NOTE: This story contains elements of cheating / Netorare, if that's not your cup of tea, stop reading here.
Sage's heart raced in her chest. None of this felt real, she wondered if it was a dream. David was standing in front of her, his cock still wet from her juices, staring at her like a deer in headlights. Her disposition wasn't much better. She had let him fuck her raw, she had lost control. This wasn't how the night was supposed to go. She was supposed to have her fun with Theo, not fuck David behind Jeremy's back.
Sage's heart sank, she had forgotten about Jeremy.
Jeremy was downstairs still waiting for the videos. Panic began to wash over her as a million thoughts pooled in her mind. She wondered how long David and her had been missing, or if Jeremy had seen him at the party. Sage took a deep breath, none of that mattered right now. She had to stay focused and make sure David would behave.
"So... what the fuck happens now?" David asked nervously. "You plan on blackmailing me with that footage?"
Sage was relieved to hear shaking in David's voice. As of this moment, he was scared, and that was precisely what Sage had hoped for. David needed to believe that Jeremy was ok with what had just happened. She took a deep breath, smiling as she calmly walked past David.
"What's next is pretty simple, you're going to learn your place and become a well-behaved bull. You should consider yourself lucky, I really was debating never letting you fuck me again. But so long as you do what I say when I say it... our relationship can continue." Sage opened the linen closet and took out a towel, wiping away a stream of cum dripping down her leg.
That's when it finally started to sink in, what she had actually done. Guilt ripped through her heart and burrowed into her stomach. She had cheated. Sage's mind immediately blocked the invasive thought.
No, this wasn't cheating, was it? After all, she loved every minute of it... and Jeremy would have to.
She turned to David and smiled. "From now on, you do as you're told. Right now, for example, I'm going to tell you to fuck off and go home, and you're going to obey me." David sniffed and nodded slowly. It was clear that he was beginning to regain his senses. This wouldn't be as easy as Sage had hoped.
"And what happens if I don't?" David asked.
"I think you know." Sage shot back. David shook his head.
"No, actually, I don't think I know. You're going to, what, send that video out for the world to see? You're going to accuse me of raping you, is that it?" David took a step forward. Sage's heart raced as he stopped right in front of her. She did her best to look up and remain calm. This was so much easier when they were both craving each other. The once warm embrace of tempting attraction had been swallowed whole by cold waters of fear and guilt.
"That's the gist of it, yeah," Sage replied. David scoffed.
"You know what I think Sage?"
"What?"
"I think that you're full of fucking shit." David pressed into Sage, slamming his hand into the wall behind her. " I think that Jeremy doesn't have a fucking clue about what just happened. And I think that video is your way of keeping my mouth shut."
Sage opened her mouth to speak, but the slight hesitation in her voice was all David needed to know he was right. He grinned, it didn't matter what she said now.
"That's what I fucking thought. So let me make something clear," David leaned in, his lips inches away from Sage, she stared with unflinching eyes. "You're going to delete those videos, or I'm going to tell Jeremy what we got up to."
"If you tell him, I'll release the videos and destroy you publicly." Sage shot back.
"Well, at least now I know I was right. That poor fucking bastard has no clue you cheated on him." David chuckled and stepped away from Sage, walking over to his pants and picking them off the floor. "Sage, think about this for five fucking seconds. Imagine I tell Jeremy you and I fucked behind his back, then you retaliate and release your stupid fucking video. What happens next? What exactly do you accomplish? Sure, it might tarnish my reputation a little bit, but that doesn't even come close to the damage it will do to you. You'll lose your job, your family and friends will see you for the cheater you are, and the whole world will publicly shame you for it." Sage felt her entire body shaking, she really thought the video would be enough. She really thought she had beaten David.
"You'll lose your career..." Sage said weakly.
"My career?" David threw his head back and laughed, pulling his phone out of his pants and typing as he spoke. "You think that scares me? I'm retired, and I can remain retired as long as I'd like. If you're going to threaten me, at least lead with the good stuff Sage. Like that fact that I could go to jail, I would've started with that. But guess what..." David walked back over to Sage and grabbed her hair. She let out a moan but didn't fight back. "Even if that happens, even if you destroy me, Jeremy won't believe you. He will know what actually happened. He will watch that video over and over, jacking off his little cock, knowing his ex-wife cheated on him."
