1.Nancy Confronts Her Recent Past.
My wife Nancy and I were totally monogamous for the eight months following her session with Ben and Karl (described in "Nancy and the Produce Man"). Pretending not to be her husband, I'd photographed that session. Afterwards, Nancy and I spent a lot of time looking at the photos together. She was genuinely impressed by them and even thought some of them had artistic merit.
But, like me, she also found them incredibly arousing. As we looked at them, I'd sometimes ask her to describe how it had felt riding on Ben's oversized cock or being ass-fucked by his smaller-cocked friend Karl. She gladly obliged me, going into some detail about how great it had felt as the guys brought her to several huge orgasms. These little talks would invariably lead to great sex.
For some reason, though, she didn't seem eager to repeat anything like what she'd done with Ben and Karl. Hence our lengthy monogamous period. I asked her about this reluctance several times and she answered me evasively, saying she might want to do "something like it one of these days." Meanwhile, she insisted, she was content with having sex only with me.
Or so I thought.
I'd always assumed that Nancy and I told each other everything, or virtually everything. So I was surprised, one Saturday afternoon in early May, to come upon her talking on her cell phone with her back to me to someone in a quieter-than-usual voice. I'd been working on a project upstairs at my computer and had come down to the kitchen to fetch a beer. I guess she hadn't heard me coming.
"Well, I just can't make it today, Ben," I heard her say. A little stunned, I paused in the dining room, just out of sight from where she was standing in the kitchen, and listened to hear more.
"You know I'd like to," she said quietly. "Maybe I can get away later in the week."
This was followed by a long silence. I tiptoed back out of the dining room and into the living room, where I turned on the television to let her know that I was back in her vicinity.
About two minutes later Nancy came into the living room, her cell phone still in her hand, and sat down next to me on the couch. She was blushing slightly and looked gorgeous even though she was dressed casually in a pair of jeans and an old sweat shirt. I pulled her to me and gave her a big kiss, which she returned enthusiastically.
Did she know that I'd just overheard her talking to one of the guys she'd fucked six months earlier? And had I really heard her planning to meet him somewhere?
We necked a little longer before she pulled away from me and looked at me with a serious expression on her face. "Cal," she asked, "I need to know something. Did you overhear me talking on the phone a few minutes ago? I thought I heard you in the dining room."
I kissed her again and admitted that I had. I apologized for listening to her conversation, even if it was only for a few seconds, but assured her that it had been completely accidental. This happened to be the truth.
"Then I suppose I'd better tell you what's been going on," she said with a little sigh. As she looked at me, she took my right hand in hers and squeezed it. Then I noticed tears forming in her eyes.
"Whatever it is," I said to her softly, "remember that I'm always on your side. I love you, but I don't own you. I don't need to know every little detail of your life."
She smiled at me and said, "Maybe I'd better tell you about this 'little detail' before you become too forgiving. I'm afraid it amounts to me being unfaithful to you."
She looked at me closely to see how I'd respond to this confession. I spent several seconds trying to process the word "unfaithful." I'd watched her tease and fuck quite a few guys. I sometimes joined in to fuck her, but usually I'd just watched her in action with them. In all situations (except one) I'd passed myself off as someone who wasn't her husband.
So I was pretty much used to her being unfaithful to me. In fact, her fucking other guys was a big turn-on to me and she knew it.
I asked her to explain what she meant by "unfaithful."
She paused to choose her words carefully: "Well, I guess I mean that I've been carrying on with Ben without letting you know. We haven't had actual sex, but we've been talking a lot on the phone. It started about three weeks ago."
I kissed her on the cheek without saying anything. Then she told the whole story.
"Ben called me, as I said, about three weeks ago. I was home and you were at work. He said he couldn't get me out of his mind, that he thought about me constantly. At first, I put him off. I told him I was flattered but that my life – I mean the imaginary life that he thinks I have -- was still a mess and I didn't want to get into a relationship with anyone right now."
"He asked me where I was living since I'd moved out on my husband 'Bill.' I told him I'd been living with various friends but that, for the last month, you – I mean Cal the photographer – was letting me stay in his guest room. He asked me if he could visit me there, but I told him not to. When I moved some of my stuff into Cal's guest room, it was sort of understood that I wouldn't to have any friends over."
"Then he asked me to come over to his place, a house he shared with two other guys. I told him I'd think about it and rang off."
"But he kept calling me, sometimes twice a day. That's when the talk started to get very sexual. He said I was the sexiest woman he'd ever been with. He kept talking about how good his cock had felt in my mouth and in my vagina. He said he'd loved fingering me and eating me and watching me cum. He said sometimes he jacked off thinking about all we'd done at the photo shoot. He also said he was jealous of Karl when he fucked me in my vagina and then got to fuck me in the ass, too."
"I kept putting him off, though he knew I was becoming excited by the things he was saying to me."