Payback Sex Pt 08

THE STORY SO FAR

Eric had an affair with Alice my wife. For payback I am sleeping with Eric's wife. Mary will decide whether to live with her husband or me.

Last night Mary and I had sensational sex in the Downward Dog position. But post-coital things had gone badly. I had fucked Mary as if she was a prostitute. I had used her as a cum dump.

I thought it was a compliment when I told her "That was the best fuck I've ever had."

I had to apologise for calling Mary "a submissive slut." Eventually Mary was appeased and drifted off to sleep.

I now knew that Mary wanted sex to be acts of mutual love-making.

THE STORY CONTINUES

While Mary was asleep I pondered how quickly my life had changed. My estranged wife was now having exhibitionist sex with strange men. I was sleeping with my friend's wife and I am competing with him for the right to be Mary's partner.

I knew that Eric must have heard us having sex. His bedroom is next to Mary and my bedroom.

I hadn't made love to Mary. I didn't know if I ever could. I heard Eric going downstairs. I knew that me fucking his wife was a cross for him to bear. I wanted to clear the air with him. So I put on my expensive pyjamas and went downstairs.

ERIC'S REACTION

Eric was in the kitchen. He was naked and preparing a fruit tea.

He said "Have you come down to gloat?"

I said "No. I couldn't sleep. But I could use a fruit tea. We need to be friends as well as competitors. You will have your date nights. I know that you and her haven't had sex since your affair with Alice."

Eric said "My wife kissed my cock so lovingly and then went and shagged you."

I asked "Did you hear our post-sex conversation?"

Eric replied "Every fucking word. And I can make love to Mary. Can you?"

I said "That is something I will need to find out. Our current arrangement is..."

I couldn't think of a suitable word.

Eric said "Mary's current arrangement is a pain in the arse. So I sinned and I am paying the price for my adultery. I now know how it feels to be cheated on. I wanted to run out of the house and never return. But I forced myself to listen."

Eric handed over the fruit tea,

Eric continued "My only consolation is that in 18 days time, Mary will make a decision. So I have 5 date nights to win her back. And that's what I intend to do."

I said "On your date nights, if you want to use the master bedroom then I'm happy to use the guest bedroom. And don't worry about needing to come home by midnight."

I don't know why I said that.

Eric said "That's a generous gesture. Hopefully Mary and I will make use of the master bed this Friday."

He asked "Why your change of heart?"

I replied "I'm not sure, I should be angry with you because you fucked my wife. I have just fucked your wife. I should be gloating. The payback sex was sensational, but it wasn't what I expected it to be."

Eric asked "In what way was sex with my wife different?"

I replied "I expected missionary sex, not a female submissive position."

Eric said "Your wife complained that it was always missionary sex. That was a major reason for her wanting to bed me. That and she knew that I was better endowed."

I said "And now my wife is working her way through the Karma Sutra with any man she can find."

I said "I wish I hadn't said anything after having fucked your wife."

Eric winced as I said "after having fucked your wife".

I said "I was clear what I had to do when I learned about you fucking my wife. My reaction was immediate. I initiated divorce proceedings. Although legally Alice is still my wife, psychologically he isn't.

Immediately I heard about you and her rutting I was able to stop thinking of her as my wife. It didn't even hurt that you and her briefly lived in the same house as me.

But now I'm confused. I want..."

Eric interrupted "A woman to make love to, not use as a cum dump."

ERIC UNDERMINES MY CONFIDENCE

Eric had heard Mary and my post-coital conversation

Eric continued "But you're not sure that Mary is that woman, but she's available to shag. And you're not sure that you like cuckolding me."

I replied "Yes to both."

Eric said "So you try to square the circle and make cuckolding me as painless as possible."

I said "That sounds like the theme song from MASH."

Eric asked "That's a pretty random observation. What can possibly connect cuckolding and MASH?"

In reply I sang "Cuckolding is painless, it brings on many changes, and I can take or leave it if I please."

Eric said "Except for you cuckolding is painful."

I said "And it is Mary who will decide, not you."

I asked Eric "What did you feel when you were cuckolding me?"

Eric replied "Don't open that can of worms."

I said "Okay, one question. Which one of our wives gave you the better sex?"

Eric replied "Yours did. When I wank I imagine fucking your wife. But Mary will make one of us a better wife. Hopefully it will be me."

Eric asked "What will you do if Mary chooses me?"

I said "I will look for a woman to make love to, not use as a cum dump. One I love and one who loves me."

Eric said "And you aren't sure that my wife fits that bill. You know she may not be faithful to you."

I said "That's true."

Eric had introduced a fear factor. I could marry Mary and be cuckolded a second time.

Eric said "Mary fits the bill for me. Don't worry you and my wife may yet share the same values. Like going naked."

Eric had won our mini-battle. I felt under pressure to make my next fuck perfect. Yet I didn't know much about Mary.

To be continued