...continued from Episode 1
Last night was one Eric will never forget. Though he witnessed his beautiful young wife fulfill one of his sexual fantasies by undressing and lightly fooling around with an older, attractive man, he also saw those fantasies potentially evaporate before his eyes. Katie made it clear when they got home from Max's penthouse that she wasn't going to do anything like that ever again. Eric was crushed. He didn't know how to cope with such highs and lows in one night. He went to bed with very mixed emotions.
The next morning Eric received a text message from Max, who apparently had an amazing time with Katie.
(MAX) Had an amazing time w/ Katie last night. Looking forward to seeing her again.
(ERIC) Not sure that will happen. She was a bit upset w/ everything.
(MAX) What? What part?!
(ERIC) She said she felt like you were a little rough and demeaning.
(MAX) WHAT?! Get her on a video chat w/ me. Is she there?
(ERIC) She's at work.
(MAX) When she gets back, put me on video w/ her. I'll smooth it all out. Don't worry.
(ERIC) I don't know man, she seemed like she was done with it.
(MAX) She's NOT done w/ it! Just get me in touch w/ her. I NEED those tits again.
(ERIC) Mmm. Very hot to hear that you liked her so much.
(MAX) LOVED her. I wasn't kidding - best tits I've ever seen.
(ERIC) Man, I know it. So hot watching you suck on her.
(MAX) Yeah, I've got a lot more planned for her too, so get me in touch w/ her tonight when she gets home.
(ERIC) Np.
Katie got home late that night after spending some time working out at the gym. She walked into her apartment, and was greeted by Eric, who was on his computer. She grabbed some food that Eric had made, and sat down at the kitchen table to eat. She checked her phone messages, read some news stories from her news feed, and put her dishes in the kitchen sink.
Eric, who was busy on his computer, looked over towards Katie. He typed on his keyboard some, and walked towards Katie with his laptop.
"Hey, so I chatted with Max some today. He feels awful that you didn't have a good time," Eric said to Katie.
"Well, good for Max," Katie responded sorely.
"Well, he wants to apologize to you," Eric said, holding out his laptop.
"Huh? Like now?! Like he's on the computer now?" Katie asked, seemingly annoyed by the bluntness of Eric's action.
"Yeah, he's right here. He's insisting on video chatting with you. Hey Max, Katie's right here," Eric said, speaking into the computer's camera.
"Hey Katie, it's Max. Look, I'm really sorry that you didn't have a good time. Eric told me that I took it way too far. I'm really sorry about that."
Katie, looking annoyed at Eric, responded to the camera, "Well, yes, it was incredibly demeaning of you to call me slut, or talk to me like a dog like that."
"What do you mean?" Max asked.
"Saying 'good girl, Katie', or telling Eric what a great 'cocksucking slut' I was," Kate replied angrily.
"Look, to be very honest with you, I felt a little uncomfortable saying those things too. I was just trying it out to see how you guys would respond. I only did it once, and would never say those things again," Max pleaded.
"And not only that," Katie responded angrily, "but you also were a little rough on my nipples at one point, and I asked you to stop."
"You didn't ask me to stop, you just told me 'not so hard', so I stopped sucking so hard. I didn't think it was that hard, but again, it won't happen again. I promise," Max said to Katie with a regretful tone.
Katie paused and looked at Eric, not sure if she was willing to forgive Max. She was already feeling remorse from joining in Eric and Max's tryst last night. She didn't really feel that what she did was something a "good girl" like her did. Yet she did have a nice time at the bar with Max before going to his penthouse, and felt a nice connection with him overall.
Max, sensing that Katie was on the fence, chimed in once again, pleading his case, "Katie, didn't we have a good time at the bar? I thought we got along well there. It was so nice sitting close to you like I did."
"It was fun, but I felt a little awkward being seen with two men like that at the bar," Katie said to Max.
"Well did you enjoy my place?" Max asked.
"Yeah, it was a beautiful suite, or whatever you call it, but I felt a little strange being watched like that when we were fooling around."
Eric, sensing that Max was starting to find a path to getting Katie back into the "wife sharing" mood, interjected, "You mean, you didn't like me watching you and Max together?"
"No, I felt weird that you were watching us. Like it just felt a little creepy that you were just sitting there getting off on that chair," Katie said to the men.
"Well, I don't have to watch next time, if you want. You guys can be alone, if you feel more comfortable that way," Eric said, frantically trying to find a way to get Katie to agree to fool around with Max again. Eric had long fantasized about Katie being intimate with other men, and was so obsessed with the fantasy, that he found himself excited by all sorts of scenarios with Katie - including her being intimate in a lone setting with another man.
Max started to see some light at the end of the tunnel and made a plea to Katie, "Katie, look, I had a fantastic time with you last night and want to see you again. I can't remember the last time I was around a woman with your beauty and charm. I've been thinking about you all day today. Okay?" Max said, smiling as he tried sweet-talking his way back to Katie. "To be very honest with you, Katie, I'm glad to hear that you'd prefer to have more alone time with me... I'd like more time alone with you too. Okay?"
"You were thinking about me all day?" Katie says back to Max, with a coy smile on her face.
"All day... couldn't stop," Max said. "So what do you say, Katie? Can we try this again this weekend?"
"Fine, but only if Eric is okay with me being alone with you," Katie said to Max, as she looked up to Eric.
Eric, caught off-guard a bit by how quickly the conversation swung around in his and Max's favor, responded awkwardly, "Uh, yeah... yeah, I'd love that! I think it would be super hot for you and Max to spend some time together alone."
"Okay done deal, guys. I'll send you an invite for this Friday night, if that works," Max said.
"Sounds good," Eric replied.
Eric, sensing that his wife-sharing fantasy is hanging by a thread, didn't mention Max's name all week to Katie, only bringing it up Friday morning to remind her to be home at a reasonable hour before heading over to Max's place. Katie got home from work later that day, and the couple made their way to Max's luxurious suite at the top of the city. They pressed the elevator button for Max's suite when they arrived at his building, and swiftly ascended.
Eric knocked on the door and was greeted by Max with a smile. "Hey guys, come on in! Katie, I'm so glad to see you here. I've been thinking about you all week," he said as he planted a confident kiss on Katie's lips in front of Eric.
"No kisses for me, Max," Eric said playfully.