Trey was, quite possibly, the best lover – up to that point in my life anyway – I’d ever had. We had experienced kink together, had tied each other up, had sex, once in a cemetery, on top of a grave. We were both a bit of Midwestern fringe – not quite fitting in, not quite outcasts. Of course, our families thought we were perfect for each other – there are so few Catholics in my small, Midwestern town – my mother was absolutely thrilled. The night of our graduation, Trey had ended it, with an absolute pronouncement. “We’re both going to college,” he said, “And we don’t need to pretend we’re going to hold on to this.” Perhaps for the first time in my life, I was truly, truly heartbroken. I was the one who broke relationships – I was the one who decided when it was over. Not this time. The day after graduation, I stayed in bed all day, claiming sickness and crying myself into infrequent naps. Of course, we had both gone to college – I had dated, danced, drank, fucked – but I’d not quite forgotten Trey. And here he was, smiling at me, a mop in his hand.
I heard Betty’s croaking voice – “Umm, let’s see – Trey and Kristen – since you’re the young ones – maybe you can share the floor mopping, hmm?” The “hmmm” was a verbal tic Betty had never quite gotten over. “Yes,” I heard Trey say, “We can do that – here’s one mop – do we have another? And floor cleaner?” Betty looked over the collected cleaning supplies. Somehow, Mom had gotten swept away with the dust and the chatter and was now cheerfully polishing pews. I could hear her laugh and her distinctive gossip tones. Betty clicked her tongue, and said, “You know, Trey – I think there’s another mop in the cleaning closet downstairs – and I’m sure that’s where the Soilax is, too – do you want to go get it? Let me know if it’s not down there.” “Sure,” Trey said, “We can do that – c’mon, Kristen.” Numb, I followed Trey down the steps to the basement, site of my early religious training – my mind jammed with thoughts of Sunday school and saintly filmstrips.
“So,” Trey said, “How’s school?” I shook my head a little and smiled, “It’s going well – actually, very well. I think I’ll make the Dean’s List this semester.” “Yeah?” he sounded genuinely pleased, “Good for you.” “And you?” I asked, “How’s school for you?” “It’s all right,” he sounded uncertain, “I think I’m just making an adjustment – to go from here to the University of Minnesota – well –‘ I nodded an acknowledgment, and we both stopped in front of the cleaning closet. “Well,” he chuckled, “In we go – brave enough to follow me?” I could never resist Trey’s dares – hence the socks, hence the cemetery. I lifted my chin and followed him. Automatically, the door clicked shut behind us. It was dark, and I fumbled for the light. A hand covered mine. “Kristen,” Trey’s voice was different – the way it used to be, when we lay panting in the back of his car, or sweating in the hay mow of my family’s barn – “I’m sorry – I never should have – I mean – I don’t know what to say – I really miss you. I thought, somehow, I was going to go – be this Big Man on Campus – and – I just really miss you. I’m sorry.” My breath was coming in quick gasps, but I tried not to show it. “No big deal – it’s okay – We did have a good time, though, didn’t we?”
Trey’s hand lifted from the light switch, and he turned me towards him. We faced each other, there in the darkened broom closet, in the church of my youth. “Oh, Kristen,” he moaned, and his hands were on my neck, in my hair, traveling down and under my thick winter sweater. His hands traced my nipples, then bit them with a pinch. “Trey,” I breathed, stepping back, “They’re going to expect us back – they’re going to come looking . .” Trey stopped me with a deep kiss, then leaned against me, towards the door, and locked it. “Trey,” I said, “Have you done this before?” He laughed, and I hoped those upstairs couldn’t hear, “Do you think I would tell you?” After his stumbling apology, Trey’s devilry was back. He leaned against me, in control, and I felt the doorknob press into the small of my back. I shifted forward, and found myself pressed against Trey’s thin, muscled body. I could feel the thick hardness of his cock, and groaned in spite of myself. Trey’s tongue was in my mouth, probing, and I could taste the familiar cinnamon of Big Red. Trey’s hand traced my cheek, my neck, then moved down to my jeans – the zipper echoed, a gunshot almost, in the cleaning closet, “Trey,” I said, “Shh,” he responded, “We’ll make it quick – tell them we couldn’t find the mop,” “But Trey,” I said, even as I felt my cunt getting wetter – wet enough, in fact, to mop a floor, “My mom –“ “Your mom loves me,” he said, and that was true enough. His long fingers entered my open zipper, probing my thick hair and my wetness. I could feel his smile against my hair, “Still doesn’t take you long, huh Kristen?” “Nor you,” I responded, and unzipped his jeans to release his pulsing cock – purple, hard, crying for attention. He moaned softly. I took his cock in my hands, moved my fingers up and down, reached for his balls. His head went back, and I grabbed the opportunity, leaning over to take his shaft in my mouth, his balls cupped in my hand. His groan was loud. I put my finger on his lips.
“I have to have you,” he mumbled. “Here?” I asked, wondering about logistics. “Right now, there seems no better place.” I chuckled. “It’s going to have to be quick.” “I know,” he groaned, “Unfortunately.” He yanked my jeans down, almost a violent gesture, and I tripped forward. Trey caught me, leaned me back against the locked closet door, his cock thrusting towards me, insistent, unafraid, not intimidated by the church, the church altar, the church closet, the church ladies, upstairs chattering like busy field mice. I looked up, saw the dark of the closet ceiling, held tight to Trey’s neck. His pants were down to his knees, and his cock jabbed towards me. I spread myself, wanting him inside again, wanting to feel that thick, hard cock opening me the way it used to. I reached for him, guided his cock into my wetness. As always, the passage was easy, and I stifled my gasp as his cock reached its limit. I leaned against the closet door, my eyes closed. I saw myself, tied up, laughing at Trey’s feather torture – and then Trey, tied up as I scraped my nails down his chest, down his thighs. I felt the grave underneath us, the dank soil as we scrabbled madly against each other. I saw the Crucifix, Christ agonizing in perpetuity, the velvet of the altar robes, heard the moaning of the priestly ritual. All of it melted together, somehow, in kaleidoscopic colors – so appropriate, so wonderful. I tried not to yelp as we got there – Trey first, me shortly thereafter. I could feel the warmth of his semen as it spurted inside of me, spilling, in its old delicious pattern, down the insides of my thighs. I wanted to laugh, but couldn’t –
“Trey? Kristen?” It was Betty’s croaking voice, carrying down the church stairs, “What’s taking you so long?” We zipped hurriedly, and Trey quietly unlocked the closet door, opening it slowly, stealthily. “We couldn’t find the mop, Mrs. Peterson – but we have it now.” “Oh good,” Betty answered, seemingly oblivious. “And the Soilax?” Trey looked around him, grabbed a box and a mop and yelled, “Got it – it was just behind a bunch of other stuff.” “Okay,” Betty called, “Come on up and we’ll finish this off.” Trey and I returned to the church proper, mop and Soilax in hand. Together, we mopped the floors, sometimes exchanging jokes and college stories, sometimes just looking at each other and laughing. When we finished, Trey grabbed my hand. “Can I ask you out – while you’re here?” I laughed, feeling the old blush creep from my tits to my face, “Of course.” “I’ll call you.” He smiled and followed his mother out, the church floor gleaming under his path.
Mom and I walked out together. “Well, that wasn’t so bad, was it?” She asked, stopping to zip one of her clunky, winter boots. “No, “ I said, “Not bad at all.” “And I’m so glad,” she gave me a sideways glance, “That you were able to talk to Trey again – I always thought he was such a nice young man. I hope you’ll see him while you’re home.”
“Well, Mom,” I smiled, “Maybe I will.”