The chapters that follow describe the sexual lives of an attractive and successful young Chicago husband and wife, James and Nora. First they review the erotic aspects of their lives during the early years of their marriage. Then, after careful consideration, Nora enters a relationship with an older man, Adrian Benton, who helps her, and James, fulfill some of their fantasies and who promises to guide them toward further sexual adventures. Some of these will involve Adrian directly; others he will suggest and sometimes arrange. Gradually James, and especially Nora, become more confident and creative as they seize opportunities to satisfy their growing hunger for erotic excitement.
A new sexual relationship?
On a Friday afternoon in early February my wife, Nora, and I spoke not a word during our elevator ride down from Adrian Benton's law office high above Michigan Avenue. The conversation we had just had with Benton left us with a decision that could deeply affect our personal lives, especially the most intimate aspects of our relationship. Benton had asked us to consider his proposal and, depending on our initial reactions, to join him for drinks and dinner at his house in Chicago's Gold Coast neighborhood the next Friday evening. He hoped we would be able to decide on his proposal during the next several weeks, though he hoped it could be sooner.
Nora and I remained quiet on our drive home. As we entered our apartment on North Lakeview Street near Lincoln Park, I broke our silence by asking," Nora, are you leaning to saying no? Or even yes?"
Nora replied softly, "Not a definite no, James, but not yes, at least not yet. What about you?"
"The same," I responded. "We need time to think, and then to speak frankly about our feelings. Maybe we can begin that tomorrow evening if we stay in and cook together. You have told me before that Adrian Benton recently has seemed highly attentive to you. But now I need to know what you are feeling about this."
Nora had hinted weeks earlier that she suspected that at some point Adrian Benton would act on his increasingly evident interest in her. I had not pushed her to describe her feelings or share her reaction to his attentions.
I'm sure that deep into that Friday night Nora was recalling our conversation that day with Adrian, formerly the senior partner at Belknap and Smithers, one of the oldest, most prestigious and best politically connected law firms in Chicago. I was doing the same.
We had arrived at Benton's office promptly at 5:30. He had led us into a small adjacent library and motioned for us to seat ourselves on a small couch. He offered us wine or, if we preferred, a martini. We both settled for red wine.
Benton sat in a leather chair facing us and began the conversation by describing his impressions of Nora and me during our several years involvement with the firm. "Though neither of you is a lawyer you hold unique positions here. In just a few years you both have become quite useful to the firm."
He was aware that I held a Ph.D in economics from the University of Chicago after graduating from Princeton. Benton said, "James, you have used your education and your dissertation research to become an excellent advisor on the firm's own investments and, when we have needed it, as a consultant on investments for selected major individual clients. It has been a pleasure to work with you the past five years."
Benton then reviewed his familiarity with Nora's work as a specialist in art and the art market, managing the firm's own valuable art collections and serving at times as an advisor to wealthy clients regarding decisions on their own art, especially issues regarding provenance and ownership.
He said, "Nora, I know that you grew up in Kansas City, graduated from the School of the Art Institute of Chicago and then acquired an MBA from the Kellogg School at Northwestern." And he added, "I have read your thesis on the financial condition of private art galleries in Chicago. Given how reticent for-profit galleries are to reveal their financial practices and conditions, this must have been a challenging research project. From my experience with galleries as clients and from what I know of your work at the firm, few individuals in Chicago have your insights."
Benton stressed that he had grown to admire not only our expertise but also our our ability as non-lawyers to function effectively within the firm. He said, "I am not the only partner you both have impressed within the firm and more broadly by your energy, confidence, sophisticated good taste and, not least, by your appearance. You are a very attractive couple."
We were flattered by Benton's comments. He was highly regarded in the firm and highly influential in the community. He made clear also that he knew quite a bit more about us, including that in our early months at the firm we had met at one of its summer picnics on Lake Michigan and then were married six months later.
Looking mostly directly at Nora, and glancing at me from time to time me, Adrian Benton explained that he had watched Nora closely at the firm and at various political and cultural events around town over the past four years. "And I have come to regard you, Nora" he said "as a beautiful and highly desirable woman. I want to be very frank with both of you. As I'm certain Nora already suspects, I want to become her lover."
It shocked me to hear him say this so directly, but his proposal was not altogether surprising. In fact, on the way to this meeting I had asked Nora what she thought this meeting was about. She answered immediately, "Mostly, it will be about me. Don't be surprised by that, James."
Benton went on to say, "I find myself constantly thinking of Nora, fantasizing about the two of us together and how it would be to make love to her. I have been unable to get her out of my mind. At 51 I am considerably older than you both. But I am still very vigorous, able to both provide and enjoy intense sexual pleasure, and I seek new ways in which to do so. I need that. And I need Nora."
Benton looked me directly in the eye. "James, you should understand that despite what I have just said, I will not pursue Nora further without your permission as well as hers. I have no intention of breaking up a good marriage or in driving you apart. But I remember when I was about your age, I was 33, after five years of marriage my first wife and I found that our sexual life together was declining, was becoming stale. We did not know how to fix that then and ultimately it drove us apart.
"I don't know if a diminishing sexual life is yet an issue for the two of you. You certainly always appear comfortable and close when I see you together. But what I can help you and Nora find as a couple is a new stage in your relationship, one that offers a variety of sexual experience that will enrich your pleasure individually and as a couple." He explained some of these experiences would involve him but others need not. "While I seek my own sexual pleasure, I also derive satisfaction from observing others and in finding sexual adventures for them beyond my own involvement if that is what they come to desire."
Benton concluded our conversation by telling us that if we were prepared to meet him for dinner at his house the next Friday evening we might begin then to explore the more personal and sexual aspects of a potential relationship. "If this does not go well for all of us," he said, "we should recognize that and go no further. My wife will be away, "he said, "but I would tell her about our meeting beforehand. Janet and I have an open relationship and she would not object, as I do not to her own private arrangements. Each of us at times has suggested ways to bring others into our marriage. "He asked us to let him know on Monday if we would meet with him again.
Following that first meeting with Adrian Benton, Nora and I may have had a preliminary sense of what we would each prefer, but neither was yet ready to reveal it, even tentatively. We needed to consider how such an arrangement might impact our future, individually and as partners. My own thoughts went first to our sexual experiences within our marriage so far, and what I thought I knew by now, or at least suspected, about Nora's deepest sexual desires. But then, did I? And how did I assess the state of our sexual satisfaction?