As I stood in our en-suite bathroom and observed myself in the mirror I couldn't help but observe what a state I was in. My whole face covered and glistening with bodily fluids -- as I breathed out cum bubbles formed on my nostrils. I noticed that my eyes were blood-shot. But despite all this and the fact my wife Katie was currently sprawled out satisfied on our bed with another man in the next room, as my eyes wandered down over my smooth waxed torso and stomach, my penis stood aroused at the situation. So how did we get to this point?
Katie and I had been married for about a year. Our sex life up until around two months ago had been completely vanilla -- we'd never tried anal sex and Katie only occasionally went down on me, though I returned the favour much more frequently in return. All that changed two months back when I opened up about a recurring fantasy of mine -- cream pie clean-up. Since my first experience of gulping down my cum from Katie's large labia, Katie had really got into the idea of this and sex now almost always ended with her bringing herself to orgasm whilst grinding my juices into my face.
Then around two weeks ago while laying on the sofa and fondling each other, as we usually did before sex, Katie took her hand from my boxer shorts and turned to face me.
'Honey, I've really enjoyed how we make love now', she whispered.
This turned me on and I motioned her to continue fondling my stiffening penis, but she brushed my hand away.
'And I've been thinking', she continued. 'How about if we took the next step?'.
I frowned - 'what do you mean?'
Katie stayed silent for a moment, and then went on, but no longer meeting my gaze. 'Well I wondered about...about maybe bringing someone else into our love making'.
It took me a while to process exactly what Katie was saying. I was just about to speak when she added
'I was thinking another guy...perhaps someone who could give you an even bigger cream pie to enjoy!'.
As she said this her eyes widened excitedly, and though I felt somewhat shocked at how the conversation had developed, I felt my penis begin to throb as my blood began pumping more quickly in my anxious state.
Katie noticed this too and returned her hand to my shorts to squeeze and stroke my balls. At this point I was already leaking pre-cum.
'Wow seems we have the answer then?' Katie said as she rubbed her thumb across the glistening head.
'Would you like to taste a thick, hot load of cum that someone else has just left for you inside me?'
My eyes closed, I struggled to focus now as Katie used my pre-cum as lube on her thumb and forefinger to tease the head of my cock.
'Yeeees' I whispered, before Katie moved to grip my the shaft of my whole penis. It took just a few tight pumps for me to spasm ejaculate all over the inside of my shorts.
The next day, conversation turned to how we would find the right person to join us. We decided to use a regular dating app to find potential men; Katie would post a profile of herself and we would then review any interested parties together before Katie messaged back and started to explain what we had in mind.
I knew we wouldn't have trouble finding interest from guys -- although Katie was 35, she could easily pass for being in her twenties. An active lifestyle and without ever drinking alcohol, Katie had kept an amazing physique and smooth clear skin. She was also of Eastern European heritage with platinum blond hair and pale blue eyes. We posted a few pictures on the site of her in some of her most revealing dresses, including a tight black mini dress that she used to wear out to nightclubs back in her single days.
We quickly found a good few potential guys to message back. A number of them then ghosted us as soon as we mentioned what we were looking for, but on our fourth attempt, we found someone who sounded really keen on what we had in mind.
Jay was in his late twenties and of mixed-race heritage. From his pictures he clearly enjoyed visiting the gym, he was over 6ft tall and had a great body. Although I wouldn't class myself as bisexual, I could tell he was a handsome guy. After a few messages we agreed upon a plan for Jay to come and visit us next Saturday evening.
Ahead of Jay's visit, Katie set a condition that Jay was not allowed to ejaculate between now and his visit, which at this point was exactly one week away. It she said that Jay's balls were as full and ripe as possible. Although he put up some playful protestations at the idea of this, Jay agreed, and as a special treat Katie sent some surprise nude pictures to keep Jay aroused and excited about what was to cum.
Katie explained to me that I couldn't cum either, since it wouldn't be fair on Jay, and besides she wanted me to be as horny as possible too. This was a significant challenge for me. I hadn't actually cum for a good few days at this point, and had been looking forward to jerking off that evening. Instead, I found myself laying in bed that night rock hard and with a thumping heart from the anticipation of what was to come. Katie meanwhile slept without trouble, helped along by our bedtime cunnilingus sessions during which I always made sure Katie orgasmed in her cute, squeaky voice.