I held my vodka-and-grapefruit juice in front of me, aware that I was closing myself off through body language, but unable to help myself. Perhaps when this drink is inside me, I thought, I can relax a bit more, but for the moment I held my glass like a shield in front of my 34D chest, which at the moment felt all too exposed by my low-cut dress.
And it was excusable to feel the need for a shield, because this was the first time I'd ever been to a swingers' event. My husband Patrick had finally talked me into trying it, just seeing what it was like, and had agreed to my condition that we go to an out-of-town party. So here we were on a whirlwind, last-minute trip in New York City, at a hotel swinger's party, and I felt as though I'd been set down in some bizarre alternate reality.
We'd talked about sex with other people, and about both of us with a woman, for years while in bed, spinning fantasies together to increase the already-intense heat between us. We both loved the idea of including others in our sex lives; I just wasn't sure about the reality. I'd always been shy, and particularly had always needed a connection in order to really relax and enjoy myself sexually with a partner.
That connectedness wasn't a part of swinging, as I viewed it. Swinging, in my mind, was faceless, anonymous sex, the ultimate in fucking for the sake of physical pleasure and nothing more. The image in my mind was a sad, tawdry one, glazed eyes set in bored faces, faces detached almost physically from their genitals that were being fucked by some stranger. I'd had a couple of one-night stands years before, before I was married, and I was amazed at that time that sex could be so on-the-surface, so unsatisfying, so lacking in intimacy. It always made me think of Benjamin Braddock's comment in "The Graduate": "we might just as well have been shaking hands." It made me feel so lonely and empty afterwards, frequently trying to fill an unnamed void with raw cookie dough or a tub of ice cream. I couldn't imagine that, for me, sex with swingers would be any better.
So, fantasies aside, casual sex wasn't something I was interested in pursuing; I knew it couldn't really be the stuff of the fantasies we wove for each other in bed. In bed together, we volleyed words between us until we worked ourselves into a sexual frenzy over the thought of delicious new partners tailored to our desires, stimulating us beyond the edge of our experience. But Patrick, more than stirred by our talking, wanted to live it out, wanted to experience in full the variety and novelty that I guess every man craves. I understood, and I truly wanted to let him have that. I even wanted to be a part of it. We were perfect for each other, a pairing that had made me begin to believe in soulmates, ideally matched in virtually every way: intelligence, interests, temperament, goals, certainly sexually. I didn't feel threatened by his interest in exploring with me; hell, most men would've simply cheated rather than suggest going to a swinger's party. I felt lucky that we were close enough to talk about these thoughts, in and out of bed. But I wasn't sure I could bring myself to repeat the empty sex like I'd had before, the handshake sex.
So we had decided to come to this party, a thousand miles from home, a thousand miles from our reality. We agreed that wouldn't touch anybody but each other, and there wouldn't be any pressure for either of us to do anything. We'd just meet some people, look around, see how it felt, perhaps find some fodder for our own lovemaking later. Patrick thought that my tawdry stereotypes might be mistaken, and I was willing to entertain that idea. After all, if we found that we could connect with a couple, or a woman, perhaps it could be a worthwhile experiment, even for me.
So far, the party had felt rather intimidating. I had dressed in a lacy black dress that looked more appropriate for lingerie. I was constantly aware of how it hugged my curves and crept up my thighs. I wasn't even one of the most skimpily dressed women there, but it was an unusual look for me, and the dress put my body on display for all to see. Also, the other guests all seemed to know each other, all comfortable and chatty. We'd been there for three hours, in the hotel that was closed for business to all but this swingers' group, and most people (other than me) were past relaxing, had moved on to seriously enjoying themselves. There were clusters of people laughing and talking here and there, body language loose and inviting, and a few people had started to move onto the dance floor. There were about eight couples out there now, dancing, smiling, enjoying moving their bodies against each other, grinding a little. A fluid group of women, sometimes three, sometimes five, sometimes more, were dancing together, occasionally moving in to kiss and touch. Watching a woman slide her hand over another woman's breast, her fingers circling her hard nipple through her blouse, I felt my panties growing wet in spite of myself.
"Are you doing okay?" Patrick asked, his arm around me, his face nuzzling my hair.
"Yeah, I'm okay," I said. "Just a little nervous. But this is not so bad." I took a sip of my cocktail that turned into more of a gulp.
