This story was inspired by Sting's song "Everybody Laughed But You":
Thank you to LittleBitOfEverythingReally for the edits.
PROLOGUE: MERCURIAL
Gather closer, my slumbering cohorts
For tonight's tale and a lesson of sorts
In the very spirit of our eves of grief
The fate of a cinder belle who was struck by a thief
No love as pure and splendid
Had this school ever attended
As the passionate little affair
Of Frank Hart and Molly O'hare
At Marlon Merlo Brooklyn High
Hand in hand, they would stroll by
Inseparable, the two were soulmates
Their union ordained by the fates
Molly was silly, sassy, and sweet
Frank was suave and snappy, a real treat
He would have taken a bullet for you
And that's what set their love askew.
The boy was too gentle, his heart was too big
And it caught the greedy eye of a certified pig
Into their lives Katie Osmond barged in
And their love she threw in the trash bin
Every girl hated the red headed sow
There was no guy she couldn't chow
She'd steal your boyfriend just to show
That no one was safe from the little ho
Why did she do it? Nobody knew
She hated Math, sucked at Chem, and at Sports, ew
No, Seduction was her one unique skill
And stealing nice things gave her
such
a thrill
At one point she had not one, not even two
But
three
whole beaus waiting on cue
All three eventually got their arses expelled
Thanks to a ferocious fist fight they held
From ninth to twelfth grade, every year there was drama
Like clockwork, Katie always delivered a fresh new trauma
Usually a brawl that ended with a black eyed quarterback
Or a suspended linebacker moping at home doing jack
Her senior year promised more of the same
When Molly marched in to meet her flame
On her seat at the cafeteria giggled Katie
Learning about sines and cosines from Molly's matey
Molly knew she was in for a fight
As Katie was nothing short of a blight
She played hard to seduce Molly's boy
But he would not fall for her wicked ploy
Her lurid advances were easily foiled
Frankie's love could not be soiled
This was the one boy Kate could not possess
And such resistance brought her great distress
Unable to dent Big Frankie's devotion
Katie put a grand new plan into motion
She trained her sights on poor oblivious Molly
Hoping to sink her soul into folly
As Molly walked on her merry way to class
Katie's words would shatter her like glass
"The bitch doesn't deserve Frankie, just look at her,"
She'd whisper with bile, the little saboteur
Molly's ears were bombarded, her poor heart rendered sore
"Junkies and thugs, her whole family's rotten to the core"
Yes, her Dad was on the take and her Mom was a whore
The O'hares were far from exactly top drawer
Her attendance was dismal, her grades were abyssal
And her notion of fashion would make anyone bristle
The zingers kept coming and she got fed up
Molly's pot boiled over and she finally blew up
It went down in October and it still haunts her, I swear
The falling leaves were the same color as Katie's hair
Cheerleader practice had finished, so Molly took a detour
through the back of the gym to go meet her
amour
Students hanged back there, all talking and smoking
Among them, Katie started poking and joking
"By
God
, just look at her ass, that thing is
titanic
!"
Indeed, Molly's butt width was roughly oceanic
"What did you just say to me?" Molly spun on her heels
"There's a famine in Ireland, O'hare. Save them
some
meals."
The students saw murder flash in Molly's flaming eyes
and quickly made a hole in shock and surprise
"Bitch, who the
fuck
told you you could speak to me?!"
Mad Molly growled with rage like a crazed Banshee
All the bottled up anger inside her chest erupted
"You
whore!
" Molly's vision blurred, her wits were corrupted
She saw red and her fists flew
As she punched Katie's nose into a goo
It was liberating, she was actually grinning
Sweet justice filled her with glee and it sent her head spinning
Every girl there was secretly cheering and clapping
As the pompous redhead endured a royal slapping
Nobody really knew how long the slaughter went on
As justice was handed by Vengeance's Paragon
"Molly..." A voice finally woke her from her murderous rage
And found her beaming triumphant, standing on a morbid stage
The horror in his tone made the girl freeze
"Molly, c'mon," Frankie whimpered. "Stop... please..."
In her hand, a bloodsoaked fistful of Katie's hair
Had been viciously used to wage open warfare
To bash the girl's head against the wall
Again and again in the ruthless brawl
The clapping had stopped, the smiles had faded
Katie had been crushed, her smirk castrated
Molly took a look at her ghoulish masterpiece
And hoped to God nobody had called the police
(They
did
show up, but my wife was the lunch lady
With the key to a room in a motel most shady
She rode them for days and made it all go away
But I'll leave those details for another day)
"I scraa..." Katie Osmond whimpered on the floor
Bloodied and shaken to her very core
Softly, she mumbled; "I scraped my knee..."
Her mind was gone, surely you'll agree
Frankie covered her with his Varsity jacket tenderly
Worried the red headed girl's mental health was in jeopardy
He lifted Katie in his arms with formidable energy
And quickly carried her to the nurse's office commendably
"Look, Frankie... I scraped my little knee..." Katie mumbled
"Mommy's gonna be so mad..." In his arms she crumbled.
Totally appalled by what she was viewing
Molly called him: "Frankie?
What
are you
doing
?"
Eyes of a stranger glared back in disgust
Frankie's love for her crumpled into dust
She was suspended for a month and when she got back
Things had gone bizarre, reality all out of whack
Frank walked around with his arm on Katie's shoulders,
Puzzling even the most casual beholders
Molly's eyes met hers and Katie smirked, victorious
Frank was hers at last and the feeling was glorious
She had changed her image, rebranded herself and repacked
And he had fallen for her defenseless victim act
Katie wore a bandage on her head for much of the school year
And milked the boy's compassion in a manner most cavalier
In time, his pity bloomed into love
As he grew sure they fit like a glove
Everybody laughed or whispered: "What a sad display"
Then set their watches and waited for her to stray
To her credit she never did, far from it
Maybe she grew up and shifted her wit
Glued she was to her Big Frankie on the playground
Blinded to any of the other boys around
I like to think it was irony that brought her her defeat
'Cause the
symmetry
of it would be just plain sweet
In the effort to bow Frank to her selfish whim
She
was the one who fell in love with him
Molly meanwhile vanished, she went underground, full quiet
The rest of her school year was spent on a strict dim diet
Of depression, amfebutamone, and Linda Ronstadt
Hey, don't you judge! It was 94 and it '
Hurt So Bad'
She tried everything to reconnect with him
But the mere sight of her made Frank's face turn grim
Over the Summer, she finally caught him alone
"Go away, Molly," he grunted. "It's over, we are
done!"
"Please come back to me, Frankie," Molly pleaded in despair
"She's going to
destroy
you," she cried, her heart laid bare
"Like you did?" His cold tone materialized her worst fears
His love for her was truly dead and it brought her to tears
She couldn't get through to him, and it cut her like a knife
"You're making the single biggest mistake of your
life!
"
"You
were the biggest mistake of my life, Molly!"
Frank roared, remembering her all giddy and jolly
The cruel, sadistic delight in her expression
And her vicious explosion of boundless aggression
"I saw you, the
real
you." He glared at the girl
"You're
sick
, Molly, you made me wanna
hurl!
"
"You were going to
murder
her," Frankie said
"Doc says you came
this
close to crushing her head!"
"And you know the worst part?" He remembered with dread
"You were
grinning
while she was lying there half dead."
"I love you, Frankie." Tears rolled down Molly's face
Their once epic love gone without a trace