The girls came trotting back in response to our call, only slowing to walk hand in hand and pose playfully once they reached us. I gave an appreciative whistle as they did a coordinated bump and grind, earning a grin from Sally and a stuck-out tongue from Plum.
Jim spoke first. "We're going to start with you, Plum. Dave tells me you've never had more than one man at the same time before, and you really should have the chance to see how you like it before you try it on stage. Are you ready to find out what it's like?" She looked surprised for just a moment, then nodded enthusiastically.
I took her hand and pulled her toward the lounge. "Good girl! Since you're prepped for it, we'll start with anal. And we'll spit-roast you like you'll be on stage. Unless you want to try double penetration again with a real cock in both holes?" She smiled, but shook her head "no".
Unprompted, Plum knelt at the edge of the lounge, facing outwards with her mouth at the ideal height for a standing man to take. Her knees were spread wide enough to leave her bottom readily accessible, too. After a quick game of rock-paper-scissors Jim grinned and grabbed a bottle of lube while I walked to her head, my hard cock bumping against her face. She gave me a cheeky grin and kissed it before obediently opening her mouth and sucking me in. I relaxed and petted her head as she began to work.
She may have forgotten how open and vulnerable her position was; I could feel her gasp on my cock head as the lounge shifted under Jim's weight. Though she jerked slightly when he first touched her, he took his time. I watched appreciatively as he slowly trickled lube down her crack and pumped well-lubed fingers inside both her entries a few times. He waited until she relaxed and began to push back against the intruders, adding a second finger in her rear until she adjusted to the larger size, then replacing them with his condom wrapped cock and gently pressed against her ring; after a moment's delay his cock head popped inside, and I watched as he slowly slid forward until he was fully seated.
Neither Jim or I are porn star huge, but large enough. She looked almost impossibly tight, her anal ring clinging to his shaft as it moved. He was taking long, slow thrusts, pulling himself almost out before sliding home once more. Plum had lost focus as Jim moved; I wrapped a hand in her hair and pulled her forward onto my cock to remind her I expected service, too. As she adjusted to the needs of dealing with us both, the quality of her blow job improved slightly, but it was obvious a majority of her attention was focused on the sensations as he slowly, gently, but thoroughly reamed her ass. As he began to drive into her with increasing urgency, I shrugged and did the same β rather than a blow job, it was a messy face fuck, holding her head in place as I slid my cock roughly in and out. Though the sensation wasn't as intense as her normal blow job, her hot wet mouth helped keep me hard as I watched him plunder her ass.
Given Plum's lock of oral focus, I was lagging behind; Jim finished long before I was ready, bellowing his triumph and pulling her butt tightly against him as he buried himself in her ass. After a long, frozen moment, he slumped slightly and withdrew; there was an audible 'pop' as he pulled himself out.
I didn't let Plum slump with him; with a growled "Stay there! I'm next!" I pulled my cock out of her mouth and reached for a condom, rolling it on as I moved onto the bed. I thrust roughly into her leaking pussy a few times to wet it, then moved up. Her asshole was still gaping half-open, allowing me to squirt a dollop of lube directly inside her entrance before I slid my cock inside her tunnel, taking up a steady pounding rhythm that had her body swaying back and forth with my thrusts, moaning in time as I slid a hand down to strum her clit.
Despite my best efforts, I didn't manage to last long enough to her to reach her own orgasm with me; the tight hot sensation of her ass accomplished what her mouth hadn't β within just minutes, I had erupted inside her as well.
Orgasm or not, Plum seemed exhausted; when I released her hips and slid myself out, she let herself slump to the bed, saying nothing but giving a tired smile as Sally brought a washcloth and began wiping her down. Sally's face was tender and protective as she worked; after putting the washcloth away, she returned to the bed, laying next to Plum and holding her tight as they whispered to one another.
