My wife Mandy and I have been married for 10 years and have 2 kids. We have a nice family and are really happy. Our sex life is great and we have lots of fun together. Mandy comes from a fairly conservative background where my upbringing was much more of a wild card. For a long time I have fantasized about sharing Mandy with another man but have never brought it up to her because I thought she would freak out.
Mandy is gorgeous with curly brown hair and a smile that kills! She's 5'10" 160lbs and was a college athlete so she has a really sexy build with 36b tits. They're a little bigger currently because she's breastfeeding. Thanks to her athletic background she also has an amazing ass! The smoothness and tone of her skin really puts it all together. No man, or woman, would say no to her!
I am about the same size as her with a thinner athletic build for a guy (runner) with a decent size 7.5 inch cock. That is where our story really begins.
My wife and I really do have great sex. She likes to dress sexy from time to time and is fairly experimental with me! She's let me blindfold her, tie her to the bed and even lets me fuck her sexy ass every once in a while! All of this has taken time to get her to try it out, but each step she's taken she has really enjoyed. Lately, we've become a bit more vocal during sex and the talking has made things a bit more exciting.
One night, while we were having sex, she was talking sexy about how big my cock was and how good it felt inside her. She only had two sexual partners before me and doesn't watch porn ever so she doesn't really know how big they can get. It was really hot to hear her talk like this but, at one point, I mentioned that I'm not massive or anything and that some guys cocks are much bigger than mine. She was floored but told me she found that hard to believe. She stated that there is no way guys can be much larger than me, maybe slightly at best. We continued to fuck and had a great evening, but I think her curiosity was sparked!
Talking with her about cock sizes greatly increased how much I thought about this fantasy of watching her with another guy. Later that week I took it upon myself to find a guy with a big cock. I posted an ad stating that I was looking for a big cock for my wife to experience. After wading through a lot of responses and looking at a lot of cocks, some guys really think they are hung when they are not, I finally found a guy that I thought would work. He was a built athletic guy 6'2" 200lb guy in his early 20's and had a cock to match! His name was Eric.
Eric sent a picture of his cock next to a soda can and he had both the length and the girth to go with it. I was impressed with how big it was and I really wanted to know what Mandy would think of it. I couldn't stop thinking about watching my wife with this massive cock! I met him in person just to talk about what my idea was and letting him know that this wasn't a sure thing.
Eric had a pretty chill demeanor but let me know on more than one occasion that once it starts there's no turning back, he's going to get what he wants, my wife! "Once we make it to the bedroom I can be really dominant and there really will be no turning back," he told me. I didn't even think this would go anywhere so that didn't bother me at all.
The plan was really pretty simple. My wife and I would go out one night to get some drinks as I try to get her a little tipsy. Eric would spark up a conversation with us and try to work on a wager regarding cock size. The goal was to see if my wife wanted to see it! So really there was no plan, just see if my wife would go for seeing another man's cock! I was pretty sure my Mandy wouldn't let it go that far, but, at least we'd try.
The following Friday night our kids were spending the weekend at her parents house. We got all dressed up and went out for dinner. After dinner we were headed to get drinks at a bar somewhat close to our house. I texted Eric to let him know where we would be at and that Mandy and I were drinking.
Mandy was about 3 drinks in when Eric walked in and I knew I was stupidly at a no going back moment! I thought about heading home multiple times before Eric got there but my fantasy was rolling around in my head too much and I just had to see how my wife would respond. I quickly got us another round to make sure she wouldn't think about leaving either. My wife doesn't usually drink more than 2 at best so she was feeling it for sure and I started to get really flirty with her in hopes to get her aroused before Eric stepped in.
After a little while, Eric made his way to us and started chatting it up! He's a natural, and my wife and I love talking with people so it starts up with ease. Later in the conversation he is mentioning how cute of a couple we are and Mandy asked, 'You're a good looking guy, where's your girlfriend at?'
Now I'm not sure his next lines would really work on anyone else, but because of the discussion on cock sizes previously between Mandy and I, it piqued Mandys interest!
Eric replied, "Well I'm only 21 and I've had a couple of girlfriends but once we get into the bedroom I think I make them a little nervous."
Mandy inquired, "Why would you make them nervous? This conversation has been lovely."
Eric replied, 'It's not my personality that makes them nervous."
Mandy, being so naive, dug a little deeper, "I don't understand, what is it then?"
Eric boldly stated, "It feels funny to even say it but, I have a really big dick and it kinda freaks them out."
Mandy, still being so naive and a little drunk, "Well my husband has a pretty big one and look at us, we're happy and together." Mandy leans over and gives me a hug and a kiss.
Eric chuckled lightly, "I don't think you understand Mandy, I'm probably bigger than your husband by over an inch for sure."
My wife drunkenly slid her hand down toward my cock, "I highly doubt that, that doesn't seem possible."
Eric replied, "I tell you what, I would be willing to wager a bet." Eric dug into his pants pocket and pulled out a wad of cash. "If I'm not more than an inch bigger than your husband, all this is yours! It's about $500!" Eric said. And like the smart man he is, he just paused and waited.
Mandy, being more curious than I thought she would, asked the obvious follow up, "And if you're over an inch bigger?"
Eric smiled at Mandy warmly and you can tell all parties involved are interested in this wager. "There is no way I'm smaller, but let's just say if I'm more than an inch bigger you have to give me a handjob, but, if I'm more than 2 inches bigger... well then, let's just say you're mine for the night!" He finished his drink, set it on the table and said "I'm going to head to the bathroom and let you two talk."
My wife looked at me to try to get some sort of read on me and sayid, "What a coincidence after our talks earlier this week!"
"Yea, that conversation changed rather quickly and came out of nowhere! He's kind of brazen isn't he!" I replied. There's a short pause and you can feel neither of us know how to ask about the proposition laid out in front of us so I just asked plainly, "What are you thinking?"
Mandy replied, "I was going to ask you the same thing!" Neither of us are wanting to tread into the unspoken territory.
I keep pushing us deeper into this rabbit hole I created for us, "I mean, to be honest, it would be kind of fun to prove you wrong and see your thoughts on a bigger cock."
