"Hello?"
"Hi, James. It's Tim."
"Oh. Hey."
"James, do you have a few minutes to chat?"
"Sure, I guess."
"No, I mean, not on the phone. I'm at the coffee shop you and Katy like to go to. Could you come down here alone? Don't tell Katy what you're doing."
James craned his head around the hallway corner to see if his wife was still in the bathroom. She was.
"Uh, okay. 10 minutes?"
"Great. Thanks, James."
James was surprised by Tim's appreciative tone. They hadn't had much conversation as Katy usually did the talking if her husband was watching her with Tim. Tim had told James before that he respected everything about him except for his marriage to Katy—as in, he was clearly acting disrespectfully by putting his cock in her.
James had mostly had a very hard time believing Tim had any respect for him at all. And why should he? If James were to fuck another man's wife right in front of his eyes while hubby did nothing to stop it, would James respect that man? Certainly not. He would laugh at him. James was almost certain that Tim laughed at him behind his back.
Tim had coffee waiting on the table for James, and a coffee for himself as James walked into the coffeehouse. James sat down at the table. Tim spoke first.
"Hey James, thanks for coming. Katy told me once you like your coffee black, if I'm not mistaken."
James didn't know where to start. Eeeny meeny miney moe. "Katy talks about me to you?"
"All the time. Your wife loves you very much."
"Well, she loves me, but she loves your cock more," said James regretfully.
"Okay, but she also loves me, but not as much as she loves you."
"Sure."
"I'm serious. What possible reason could I have to butter you up?"
"I'm still trying to figure that out. Dominance naming."
"What?"
"Dominance naming. It's a way to take control of a debate, by intimidating your opponent. You did it to me relentlessly the last time we had one of these long chats. 'James, this is how it is. You've gotta listen, James. James, you're wife wants to fuck me, so I'm gonna fuck her, James.' You're not doing it now, all 'thank you's and compliments. You want something."
"Yes. Your equal participation. I asked you here to see if you wanted to be a part of something. If you prefer, I can do it without you. That time that I was 'dominance naming' you was strictly to give you as strong an impression as possible that I had no intention of breaking off my relationship with your wife. I figured you would either kick my ass, run away, or give up, and that would be that."
"Hmph. So, I gave up, is what you're saying."
"Well, yes, but it's meant as a compliment. My real point, however, is this: I wanted it to be over as quickly as possible. I didn't see any reason to drag out some emotional melodrama. Unlike your wife, James, I don't get off on your pain."
"Could've fooled me."
'Well, if that's the case, I'm sorry. The thing is, James, I've been in your position before. I'm still sort of in your position right now, a little bit."
"Come again?" James chuckled sardonically.
"Ah. Right. Very good. Look, seriously. I was the cuckold in my last relationship."
"Sure you were."
"I was, James. She cheated on me once, felt guilty as hell, and told me about it. I kicked her out of the house. While she spent the night in a hotel, I was at home, picturing her with another man, jerking off like a goddamn teenager. I never did quite figure it out. Hot as hell."
"True."
"Anyway, the next day, she came back to the house to beg me to take her back, which I did. That same night, while we were fucking, I told her I wanted her to keep doing it. She couldn't believe it. It took some convincing, but eventually, she was screwing around on me constantly. I didn't even always get to watch."
"So, what happened to her?"
"Well, she wanted me not to sleep with other women."
It hadn't even occurred to James before that Katy's behavior justified his sleeping with other women. He realized that Tim's ex was nuts.
"Ha! Did she tell you this with another man's cum in her pussy?"
"That's right, James. Predictable, no?"
"So you left her."
"Yep."
"So, how exactly are you in my position right now? You've got a wife I can fuck?"
"Nope. But I do have a girlfriend."
"Hmph."
"Do you think I don't have feelings for her?"
"Oh, I know, you feel her whenever you want."
"James, I get jealous when I watch her with other men."
"Film her, you mean to say."
"But, of course, it turns me on. And I get even more jealous when she goes off on her own with someone I've never met."
"What's this now?"
"See? You've learned to trust me. You know I would never hurt Katy."
"She sees other men, men neither one of us know about?"
"Well, I know about them—I think—even though I don't know who they are."
"You think?"
"James, I always told you that I was never the one in control. It doesn't matter that I order your wife to swallow cum, I'm only doing it because she wants me to in the first place. You understand? I'm playing a role when I do those things. There are plenty of times that Katy and I have sex alone. During those times, it's usually Katy calling the shots, not me. You know? 'Fuck me harder, Tim. Take me from behind, Tim. Tim, fuck me in the pussy, but cum in my asshole, okay?' Every time, James."
"Jesus, enough already."
"Come on. Shut up. You like it."
"Okay, but why are you telling me all of this?"
"James, I make plans to come over to your house and bang your wife's brains out in front of you so that I can watch her have those incredible orgasms. They're always a little better when you're involved. Also, I do it that way, rather than just fucking her in private all the time, because I know I'm doing you a favor. You love watching those orgasms, too. So, sometimes I come over with a raging hard-on, only to see that her car is not in the driveway. And I see you sitting in the living room through your front window. I'm guessing she told you she was going out to be with me, and she went and cheated on both of us."
"Christ! How many times has this happened?"
"More than a dozen. And I had no idea who she was with. James, The thought of my girlfriend, your wife, going out of her way, lying to both of us when she could fuck whoever she wants with complete openness, makes me insanely jealous."
"Me too! Fuck!"
"But it also makes me want to go to the bathroom and whack off right this very minute."
"I can relate."
"Because it means she's doing something that makes her cum in a way that neither of us can make her cum."
"In a nutshell."
"So James, are you in or out?"
"...Of what?"
"You and I are going to give Katy the craziest orgasm of her life. One she'll never forget, as long as she lives. We're going to make sure she knows that she needs us."
"What. We're going to DP her together?"
"Christ, it's like you haven't heard a word I've said. No, James. Not even close, brother."
"Then what?"
"Well, I can't tell you. That's part of how it's going to work. I just wanted to see you in person, to convince you of my respect for you, and to find out if you are fully committed to your wife's pleasure, no holds barred."
"No holds barred?"