Chapter 1
"Mmm. That feels nice," Riley whispered as he pushed hard against her.
"Are you sure you're okay with this? I don't want you telling me this was a mistake again tomorrow."
"We just can't go any further, okay?"
Colton Bradley stopped dry humping her and Riley asked, "What's wrong? That felt really good. You don't have to stop."
"Riley? I don't deal well with mixed signals. We're both in our '20s and yet we go through this...this...dance...every night."
"So what are you saying, Colt? You don't want to do anything?"
"I think you know exactly what I'm saying. The real problem is you don't want to listen to yourself and visualize what you're not saying."
Riley sat up and said, "I resent that. I really like you. You're the first guy I've dated since my divorce and I enjoy making out with you. I know what we were doing beyond that is wrong, but sometimes I just..."
"Sometimes you just...what? Finish your sentence this time, Riley."
Riley huffed. "You're exasperating! You know how important the Church is to me. We can't have sex outside of marriage. Period. We can't even pet, so this is as far as we can go. If you don't enjoy it then maybe we should..."
"Should...what? Come on. You know what's going on here. I see it and I admit you. You see it and claim you have no idea. For someone who's been married and divorced twice 
before she's 28, you can sure be clueless."
"I don't like being talked to that way. I think maybe you need to leave. "
Colt picked up his jacket and said, "No, you don't like being talked to like that. You don't like being talked to that way because you like men who won't tell you the truth. You seek out men who are gutless. You want someone you can control. You want everything on your terms but that's where you run into trouble because you can't ever have what you really want on your terms. You can only get a shallow, hollowed-out, low-rent version of it that way."
Riley stood up and pointed her finger at Colt. "I will not be spoken to like that in my own home!"
Bradley walked over to her, stood inches from her face and said, "Right. Because if I finish saying what needs to be said, you'll have to deal with the fact that you're a hypocrite of the highest order. You want to live this sweet, quaint, perfect life in public but deep down you're a boiling cauldron of unfulfilled needs and desires. You want me as much as I want you, but you use the Church and your so-called values to push real men like me away. And that's what causes you to pick shrinking violets like Mike and Tommy then throw them away after a couple of years when you realize they're not enough. And here's the real kicker, Riley. It's gonna take a real man to put up with your shit and willingly give you what you really want. The other thing you can't see is that I'd gladly let you have it all if you'd make some changes for me so we could both get what we want. But your pride and your phony veneer—this...social mask you wear...keeps you locked in this prison of your own device. So you'll move on until you find another weak man to marry you and then once you've gotten it of your system—legally—via marriage—you'll divorce him and start the whole sick, twisted process over again!"
Riley was trembling with rage. "You don't know anything about me! You don't know who I am or what I want. You think you're so smart and that you know more than anyone else. Well, you don't! I know exactly what I want! And I don't need you or any other man to tell me what it is or how to get it! Now get OUT!"
Colt turned and said, "That's where you're wrong. While you do know exactly what you want, you DO need me to get it because no other man would bring home the very thing his loving wife most wants and needs without complaint because he knows that's exactly what it takes to make her life complete. And if you weren't so...so goddamned self-righteous, you'd admit it and drop this bullshit facade you play with the Church and your mom and..."
Riley's anger spilled over into pure frustration. Tears of rage fell as she screwed up her face and said, "I HATE you! You get the HELL out of my house and leave me alone!" She turned on her heels and headed for the safety of her bedroom where she would spend another night by herself crying. All alone—again. The weight of the sadness would once again crush her. But her pride would not allow her to give in. There was no way she was going to let Colton Bradley know he was right because doing so would cause the facade to fall, opening new wounds almost as painful as the kind she now willingly bore.
"I feel sorry for you, Riley. I'm the one guy whose understands you and who'll give you everything you need, but you're too damn stubborn to admit it. So in six months you'll be engaged to some other pantywaist and two years later wonder why the hell your third marriage didn't work, either," Colt said as he closed the door behind himself and walked out.
On his way home, Colt tried to shake the whole thing off, but he knew that wouldn't happen that quickly. He needed to process what was going on and see if maybe he really had made a mistake. Something told him he was spot on, but he tended to avoid conclusions based on emotion or gut feelings. Logically, he was convinced he had this right.
