I don't know why I told him. It just slipped out between sports-guy talk about the Rams and the Raiders and the Lakers. It just went quickly from "did you see that last game" to "I think about my wife fucking other men" in the blink of an eye. I knew it had been a mistake when his football-fan smile morphed into an "I can't believe you just said that" frown.
"You do what?" he said. "You want other guys to fuck your wife? You want to watch it?" I said it was just a fantasy. I didn't know if I wanted it I told him "That's nuts," he said. I told him there were others like me who fantasized about other men fucking their wives or actually shared them with other men. "Not the guys I know. I would beat the shit out of any guy who even hinted he would like to do the nasty with my wife," he almost shouted. "You are crazier than I thought," he said shaking his head in disbelief.
I knew I could not convince him, but stupidly I persisted. "At night when I reach across the bed and take her bare bottom in my hand or slip my fingers between her thighs and touch her pussy, I think about some other guy fucking it or kissing her ass." I said I didn't understand it, but I really did get pleasure from those images.
"Well," he said, "if you really want someone to pork her, call me. Since you brought it up, I've wanted in that pussy for years. We're being honest here. Just ask and I am available to service your lady."
Every time I saw him after that our conversation shot right passed Go, right passed sports trivia to wife sharing without a seconds hesitation. "You still looking for someone to fuck your bride?" he asked with a smirk.
"Not looking for guys," I said, "just fantasizing about it. It is a sexual escape." I knew at that moment that I had lost him. "There is a whole category of fiction about wife sharing and relaxing notions about monogamy," I said, but he was not seeing it. "If you are interested I could get you some things to read," I said. He smiled, then he shook his head.
"Read about guys who want other dicks in their wives pussies. Not me," he said. "I would lock her vagina up in a chastity belt if I could get away with it."
"But your wife has sexual needs you might not be able to fill," I said, beating the old dead horse. "Maybe she wants to fuck other guys. Ever think of that? Maybe she is fantasizing about being fucked by people other than you. Ever consider that?"
"Then I am not doing my job."