The woman in row three stood up and grabbed her purse. She leaned down, whispered something to her husband, and started to tiptoe down the aisle.
I sighed with relief. They had the wrong theater. I waited for her husband to follow. He didn't move.
Damn it! Just a restroom or concessions trip.
The couple in row three wasn't supposed to be here. The booking app had shown the theater to be completely empty thirty minutes earlier. It was miserably cold out, and this film--some lifeless rom-com made ten years past its prime--had flopped hard.
And yet, there they were.
Interrupting an unofficially-private showing would've been a minor annoyance on any other night, but tonight, it could be a deal-breaker. I couldn't blame them, of course. They had no idea that, five rows behind them in the back of the theater, we had big plans for this room--a practically secluded but just-risque-enough backdrop for a night to remember.
Despite this setback, there were still two things playing in our favor. Two things that could overcome common sense and see this night through. Namely, the two raging cocks on either side of my wife.
The first cock throbbed in Paige's warm grasp. It ached to be stroked again, but she held it still. Her deliberate pacing had us both on edge, but she had 123 minutes to work with, and we would abide by her schedule tonight.
The second cock fought valiantly to escape my pants. It was so stiff that a mere touch would have shattered it. My balls were swollen. Previously unknown parts of my groin ached.
Row-three woman was halfway up the aisle now. I glanced to my right and noticed my wife's hand hadn't moved. "Maybe pause for a sec?" I hurriedly whispered.
"It's fine, she won't notice," Paige whispered back. I took a deep breath and turned towards the screen, watching row-three woman out of the corner of my eye as she inched closer to our row.
Then I noticed something else out of the corner of my eye--the
other
corner. Paige was stroking Adam's dick again. Her forearm moved in unison with his dark green jacket as it bobbed up and down on his lap. Adam exhaled and closed his eyes.
The woman, now identifiable as a middle-aged woman with short red hair, was one row away now, but Paige didn't let up. If anything, she seemed to ramp up the pace. His jacket still concealed the action but was starting to slide towards the floor. Neither of them made any effort to adjust it.
As the woman passed our row and walked out the door, I frantically debated if the screen's flickering lights had been dim enough to conceal us at the end of the row. I doubted it. Paige's movements were noticeable up to her shoulders.
With the woman gone, I looked at my wife with a mixture of panic and painfully obvious arousal as if to say,
"What the hell was that?!"
She shrugged and gave me an innocent half-smile. "I was just looking for something I needed." She slowed her movements, sliding her hand down to massage Adam's balls. "Found it."
Jolts of electricity shot through my dick as it made another desperate attempt to escape my smothering jeans and lunge for my wife, awaiting a turn it knew it wouldn't get. I couldn't imagine a crueler punishment, nor a more blissful night.
-----------------------------------------------
Six years ago, I popped the question.
Not
the
question, but
that
question. I pussyfooted my way into it one night during foreplay, slipping in a joke about a MMF threesome. It went horribly. After nine years of an airtight bond and a very fulfilling sex life, Paige was taken aback, at best confused as to why I would sacrifice our intimacy, and at worst paranoid that this was my backdoor for bringing another woman into the fold. I vowed to shove the idea away forever, a commitment that lasted two weeks.
Hell hath no fury like a penis scorned.
Over time, I tried to fathom a way to communicate that as our relationship matured, I internalized our intimacy differently. Prior feelings of jealousy and possessiveness gave way to the realization that 1) I was indeed the luckiest man on Earth, but 2) Paige was meant for more.
She was the paragon of the hotwife ideal. She wasn't particularly outgoing or extroverted, but that didn't stop her from effortlessly stealing attention. In fact, she could steal the very room she was in. She stole its shadows and hid their secrets behind her dark brown eyes. She stole its textures and weaved them into her long and lush dark brown hair. She stole its light and reflected it back in that perfect smile. She stole its proportions to shape a can't-walk-by-without-grabbing-it ass and equally tempting C cups. Paige
was
the room.
