My wife Melissa eyed me from the love seat. She wanted the night to get on, she was anxious. I think we were all anxious. Tim sat with his wife Kate on the floor of the cabin. They were whispering something to each other, laughing quietly. I'd known them since middle school, and they were pretty much as close to me and Melissa as another couple could be.
"Ryan, come here, I got something to tell you." She smiled devilishly. She was the one that usually got the ball rolling. I'd met her at college, married her when we graduated. We were all right around twenty-six. I went to her, she kneel against me when I sat down.
"Me and Katie have a surprise for you guys." She wanted to warn me, in case we weren't into it. It wasn't our cabin, but most of what went on there was because of her. It was pretty harmless up until the night before. We were all close, made love to our spouses in each other's presence, didn't swap, maybe the girls kissed, licked a little, but it was harmless...
"Kate! Should we tell 'em?" Kate looked nervous, she was smiling and anxious, but she wasn't as forward as Melissa. She was more girlish, looked five or six years younger than she was, had a small thin frame with perfect little breasts. Pretty much the opposite of Melissa.
"Yes!" Tim grinned. Melissa continued,
"As you boys know, me and Katie had an extremely good time last night. And since you guys had to sleep alone while we had our fun, we've devised a scheme, pending your approval of course, for your mutual enjoyment." Kate stood up, it was her part of the presentation.
"Timmy, Ryan... We thought maybe we'd have a night where we switched, er, not sex..." She was tongue-tied looked embarrassed, Melissa coolly continued for her friend. I looked at Tim, he wasn't tracking, I was pretty surprised that she'd gotten Kate to go along this far.
"Yeah, not like sex, sex, but oral and...we went to the drug store today and both did something special...for anal too." She couldn't even say it without her cheeks turning red. I assumed she meant they cleaned out their...my thought was interrupted by Tim's laughing.
"You two are messing with us. Ryan, this is one of their gags." It was possible, but the way they were both so anxious about it made me think they might be serious.
"Mel, Kate, let me get this straight. Timmy goes to our bedroom and I go visit Katie dear for the night and we uh... can do everything but straight sex?" She nodded, I looked at Kate, her cheeks were bright red. She was a local TV news anchorwoman, with teeth that were way too white.
"Yes. Katie and me were together all last night and it was so much fun, we just wanna share what we experienced with you two." I looked at Tim, he just shrugged and mumbled that it was fine with him. So once we all agreed, however unenthusiastic, the girls had their own pow wow, then returned and told us to go to the host girl's bed.
I went to Kate and Tim's room and sat on the bed with a little light from the hall spilling in. She walked in cautiously in her jeans and sweater.
"Hi, Ryan." Her voice was shaky. She stopped in front of me, didn't bother closing the door or turning on the light.
"Hey, Katie. I like your earrings." I wanted to distract her. I was nervous but she was just about shaking. She felt her ear and the little hoop.
"Thanks, Ryan." She giggled then opened the drawer in the night stand and took out a tube.
"What you got?" She unscrewed the cap and peeled off the cover with her fingernail.
"Mel got strawberry, we got cherry." She squeezed a little on her finger and offered it to my mouth. I tasted her finger, she laughed nervously.
"I like it, it tingles a little." She set it down and took her sweater off. She wore a tight white t-shirt beneath it. She was super thin, which made her small chest look a lot bigger than it actually was sticking out from her frame. Her ass, on the other hand, was genuinely round and sexy. I rubbed her behind her knee.
"I'm supposed to strip for you, sit still." I sat back. She took off her pants, showed me her black thong in the front and back. I'd see it all before, I knew what her little lips looked like, how she left a good size patch of hair above but shaved her lips. She took her t-shirt off with her back to me, revealing her bra, she snapped that off too and it fell to the floor. It was just her dark brown hair and underwear that was all that was covering her skin. So far she was just undressing, not exactly stripping, but the way she bent over in front of me to slide her thong off made up for it. She did it slow and revealed her perfect nakedness to me inch by inch.
"You're so sexy, Katie." She turned around with her hands by her side, I was instantly hard. She tugged my shirt off over my head so I was just in jeans. She sat sideways on my lap facing away. She was so light, felt so different than Melissa. I kissed her neck and stroked her belly, she leaned back against my chest.
"We can kiss anywhere but the mouth, Ryan." I sucked on her earlobe, she moaned lightly and wiggled against me.
"Kate, get on your hands and knees and I'll kiss you anywhere." She giggled and climbed off me and into position, ass in the air. I ripped my pants and boxers off and kneel on the bed behind her.
