Lisa, a catholic school teacher and my wife of 15 years, was a virgin when we married, I always joked that her was just one step above a nun. Well at age 41, after three kids and a few extra pounds, Lisa was feeling less sexy and more and more like a nun. Don't get me wrong, Lisa is 5'2" and has a petite cheerleader frame, she walks every morning I am lucky to have her.
For the past three or four years, when Lisa and I would make love, I would tell her an erotic story to enhance the experience. Because I was the one telling the stories, they naturally revolved around my favorite fantasy, Lisa being fucked by another man. Eventually, as evident by her orgasms, this also became her favorite fantasy as well.
Although, Lisa would never actually consider being with another man, she does frequently play the role quite well. From time to time when she and I go out to dinner or to a movie, she will shave her pussy and go commando. Once we were sitting on a patio and Lisa pointed to a group of younger guys and looked me in the eyes and said "I'd fuck any one of that guy's if you want me to". I nearly fell out of my chair. Our love making session that night was short but intense. No doubt thanks to that anonymous group of guys.
That night, I devised a plan to add a little roll playing to our lovemaking. I did not want to share Lisa with anyone, but I did want to add a little realism to the fantasies. I decided that I would blindfold Lisa and pretend I was a stranger and make love to her. It was bound to be harmless, right? Boy was I wrong.
I decided that I was not going to tell Lisa about my plan. I would just do my best to trick her into thinking that I was really being fucked by a stranger. Here's how I planned it. First I laid the ground work. Telling Lisa that I have found a guy for who wants to fuck her and that I agreed he could. Lisa was pissed and said that she did not want anyone but me, but that night I caught her fingering her pussy when I came to bed. She quickly mounted me and asked me to tell her how I was going to let this "Mystery Man" fuck his catholic school teacher wife.
Now that the seed was sown, I told her the rules laid out by me, I mean the "Mystery Man."
Rule #1 -- The Mystery Man would never speak. (This was necessary to complete the illusion)
Rule #2 -- Lisa was to be blindfolded and tied to the bed. She was to wear only a bath rob and nothing else.
Rule #3 -- In order to show that Lisa was a willing participant; she was to paint her toenails "Slut Red" (Lisa loves a good pedicure but hates red toenails)
Rule #4 -- In order to show that she really wanted to be fucked, Lisa was to purchase a box of Trojan Magnum Condoms. He said that he was not going to use the on her, but that it was a sign of her submission. (This catholic school teacher has never bought a box of condoms in her life).
Rule #5 -- Before he would even touch Lisa, she had to say aloud "I want you to fuck me"
Here is where I messed up.
Rule #6 -- I, you husband was not allowed to touch you and the day he come over, until after he is through with you. I can watch, but if I touch you, he will leave and never come back.
Rule #7 -- I must clean you up after he is done with you. If I don't, he will never come back again. (I added this one in to throw Lisa off course. She knew that I would never suck another mans cum out of her pussy and when I didn't the fantasy was over).
When I told her that I had agreed to the rules, Lisa laughed and again stated that she wanted nothing to do with the "Mystery Man." Although that night, she came to bed wearing only her bath robe. I pulled her close and kissed her. As we kissed, I removed the belt from around the robe and tied it around her wrist. I led her to the club chair on our room and bent her over the arm of the chair. I then tied the belt to the chair leg on the far side and stepped back to admire my handy work.
I was quite pleased with the view of my catholic school teacher. I could see that her pussy lips were starting to drip with anticipation. I walked up from behind and slid a finger into her wet pussy. Lisa did her best to push back, bit each time I would remove my finger and tease her.
I removed my pants and rubbed the tip of my dick up and down her pussy lips. I leaned over and whispered into her ear, "You know what to say don't you".
"I want you to fuck me" Lisa moaned.
For the next few weeks, all was quite normal. Then one Monday Lisa told me that she was sending the kids to her parents this weekend and that maybe our "Mystery Man" could come over this Friday. My jaw nearly hit the floor. I stressed to her that this was no joke and asked her if she was really ready to let some stranger fuck her. She just smiled and showed me her freshly painted toenails.
"Slut Red" she said. The he reached into her purse and pulled out a box of Trojan Magnum Ecstasy condoms.
I told her that I had not talked to the "Mystery Man" in weeks and did not know if he was available. Lisa just smiled as walked over to me. She slowly got down on her knees and undid my zipper. She proceeded to give me the best blow job ever. Just as I was about to cum, she stopped zipped my pants back up and said, "I bet you can make it happen."
I started to protest but she put her finger to my lips and said "You do not get to fuck me again until I am fucked by the Mystery Man".
As I walked out of the room, I wondered what I had gotten my self into.
All week long the sexual tension was so thick you could cut it with a knife. But try as I may, I could not get Lisa naked. When Friday came, Lisa was a basket case. I brought her a glass of wine and a give certificate to have another pedicure as I know how it relaxes her.
"Slut Red", I reminded her.
She smiled and headed for the door. Truth be known, I needed the time to "Setup" the bedroom. She would already be blindfolded, so I would need to "trick" her other senses of smell and hearing.
First I ran a wire out the window that is next to our bed and wired it onto the doorbell. Because Lisa enters the house through the garage, she would never see it.
Next I ran some string under the bed and tied it to the closet door on the other side of the room. My plan is to open the closet door on one side of the bed while making noise on the other. Thus, creating the illusion that two people were in the room.