But she couldn't see it. We were both raised in conservative settings that suppressed self-expression and exploration. My work was cut out for me.
After several years of frustratingly dropping hints, giving up, un-giving up, and giving up again, I finally noticed trace amounts of progress. Late night arguments became subtle roleplay. Roleplay became quips at dinner. We bought her first toy, a modestly sized dildo we lovingly (and drunkenly) named "Mr. Big." We started going out more often. She wore more revealing and tight-fitting clothes, occasionally skipping the bra or panties. The focus remained on our incredible bond and renewed sex life, but the dynamic was undoubtedly shifting.
Any time we talked up the fantasy, it was awkward and distant. I was admittedly growing eager for more and tried shifting the conversation to "I know it won't happen, but who would you pick?" She would always name some celebrity or public figure, but she had trouble connecting with the idea, and it usually fell flat within a few minutes. And then, on a red wine-fueled night (which I now recognize as a national holiday), the tide began to turn.
We were closing out at an intimate night at the bar with sex obviously on the horizon. I glanced at Paige across the table. "Who would you pick tonight?"
I expected one of the usual celebrities, but she was quiet for a moment and avoided my gaze. "I thought of someone who probably would."
I froze. "Oh?"
She quickly tried to play it off. "I'm just saying
he
would."
I felt an erection begin to unfold. I tried to lighten the mood. "You can't drop a bombshell like that without details!"
She rolled her eyes and lowered her voice. "Do you remember Adam from my first job?"
I vaguely remembered the name but didn't recall ever meeting him. I desperately wished I had. As the story goes, they had worked in the same department for a few months, and she had recognized very quickly that he was attracted to her. He had been respectful and kept his distance, only occasionally inviting her to lunch, but she knew the way he looked at her left an open invitation.
"So, what did you like about him?" I prodded.
"I don't know. He was handsome, I guess, but I didn't think of him that way at the time." She continued avoiding my gaze. "A few coworkers had the hots for him. He had a fling with one of them." She looked concerned. "I don't want this to change anything."
"Hey, it's just talk! It doesn't change anything," I said. It changed everything. I slipped my credit card back in my pocket and ordered us two more drinks. "I'm just curious what attracted you to him. In the... literature... the hotwife is usually after the young studs. Wasn't this guy older?"
"Yeah, I think he was around 10-15 years older," Paige said with an embarrassed smile. "You asked me who I would pick, theoretically. He just came to mind because he's the only one I can remember showing interest."
"Makes sense," I said. I tried to downplay him a bit. "So, he was kinda the only option."
Paige either didn't hear me or ignored me. "And if we were to hypothetically try this, it would be nice to have an older guy who would be mature about it. I feel like a younger guy would make it about himself and let it go to his head."
"And you don't think he would?" I asked.
"Probably not," she said. "He didn't with Lauren, anyway."
"Lauren? As in, your best work friend Lauren?" I asked.
"Yeah, that was the fling I mentioned," she said. She sipped her cocktail and finally locked eyes with me. We broke into an awkward
"What? I'm not thinking anything. What are you thinking?"
smile.
"Do women talk shop at work?" I asked. "Did you hear many details?"
"Of course," she admitted. "She was really excited about it for a while. Mentioned a few times how he was 'a complete package.' They didn't last too long, he didn't want anything serious. She wasn't happy about how it ended."
"Gotcha," I nodded. I sipped my scotch and tried to suppress my erection. We closed our tab a few minutes later and drove home. Both of us would be lying if we said the sex that night wasn't fueled by a new kind of fire.
-----------------------------------------------
Paige found Adam on social media the next day and showed me pictures. He was reasonably fit, perhaps a few pounds overweight, with messy dark hair. The age gap showed in his salt-and-pepper beard and rugged face. He had moved away for work and still appeared to be single. With each new bit we could gather, the unspoken stars seemed to align.
This was a promising turn of events, if only to add a dose of reality to my headcanon. I was never naive enough to assume Paige was an incubating BBC slut who would snap one day and fuck her way across an NFL locker room, but the Adam fantasy felt real.