"Cheers."
"I'll drink to that."
Carol and I were enjoying the afterglow of a fabulous meal in our favourite restaurant, Scalini. A favourite restaurant that we hadn't found the time to visit for two years, before tonight.
We were fixing up our marriage, and tonight was just another step along the road where we were burying our axes and getting to know each other again.
What had happened to us?
We met at University, one of the best in England, and immediately we were an item. We were almost too alike; both from relatively humble backgrounds and trying very, very hard to make the most of ourselves. We were out of our league, frankly, but both successfully punching way above our weight.
After graduation we both found good jobs and soon we were married. The next 15 years were a blur. It's true what they say: life is what happens to you while you're making plans.
And we were always making plans: promotions, new jobs, bigger houses, flashier cars. Somewhere in there we also managed to have two kids.
Outwardly, we were everyone's definition of success. We had it all: the architect designed house in the best neighbourhood in town; high profile careers; beautiful kids in an excellent private school. In our own small way, we were Ben Affleck and Jennifer Lopez, people thought of us as a unit, our own small town 'Bennifer' if you like.
Outwardly, we were the golden couple of our circle, but, inside the bubble, all was not well. Maybe it was our backgrounds, but it was beginning to seem like we just tried too damn hard at everything; I was getting tired.
The last few years had been particularly harsh. Carol had went into real estate after University. Eventually she realised there was serious money to be made and she started up her own firm with three like-minded colleagues. I had made partner at my law firm and was aggressively trying to make the board.
At first everything was fine, Carol and her partners were all great sales people and really hard working: they got the deals and closed the sales. It was at the back end where it all fell down. They were all sales people, none of them was interested in the administration, finance or legal stuff. Soon the business was in a hell of a mess.
For a while there the bank had our house as a guarantee on the company overdraft, and things got very tense at home. We started to fight.
Eventually one of the big national companies bought them over. They could see that under the mess the business was actually sound. Their offer was enough to pay off the debt, release the security on the house and pay for a good holiday. Carol also got some equity in the firm and was kept on as manager on a pretty decent salary.
Deep breaths all round.
It had been a salutary lesson, but thankfully not a fatal one. The ideal time to take stock.
So here we were at Scalini, toasting our new, less stressful future. We had sworn to take it down just a notch on the career front, make more time for ourselves and the kids; have fun, basically.
But Carol was on a mission. She really wanted a completely fresh start and insisted that we tell each other the truth about the last few years. I knew exactly what she meant: it was confession time.
And I was first up, apparently.
This is not something you should try at home. Normally I think you should let sleeping dogs lie, keep your mouth shut and your guilt to yourself. But there was something in the air, or in the cognac, and I found myself telling all.
Yes, there had been that girl at the convention a few years back. Actually there had been a few. I sat back and let it all out. To be honest, it didn't seem that much when you actually listed them. A few indiscretions, far away and unimportant.
Then Carol dropped her bombshell: "What about Annie, James?"
Annie was a fellow partner at work: early 30's slim, elegant and blonde.
And single.
Exactly the sort of woman most wives would hate their husband to spend too much time around. I had spent about 12 hours a day for the last five years around Annie.
I could have bluffed it, but this would be the only chance I would ever have and, as I said, there was definitely something in that cognac.
"It was nothing..."
Carol arched an exquisitely shaped eyebrow: "That means there was something."
I sighed: "Yes, there was something."
So I poured it all out. Carol and I spent a lot of time together, that much Carol knew. There had also been a mutual attraction that was hard to miss at company functions and so on. But, two years ago, things developed further.
Carol and I were in separate worlds, if not quite separate beds yet. Annie was single and beginning to feel her biological clock ticking. Then we were up in London, working together on a case. We had to stay overnight. It was such a clichΓ© it made me blush in the retelling: unhappily married man in his mid life; beautiful younger single colleague; a hotel.
I think we both knew all of that day. There had been a chemistry between us, a spark; embarrassed glances that hadn't been there before.
We ate in the hotel restaurant, and after a few drinks in the bar we simply went up to her room. I don't think Annie even asked me in. It just happened.
We were all over each other as soon as the door closed, and then we were on the bed, clothes being parted, unzipped or simply thrown to the floor. What I remember most of all was the absence of awkwardness, or guilt. What we were doing was good, joyful even.
Then I was inside her, our bodies slicked together with our sweat, lubricating our movements, my thrusts. She was a beautiful lover and we fit together like two pieces of the same jigsaw. This was different from any past indiscretions, something more. Some thing like, love?
We sensed each other's timing instinctively, and our bodies synchronised, calibrated and we rose from our passion to come together.
Afterward, the heat in the room made us languid, like sunbathers on a tropical island. I realised also there was something in the room with us: opportunity. Our lives had reached a crossroads and we could both look down the different roads. One way had us together, my divorce, our marriage, a different life. Another road had us return to our old lives, her single, looking for the right guy; me back at home, with Carol.
I could tell she sensed the moment too, just as I could feel her, like me, turn away from our path together.
We weren't embarrassed strangers, suddenly coping with the aftermath of our intimacy, we were friends. Good friends, with, I think, something like genuine love between us. But it wasn't enough. I think I loved Annie, but I wasn't 'in love' with her. She wasn't in love with me. I was in love with Carol.
Then, just as imperceptibly as it opened up, that other path, our path together, blinked out of existence. We never saw each other like that again. But we remained friends, pulled closer by something shared, and worked together again often.
I told all this to Carol, sat there in the restaurant. If that sounds cavalier, I can only say it felt like an 'all or nothing' situation. We had been living a lie. If we were to achieve the life together we both wanted there could be no deceit beneath the foundations.
I was finished. For a long time we just sat there in silence.
"Is that all?"
"Yes."
"No-one else, James? no more secrets?"
"No." I didn't have to think too hard.
More silence.
"I'm glad you told me that."
"Why?"
"Because I knew." Eh?
"Eh? How? What.....?"
How the hell did she know?
"She told me once, Annie, not exactly, but enough."
"How the hell did she do that?"
"Remember the party at Adam's last year?"
I remembered it well. It was about six months after Annie and I had been together in London. The first time she and Carol had been in the same room since. I was tense, Annie was nervous and drank too much: not like her at all. In the cab home I thought it had been a close thing. I had been wrong.
"You two were like cats on a hot tin roof, jumping around the room and avoiding each other. When Annie went to the ladies I followed her. You were at the bar with Adam."
She was right, I hadn't noticed them.
"In the loo we were putting on some lippy when I caught her eye in the mirror. She was like a rabbit caught in the headlights. I said: 'Did you enjoy London then?' She looked horrified, then in a small voice she said: 'I'm sorry.' turned, and walked out."
"I had no idea, I'm sorry."
"Everyone's sorry."
"So....."
"Was there ever another time? Seriously James"
I was glad I had been honest.
"No. Never."
"Okay."
"Okay?"
"Not 'okay,' but, you know, let's go on.
I was very eager indeed to 'go on'.
"I'm all done. It's your turn."