Part 1
I sat on the couch scrolling on my phone mindlessly, the clock just hit 7 so I got up and went to look for Sienna since we couldn't just sit inside all day.
"Sienna? Sienna?" I called getting a bit louder the second time.
I checked everywhere and soon found her looking through shelves in the cupboard of the spare room where we stored some of our stuff.
"What are you looking for?" I asked wondering what she was doing in here for so long. She got down from the stall she was using to reach the top shelf and dropped to my level.
"Oh I was just cleaning up a little in here, we really should keep the apartment tidy y'know." She told me nearly going off on a rant before I stopped her.
"Ok ok, spare the lecture." I replied interrupting her. She looked up at me and tilted her head to my witty attitude.
"I was going to ask whether you wanted to go out tonight to eat, it's getting a little later and I can't be bothered to cook." I said making my point to her. She kept looking at me for a second, considering her options before replying.
"I'm not really hungry if I'm honest, you can go if you want but I'm just going to stay in tonight." She answered, genuinely allowing me to go out.
I also considered what to do, it wouldn't be as enjoyable with just me so I shook my head and we both agreed to stay in tonight.
"I'm just going to finish up cleaning here and then we can get takeaway, sound good?" She said as she got back up on the stall to put the remaining things away on the shelf.
I nodded in agreement but really looking at her ass which was right in front of my face since she was on the stall. I stared for a minute before she gave me a playful slap to stop staring.
"Someone's eager huh?" She asked jokingly. I snapped out of it and looked back up to her seeing a playful look on her face. Maybe she wanted to be the takeaway?
"Do you really want takeaway, or do you want..." I couldn't finish before she leaned down and started kissing me passionately, hugging my head as she lead me to the bed.
She put her finger on my lips taking control of the situation before pulling out a condom to be safe. We always fucked with a condom even though she was on birth control, she said it was safest anyway which I couldn't argue with. She pulled my pants down and put the condom over my rock hard cock.
She lifted her legs up and took her pants off, inviting me inside. I took the invite and pushed my cock into her making us both moan in ecstasy. I wasn't the biggest, only just 5 inches but she always said it was enough even though she didn't orgasm lots from it.
We fucked passionately for a good few minutes before I started needing to cum. I gestured to her not able to talk in this moment of pleasure. She waited a couple seconds before she pushed off of my cock and ruined my orgasm which made me start cumming in the condom slowly and painfully in comparison to what her pussy felt like.
She started laughing and couldn't hold it back, I was so let down wanting to cum in her pussy so badly but it wasn't to be. She waved a single finger at me, teasing me even more.
She pulled out a big dildo and finished herself off with it before we both lay there on the bed staring up next to eachother.
"That's very mean you know, ruining my orgasm and then pulling out a big dildo to use for yourself." I told her a little less annoyed now, not that she cared.
"Does it make you feel small?" She teased playfully, waving her pinky at me mocking my cock size while laughing again.
"It's just inconsiderate, that's all." I said jokingly taking the moral high ground. Her words did hurt, I thought she liked my cock but I guess not. It was pretty embarrassing seeing her fuck a bigger dildo and moan way more with it than when we fuck together but that's just the way it is.
"Really though, you like my cock, right?" I ask looking for confirmation that I'm enough for her.
"I wouldn't say I like your cock, but I do tolerate it Tyler." She said making her point. It did hurt hearing that but it sounded like the truth.
"I know you don't like hearing about my exes but they did have bigger cocks, and it does make a difference." She added, telling me the harsh truth.
We both lay there after that, unsure what to say to eachother. After a minute or so she got up and walked out of the spare room, leaving me in there alone.
"Make sure the sheets are clean in here, I don't want anything on them staining." She instructed me all of a sudden being a little more harsh on me after our chat.
I did as I was told and checked the sheets after I put my clothes back on like she did too. As I finished up checking the sheets and making the bed again I could hear her sighing and sounding annoyed out in the kitchen. I closed the door and left the spare room to go and see what's up with her.
"You alright, sounds like there's a problem." I ask trying to make her feel better. This causes her to turn and sit down at the kitchen table. She looks like she's about to spill her life story out.
"Well. I feel quite bad saying this but it has to be said at some point." She starts leaving a gap to think about her words carefully.
"I really love you Tyler, I wouldn't want to be with anyone else and I want to marry you one day. But we need to do something about our sex life, it's alright but I just don't get the satisfaction that I'm craving. I know it isn't your fault and I'm sorry for making it seem that way but I need that extra something, you know?" She says indeed spilling it all out onto me. I take a seat aswell as she looks at me for a response which I have to find somewhere in my mind.
"Ok, I understand where your coming from and I also with I had a bigger cock." I said the truth not beating around the bush.
"I also love you loads and want to marry you too, I'd never break up with you Sienna. But I don't see what else we can do to improve this. I can't just grow a bigger cock, can I?" I finished, telling her the whole truth. I could see she was thinking of something but I didn't dare ask unless she wanted to say.
"Well, there is something that could begin to help." She started again, I was weary about what she was going to say but I stayed silent and let her continue.
