It was one of those dreary, rainy mid April days common in northern Pennsylvania. I was sitting on the couch, nursing a beer, and watching my favorite hockey team lose another important game. I remember thinking that if this trend continued, there would be no post season this year. It was at that time that my wife entered the room. She stood for a moment, looking at me, and then picked up the remote, and turned off the television.
She looked at me, and then took a seat opposite where I sat, and then the silence began. Over our ten years of marriage, I knew her tells by now, and knew that something was bothering her, and she was trying to figure out how to tell me what it was. I also knew that she wasn't mad, because if that was the case, she would have had no problem starting in on me the minute she entered the room. I also knew not to try and pry it out of her, and just wait for whatever she had to say.
After a long moment of silence, she looked at me, and timidly said, "I want to start seeing other men."
Not being completely certain that I heard her correctly, I said, "What?"
After more silence, she said in a firmer voice, "I want to start seeing other men, and when I say seeing, I mean sex, and I don't want to do it behind your back."
This time I heard her clearly, and my genius of a brain could only spit out, "Huh?"
"Why are you making this so difficult?" she asked.
"Difficult? Me? I'm not making anything difficult. I'm just trying to process what you're telling me dear." I said.
"Oh... I'm sorry. I'm just very nervous about talking to you about this."
She was nervous! What about me? Hearing something like that coming from my wife had me filled with a mixture of emotions. Most of which I didn't have time to understand or make sense of. I just looked at her with that deer in the headlights look. She must have thought I was an idiot. Before I could say another word, she continued.
"I know this is a shock and a surprise to you, and I know you must be upset, but please let me try to explain." She said.
"I don't know what there is to explain. You just waltzed in here and told me you don't love me and you're going to have an affair." My anger was starting to rise, which was not a good thing.
"I didn't say that I don't love you, and I'm not going to have an affair!" She replied. "Well... not right away anyway. And stop putting words in my mouth! You do that all the time! I don't want this to be an argument. I want us to discuss this like reasonable adults! Can't we please do that?"
"Sure, sure." I said sarcastically. "Let's reasonably discuss my wife fucking another man, and making me a cuckold. Or, is it different if I know you are doing it?"
"This doesn't have to go this way. If you would just let me explain my reasons, then we could come to an agreement, and move forward." She said.
I took another long drink of my beer, and took a deep breath and waved my hand, as if giving her the floor.
She looked a little more confident as she spoke. "I've felt that we have been growing apart these past months, and I'm not saying that's your fault. I don't believe it's mine either... I guess it's just something that happens between married couples after awhile."
"I have felt the distance too, but I assure you, an affair is not the answer." I calmly said.
"Will you please let me finish? If you keep interrupting, I'll never get this out. It's not easy for me you know." She said.
"Ok, I'm sorry. Please continue." I said knowing the sarcasm was coming through again.
"The drifting apart is not the only thing that's been bothering me, but it has added to what I'm feeling. It goes back to when we got married. I was a virgin and you were not. Remember?" she said.
"Yes, I remember, but what's that got to do with anything?" I asked.
"You had the chance to be with other women. I have never been with anyone but you, and before you say anything, I'm not blaming you for that. It was my choice to be a virgin on our wedding day, and it doesn't matter that you had women you were intimate with before we knew each other. That's not what this is about. It's just that, now, I've been thinking and wondering what it would be like to have a different lover, and it's something that I want to experience." She said.
"I don't know what to tell you. I would've married you if you were a virgin or not dear, so I don't see what relevance that has now. You're a married woman. Do you want a divorce?" I replied.
"No. I do not want a divorce." She emphatically said. "I love you and want to grow old with you. You're the man I want to spend the rest of my life with. You're not understanding what I'm saying to you. This is not something that you can fix and just forget about. I am going to do this, and I am begging you to please understand and eventually be OK with it."
"Well, if you love me like you say you do, and you don't want a divorce, then what else is there to talk about? I'm not going to be OK with my wife screwing other men for any reason." And with that, I chugged the rest of my beer, and walked out of the house.