sexy watching you eat her out, Jake," Claire says and walks over to our bed. She leans over and kisses me passionately. Her tongue roves all around my mouth and I know she can taste Carmen on my lips. When we break away, Jack is sitting on the edge of the bed kissing Carmen. "Are you too spent?" Claire asks me.

"I don't think so," I say and look down at my cock. Just enough time has passed so that my cock has recovered and is slowly growing harder.

"Good," she says and gives my cock a squeeze before laying on the bed next to Carmen. She whispers something in Carmen's ear and she smiles.

The both get up and Carmen tells me to lay on my back. Claire does the same for Jack. Claire goes to the suitcase and pulls out two condoms and gives one to Carmen. Carmen rips it open and unrolls it on my now completely erect cock. Then she climbs on top of me. She rubs her pussy a few times before guiding my cock into her. She settles down on me and begins to ride me. Her tits jiggle as she bounces up and down on my cock. The body jewelry around her shoulders and tits jingles lightly but is soon drowned out by our collective moans. I look to my right and Claire is riding Jack. She has both hands on his broad chest and is slamming her ass up and down on him. I look back to Carmen and she's put a hand behind her and is know squatting on my dick. This new position allows her to pump her hips much more quickly on my cock. I close my eyes for a moment and relish the feel of her tight pussy around my cock even through the condom. When I open them she is leaning over and kissing Claire full on the lips while they both still ride us. They make out while fucking us for a moment longer before slowing down. Claire nods to Carmen and they dismount.