Her skin was smooth, I stroked her ass and ran my fingers down to her puss. She was wet, I explored her for a little while, her breathing got heavier. When I licked her lips she shivered and moaned. She tasted better than Melissa, smelled better. I stared at her asshole, in theory I was going to get that too. I'd seen her take her husband in the ass a few times, never for that long though.
I tickled her clit with my fingers and ran my tongue over her perineum and into her crack. She shifted and mewled as I ran it over her anus. I stopped and got some of the cherry lube on my fingers and rubbed it down her crack, around her tight little hole. I licked around her crack, kissed her and slipped a finger in her puss. She was really getting into it now, pushing back against me, I was just trying to get her hot enough to slip a finger in her asshole.
"Oh, god, Ry, I think I'm going to cum." That was my cue, I rubbed her clit into her and inserted the tip of my lubed up finger into her anus. She came hard, screeched, and put her head on the bed. I stopped rubbing her puss and kept insinuating my finger into her butt. She kept her ass in the air and let me get half my index in her before she pulled away.
"Okay, your turn." She turned around and grabbed my cock, stroked it as she got into position to take me into her mouth. Her mouth was warm and wet and amazing, she swirled her tongue around the head and sucked me soft and then hard and I was going to cum after only a minute of it before I pulled her off. I had something else in mind.
"Wanna try in your behind?" She laughed, told me to go slow, got back on her hands and knees away from me.
"You're a little bigger than Tim, you gotta get two fingers in first." She was nervous again, I got the lube and squeezed a glob onto her anus. She squealed that it was cold. I rubbed it up and down her crack, she moved her hips in circles. I licked her crack and kissed her cheeks for a minute before I slipped my first finger in, which was easier than the first time. She moved with my finger as I took it out and gently pushed it back in. I told her I was gonna try another finger, she said 'okay'.
It took a little pushing but it finally popped in, she told me to go slow again. I licked her pussy to settle her down, didn't move my fingers. Finally when it seemed like she relaxed enough I stroked her in and out and she moaned, she was into it.
"Okay, Ryan, you can try to put it in, just get it lubed good." I got the tube again and stroked my cock, got myself slippery, put more on her anus and got into position behind her.
"Ohhhh! Ouch." I started to push in, my penis trying to open her. She was uncomfortable, obviously, I held my cock and pushed gently until the head popped in, she exhaled and I was able to slide farther in her. Her ass was amazing, her sphincter trying to push me out, so snug around me. It took some time working my cock into her, but it was worth it.
"You feel so good, Katie, I can't believe I'm inside you." I was moving in and out, fucking her with half of my cock. She was whining. I was holding her hip so I reached around with my free hand and started rubbing her clit. That got a better response from her and it seemed she was more open to me. I was in not quite pelvis to cheek, but still deep. We fucked, she moved back against me a little, I could pick up the pace.
"More lube, Ryan...Jesus, you're so deep, keep rubbing me." I squeezed a glob on my cock on its way out and pushed back in, I felt like I was within a minute of blowing my load. She came first, it was unexpected, Melissa had never had an orgasm during anal sex. Her body spasmed, her sphincter squeezed and relaxed around me over and over, I couldn't stand it, I came inside her, held her against me.
"I'm coming in you Katie, I can't fucking believe it, ahhh, fuck!" Her cheek was against the sheets, I was just kneeling there looking at my cock in her ass. I pulled out slowly and watched her anus close after my exit. From the looks of my dick it appeared she had cleaned herself out well earlier.
"I've never cum doing that, Ryan." She lay on her side, I lay down next to her, stroked her naked back. I leaned forward and sucked on one of her pointy nipples, she cooed and stuck her chest out toward me. I played with her titties with my mouth, ran my tongue around her aureole, sucked, nipped at her, pretty much slobbered on her breasts for the next five minutes until I was hard again.
"Your tits are perfect, Katie."
"I like what you're doing to 'em." Her hand had found my cock, wrapped itself around, she wasn't really stroking it. I stroked her cheek, looked into her eyes and out of habit tried to kiss her mouth. She realized we were kissing after a few seconds and pulled back.
"Oh, no, we can't smooch at all; against the rules." I said I was sorry and kissed and sucked on her neck while I fondled her breasts and ran my hand over her pussy. I explored her for a while before she said anything.
"Ryan, I can't believe you came in my butt." We both laughed pretty hard. She began stroking me when we grew quiet.
"You're hard, I don't know if I can let you back in just yet." She moved down the bed and took my cock into her mouth. I was blown away, little Katie was sucking me after I fucked her and came in her ass. Her ass was fun, but her mouth was wet and alive around me. She would suck me for a little then stroke me and look me in the eye then suck me and stroke me etc.
