The sex stories on the site brought back a vivid memory of mine from about five years ago.
My name is Scott. I played college basketball at a Division III (small, non-scholarship) school. After basketball season my senior year the assistant coach - Coach K - was leaving coaching to work in his father-in-law's insurance business. After he was all ready to move he approached me and the three other seniors on the team with a strange proposition.
Coach K had an obsession. He wanted to see another guy fuck his wife. I thought this was really bizarre at the time, but subsequently found out it wasn't quite as unusual as I would have thought. Nevertheless I wasn't judgmental then or now -- I just "rolled" with it!
Coach K's wife, Jill, was childless. She was about 35, dressed like a slut, and probably was one. But she had a cute face, a huge rack for someone her size (about 5'4", 115 lbs.), and a really, really nice ass. Her legs were too skinny for my taste, and I didn't like her hair or makeup, but she was definitely someone I would love to try out in a one night stand.
I don't know the details of how Coach K and his wife came up with The Plan -- I suspect she wanted him to leave coaching to make more money, he wanted to watch her getting fucked, and she wanted to have a say in who fucked her -- but they did. However it didn't surprise me that The Plan had some type of game since Coach K always was devising competitions, whether it be shooting free throws, wind sprints in practice, or, apparently, fucking his wife.
As Coach K explained it to the four of us we would go to an out of town hotel, Jill would be blindfolded, she would feel all four of our dicks and ball sacks limp and then hard, and then guess which dick belonged to which guy. She would then choose one guy from among those that she properly identified to fuck her.
As startled as we were since all four of us were horny 21 year olds who didn't get as much ass in college as we would have liked, combined with peer pressure, we eagerly agreed.
At the appointed day, place, and time, the four of us walked into Jill and Coach K's hotel room suite. Jill knew the four of us well since she attended every game and greeted us with a cleavage-flashing hug after each victory. She had on a long robe so you couldn't see any of her body. She had no makeup and her face looked cuter without it.
Coach K blindfolded her then we all moved to different positions and dropped our pants. She came by and fondled each of us, being sure to trace the full extent of our dicks and balls. Though limp when she started as she fondled each guy he started to harden, but we were told to restrain ourselves to the extent possible.
Then, while still blindfolded, Jill removed her long robe to reveal her naked body. Like soldiers at a flag raising all four dicks instantly saluted. Her tit to waist ratio was greater than any I'd ever seen outside of a porn site, with large nipples and just the right amount of sag to demonstrate that they were natural.
Her cunt was unreal. She had irregular pussy lips sticking out all over her shaved bulge and combined with her skinny legs they defined a perfect love triangle at her crotch. She spun around a few times to display her awesome ass, which looked even more round nude than it did when she was clothed, with a very large and highly visible rose. I forgot all about her ugly hair.
The first guy, Bill, she came up to couldn't contain himself as she was caressing his stiff, and started saying stuff like "holy shit", "what a bod", etc.. Since she recognized his voice, he was disqualified.
The other three of us had distinctly different dicks even though we were all between about 6'4"-6'6" and 200-220 lbs. My dick was/is a little over 6 inches, but at least an inch in circumference larger than the other two. Tom's was about 8 inches and bent very slightly to the left. Jim's was about 9 inches, but the thinnest of the three. After seeing what happened to Bill we were completely silent, although her caressing made that really difficult because she moved her fingers like a pro.
After her virtuoso fondling Coach K asked her to guess who was who. She guessed "Scott, then Tom, then Jim." She got us all right. Now she had to choose; I was both thrilled and scared.
Jill took off her blindfold, walked up to me with a wicked smile on her face and said "you'll do."
Coach K then unceremoniously asked Bill, Jim and Tom to leave. They walked out of the room dejected and looking like they had flag poles inside their pants.
After the departure of the forlorn, Jill asked me if I needed help undressing. While I of course didn't I gladly accepted. As she undressed me I asked if there were any ground rules. Her response was simple: "Fuck me harder, better, and longer than you have ever fucked before, and put cum in my pussy as many times as you can in two hours."