Riley Peterson was very attractive. A little too thin for some but if that didn't bother a guy, she was a babe in all other respects. Okay, maybe her boobs were a little on the small side, too, but her face was downright beautiful and her eyes were...what? Captivating. They were a deep, warm brown and so...alive. Her lips were soft and full and her smile was amazing. Her coffee-brown hair was silky and shiny and frankly, looked like something out a commercial for a top-of-the-line shampoo. And the way she dressed, even for a modest Mormon girl, slayed him.
Bradley was quite sure she would be hot in bed. He couldn't get her to talk about sex directly, but from the hints she gave, he knew she enjoyed it—a lot. Hell, she'd been married to two younger guys for two years each in a six-year period. The first was Mike Cummings who was just 18 and right out of high school when Riley married him. She'd just finished college and was working as an RN. Mike was good looking, well built, and very quiet. Just the kind of guy Riley could have her way with then discard when she needed someone new. After a short break waiting for her uncontested divorce to finalize, she met Tommy Ziegler, who was nearly a clone of Mike. Riley loved to dress her boy toys up in sweater vests and corduroy pants with wing-tip shoes and braces and monogrammed button-down shirts with cuff links. Being just 20 years old, he was all too willing to do anything he could to make his very pretty, older wife happy. But that was the problem. Riley could never be happy with any guy she could control and making matters worse was her need to stay within the gene pool of the Mormon Church.
Her daddy, as she called him, wasn't a Latter-day Saint. It was her mom who'd raised her in the Church in Roanoke, Virginia, along with her two sisters, Gloria and Marlis. All three of the Peterson girls were very cute and all three had married young and divorced. Riley was just a step ahead of her younger sisters in terms of the body count.
The problem for Riley was that membership in the Church presented her with a dilemma she couldn't solve. On the one hand, she really, really liked sex but she couldn't settle for just one man for life. Enter her love affair with serial monogamy. On the other hand, she couldn't have sex except with a man who was her husband and her husband had to be a Mormon. Then there was another issue which factored into the equation of craziness. Riley only dated guys who were younger than herself. And a lot younger where possible. Colt knew this because he personally knew two guys in their mid-thirties who'd asked her out. Both had been turned down. One was a very good-looking, successful attorney whose wife had died from breast cancer. The other was a real-estate agent who been divorced for several years. Both had money, looks, and a real love for the Mormon faith. They would have ideal for a woman like Riley—unless there were deeper motives in play. Colt was sure there were.
Then there was his own experience with Riley. He was just 21 himself and recently returned from a two-year Mormon mission to Moscow, Russia, when she'd asked him to take her to a church function during the Christmas holiday. While on his mission, he'd begun having doubts about the Church and even whether or not there was a God. His parents weren't LDS so he had no family support structure to reinforce his flagging faith. He was reasonably certain Riley's faith was also very shallow underneath the thin veneer she claimed as miles deep, but she'd never admit that. Maintaining that faith in front of her mother and other friends in their social circle was important not so much because she really believed it, but because it was...expected. It was...comfortable. Besides, disappointing her mother was something Riley couldn't even contemplate. So she repressed her deepest needs and flailed around chasing after them the only way she could. Through a series of legal marriages with cute, younger men.
Colt was young, but he was very good at assessing people. Each day he spent with Riley, the more certain he became as to who she really was and what she really wanted. And the truly frustrating thing was that the very same thing was happening with himself. He was slowly peeling back the proverbial onion and each new layer confirmed what he felt. He didn't believe all this "modern-day prophet/God was once a man-man can become God/Book of Mormon" nonsense. The Book of Mormon had over twenty chapters of one book directly stolen from the Bible! They were even "translated" by Joseph Smith in the King James version of English spoken in 1611! They were lifted word for word from the Book of Isaiah in the Bible but no one cared. The Mormon temple ceremony was stolen directly from the Masons by Joseph Smith and Brigham Young who were both...wait for it...master Masons! The whole thing was such a crock of...shit.
Riley was six years older than him but he had a far better grasp on reality in general, and on her needs in specific, than she did. He was now sure that what Riley needed but refused to admit, was the love of a man who understood her needs and would make it possible for her to be happy and fulfilled and stay married to one man. As long as they lived far enough from Roanoke to hide her new life from the prying eyes of her aging, invalid mother, she could live the life she wanted but keep up the front of being a good Mormon girl. Riley's mom was too frail to travel so all she'd need do is be um...creative...when they talked on the phone or via Skype.