"It's okay," he said soothingly. "Do you want another drink?"
I realized that I'd just finished my cocktail. My shield had melted.
"Sure," I said. "Same thing, okay?"
"Okay," Patrick smiled, and giving my shoulder a squeeze, headed for the hotel breakfast bar that, for tonight, was doubling as a wet bar.
Just as had happened every time I stood alone that night, the moment Patrick was out of reach, someone approached me. This time, it was a man, at least a foot taller than me (not that that is saying much, as I am barely over 5'0, even in the high-heeled boots I was wearing), with a shaved head, a goatee, and tattoos snaking up each forearm.
"Having fun?" he asked.
"Yeah," I smiled. "Just trying to get a feel for things."
"You guys new?"
"Yeah, we're not really sure about this yet. Just checking it out." I tried to relax and maintain eye contact, but couldn't help my eyes darting to the side, hoping for Patrick to come back.
"Well, it's a fun group," he said. "Good way to check things out, see if you're interested. You can always just chat and dance too."
"Thanks! Yeah, so far it seems really nice. Everybody's nice." I floundered. It's nice, everybody's nice, ugh.
"Here you go Honey," Patrick said, handing me a drink. "Sorry, it's cranberry and vodka. They're out of grapefruit juice."
"That's okay," I said, relieved to have him back to share the conversation, and to have a new drink with which to resume my isolating body language. "This is . . .?"
"Oh, sorry," the guy said. "I'm Joel. My wife's around here somewhere . . . . Let me go find her to introduce you guys." Joel headed across the hotel lobby.
"Making friends?" Patrick asked.
I laughed. "That's me, life of the party." I thought about conversations I'd had with my online friend Ryan, a kindred spirit in introversion, about events like this and the preferability of online chatting. Why couldn't everyone just type on keyboards instead, like a big chat room? People could still have sex if they wanted, but I was much better at conversation if I could do it on a computer screen. I smiled envisioning it, all of these party types hunched over laptops, bathed in the comforting screen light instead of the harsher flashes of the spinning disco ball that they'd somehow imported straight from 1978.
If only Ryan were here now. We had a rapport, a camaraderie, that had become a close friendship over time, in spite of the distance of three states and two Great Lakes. He was younger than me, with an incredibly sensual and erotic mind. His intelligence, his sharp sense of humor, the pictures he'd sent me, everything about him pushed all the right buttons for me, buttons I knew would likely gather nothing but dust among swingers.
Suddenly the D.J.'s voice boomed over the P.A. system: "all right, you guys, getting ready to warm up for the big lap dance contest! Everybody's welcome! The only rule is, no ladies can give lap dances to their own partner! Coming up here in fifteen!"
Patrick grinned. "Going to get in on that?"
I laughed. Lap dance contest . . . I couldn't imagine a less likely event for me to participate in. And who would be judging that? "I might give you a lap dance after a dozen more drinks. Not going to be in a competition, though."
"Sounds fun to watch, though," he said.
I nodded.
Joel reemerged from the crowd, leading a curvy blond by the hand.
"Hey, guys, this is Sara." Sara was taller than me, wearing a shiny strapless red dress. Her ample breasts looked like they might tumble out of her dress if she weren't careful. I liked the way her straight blond hair brushed her shoulders. I looked at her, thinking about what it would be like to kiss her, to slip my hand inside the top of her dress.
We made small talk for a few minutes. Sara and Joel were high school sweethearts, and had been swinging for 17 years. They were friendly. I drank some more of my cocktail, again too quickly, and started to relax at last. Now that we were talking to people, I was feeling more comfortable about being here.
"All right, ladies! Let's warm up! Lap dance time -- guys, find a chair and help get these ladies ready to rumble!"
Joel looked at me, questioningly. I shook my head.
"I'm sorry, nothing personal, I'm just not ready for that," I said.
"Understood," he grinned. "Just wanted to let you know that I'd be up for it if you were." He smiled and found a chair as "Imma Be" started playing. A redhead in a tight white dress who seemed to know Joel leapt on top of him with a big smile and started dancing. I watched as her short dress crept up, revealing that she wasn't wearing any panties. I shifted my weight, noticing again the wetness of my own thong.
"Honey?" Patrick was touching my arm, and I realized he'd been trying to get my attention.
"Oh, sorry, what's up?"
He leaned close to me. "Sara asked if she could practice her lap dance on me."