Though they exchanged a gentle kiss, it seemed more comforting than sexual, even when Sally shifted to cradle Plum's head against her breasts, and Plum began to suckle on the closest nipple as Sally crooned and stroked her head. I wasn't quite sure how it had happened, but the two seemed to have established a genuine connection, both friends and sometime-lovers. I smiled and bent over to kiss Plum's forehead before taking my own turn at tidying up.
Chapter 33
The two girls stayed cuddled together as Jim and I pulled out food for a quick lunch, never shifting over into overt sex but continuing their low-keyed teasing. When they finally came to join us at the table, I didn't comment but was amused to note that Plum's nipples were both as swollen β and as wet β as Sally's. She gave me a shy smile as she slid onto the bench beside me and laid her head on my shoulder, giving a wordless satisfied-sounding little noise when I pulled her closer.
Lunch was fun. Sally had made a pitcher of the same sort of fruity gin punch I'd had with Flora. None of us were drunk, but both girls were giggly and as cuddly as a pair of kittens, flirting with both of us with an almost innocent-seeming bawdiness. Or β not flirting. They made it cheerfully clear that either of them was happily ready to give all they were offering to whichever of us crooked a finger. And after we finished eating β figuratively β Jim did.
"Dave, I'd like a little one-on-one time with Plum, and I needed to talk with her anyway. Why don't you have Sally show you around for an hour or two? Maybe take some swimming gear and a beach blanket β there's a nice swimming beach at the other end of the island."
I'd already found Sally to be good company. She kept up a string of light banter as she led me along the beach, but she didn't need to try hard to charm me β besides finding her incredibly attractive, I couldn't help but like the person inside the sexy exterior. And it was a sexy exterior β in her own lush way, to me, nearly as sexy as I found Plum herself. I let myself lag behind slightly to enjoy the view; with her shapely bottom, large breasts bobbing slightly with each step, and bare skin a glowing bronze-gold in the summer sun she could have been a centerfold, or a featured pinup model.
Sally halted as we drew up to the beach, waiting as I put the basket of supplies down in the shade and pulled off my shorts. She smiled naughtily as my erection came into view, but shook her head when I reached for her. "Swim first! I want to show you the reef!".
She was serious about it, pulling goggles and snorkels out of the basket, then a couple of pairs of fins. Somehow, wearing them in the water made her seem even more naked. But I reluctantly had to agree she was right β not only were the fish and coral fascinating, half an hour of watching her bare body undulating as we swam underwater had me even more aroused.
Back on the beach, I spread a blanket on a soft, shaded patch of sand before pulling her in for a deep, unhurried kiss. An odd thought struck me β though I'd always thought her a larger woman, she was barely taller than Plum, still probably less than five feet in height. And, despite her fuller curves, not much heavier. She squeaked and giggled as I scooped her up into a princess hold without moving my mouth from her own.
Sally squeaked and giggled again as I lowered her onto that blanket before sliding down and putting her thighs over my shoulders, but it turned to coos, moans, and a final throaty howl as I used my mouth and hands to take her to orgasm. Underneath the salt taste from our ocean swim she was all clean, tangy, delicious woman.
I'd already learned that she was multi-orgasmic; I gave her just a short time to recover before starting again, though this time I stopped before she started her final rush. Sally waited impatiently as I rolled a condom into place and settled down beside her, swinging a leg across me and positioning my cock at her entrance almost as soon as my back touched the blanket. She was very wet, lowering herself without stopping to seat my cock inside her experienced cunt before starting to ride me.
If I hadn't shot a full load inside Plum's tight ass little more than an hour before I couldn't have lasted β besides the physical sensations, seeing her bouncing on top of me as she rode to her second climax was incredibly stimulating. I may love Plum's sleeker curves but still responded eagerly to seeing Sally's ripe heavy breasts swaying as she moved. She smiled happily as my hands went up to palm them, running my thumbs across her wide dark areolas and thick jutting nipples, then moaned as I began to gently pinch and tug. With another howl, she came a second time and began to slump against me; without hesitating, I rolled her over on her back and began my own hard, pounding, drive to completion.