"You asked me last night how much of what I said was real?" she asked me.
"Uhuh, was just curious how much you'd made up."
"And what do you think I might have made up?"
The night before, she'd told me some pretty outrageous things; wearing that 'thing' out in public to a store, making up another couple, fucking the other guy, and so on. Those things just don't happen to forty-nine-year-old, conservative high school teachers. Of course, most married high school teachers don't have ex-NFL boyfriends, either.
We were in the bedroom, getting ready for bed. I was sitting on the bed in my red boxers, Dani had put on a nighttime outfit, one of my favorites, that she'd bought a couple weeks earlier, a pajama set; pink lace and very, very sheer, all intricate, flowery patterns throughout; the top - spaghetti straps over her shoulders, a deep 'V' and elastic under her boobs emphasizing her 'assets'. The bottom was cut low on her hips with a tie around her waist; loose and flowing legs with slits nearly to her thigh, all concealing exactly nothing, only pretending to try, which made the whole thing sexy as hell.
Not even considering the makeup and perfume she'd put on that we'd gotten that night in Tampa, if she was trying to seduce me, she was doing a damned good job.
"Jerry and Jamie for one, going shopping for another," I told her, looking back and forth between her nipples poking through and an almost naked, shaved pussy that I still wasn't used to - not at all.
She laughed, "Seems I have a credibility problem, then, don't I? Alan didn't believe what I told him about that night last October, either. Which do you think is more likely to not have happened, that night or Jerry?"
Not giving me a chance to answer, she went to my closet, rummaging through it. "I don't see your old jacket from that night, you do something with it?"
"No, I hung it in the closet, haven't touched it since. But you're changing the subject, tell me."
She turned toward me, walking back to the bed and sat down beside me, "I asked you... which do you think is more likely to be real, that night, fucking Jerry, or the shopping trip?"
"Well, I know what happened that night, so that's got to be the top of the list, and I have to seriously doubt that either Jerry or going shopping wearing that thing happened."
She started giggling, "Guess it's a matter of knowledge, isn't it? Alan knows what happened Sunday night, doesn't think that night in October was possible, so he'd tend to put those things in the opposite order."
I looked at my wife, finally saying, "You're telling me..."
"That what I told you about Sunday was real?" She turned more serious, "Meeting Jerry and Jaime in the park, they came back to the house and we fucked. Twice.
I closed my eyes, leaned back on my hands, and pictured in my mind what Dani was telling me. I opened them when I felt Dani get up off the bed. She went out in the hall, then back a moment later with a kitchen chair.
"I want to show you exactly what Jerry and I did while Alan and Jaime were occupied on the bed," she said, rummaging through a drawer after setting the chair down. She pulled out the blindfold and a pair of handcuffs, then pushed her pajama top and bottom off, making herself gloriously naked. Staring at her like this, imagining just two nights ago, brought me a whole new appreciation for my wife's body.
She put the blindfold on herself, then told me, "You need to get naked, too," and sat down in the chair she'd brought in.
She waited a few moments while I slipped my clothes off. My cock was rock hard, imagining myself as Jerry, looking at this beautiful, naked woman for the first time then she held out the handcuffs to me, "Put this on me," holding her arms together behind the chair.
I did as she asked, locking her arms together in the cuffs, clicking them tight on her wrists, then stood, admiring my handiwork, my gorgeous wife blindfolded and handcuffed, her legs spread apart on the chair showing her puffy, damp, shaved pussy.
"Now," she said, "suck my tits... be Jerry." If we hadn't had the sex just the night before, I would probably have come right then, visualizing this guy that Dani didn't even know what he looked like, sucking her naked tits in his mouth. Fifteen minutes earlier, I was certain he was just 'a story'. No more!
I knelt in front of my wife, sucking one of her nipples in my mouth, then her entire tit, imagining how Jerry must have enjoyed doing what I was.
Dani moaned, "Oh yes, feels so good!"
I mimicked what I thought he would have been doing, switching to her other tit, my hands all over her, her nipples hard and pointed, eliciting more moans. "I had the gag in my mouth," she whimpered in-between moans.
Okay, I knew where she'd put it, the same drawer as the blindfold and handcuffs. I got up to get it and she stood up at the same time. "Make this even more realistic," I said as I forced the ball in Dani's mouth, then strapping it tight around her head. I know she said she didn't like it, but too bad. It's how she said she was that night. And fuck, it was hot, my smart, sexy wife so helpless with a complete stranger.
She sputtered, trying to make sounds, her mouth opening and closing but nothing more than grunts coming out. Her hands motioned, pointing to me, then the chair, along with the 'ahh, ahh' sounds she was making. I presumed she was trying to tell me to sit.
My heart was pounding in my chest when I felt Dani's body sliding down mine. We'd made love, had sex, thousands of times in the last twenty-eight years, but this was so different. Only two nights earlier, her naked body had been sliding down onto a stranger's cock. When I began to feel her pussy slowly wrapping around me, I was that stranger, feeling her for the first time.
She ground her pussy down on me, eliciting moans around her gag, pressing her naked tits against my chest and almost frantically rubbing her lips and the gag against my lips, almost like she was trying to tell me...
I pulled the gag from her mouth and within a millisecond, her lips were on mine, her tongue exploring my mouth, grinding her pussy on my pelvis, my cock buried deep inside her.
She pulled her lips away for a moment, saying, in her fevered voice, "Suck my tits."
That's a phrase I would never have expected to hear from my wife a few weeks ago, especially being said to anyone other than me. But who the hell was I to deny the lady's request? Her nipple was hard and distended when I sucked it into my mouth. Dani had thrust her chest out and her head was thrown back, eliciting moans from her mouth, "Ahh, so good!"
My excitement level was at least a fifteen on a scale of one to ten. This concept of 'being' this other man who had done this very thing to my wife only two nights earlier was blowing my mind.
Our bodies were in unison, Dani pumping up and down, my thrusts into her with every one of her down motions, and my lips moving from one tit to the other.
I felt it before her scream, her pussy tightening, clamping around my cock, "Yes, yes, yesss!" she screamed as her body quivered and shook from her orgasm, setting off my ejaculations inside her, spurt after spurt, the intensity almost agonizing. The thought briefly went through my mind wondering if this other guy's orgasm was as forceful as my own, which only made me come harder. Who'd have ever thought?
We were both damp with sweat, breathing hard when it was finally over. God, it had been hot! When Dani was able, she climbed up off me and turned, "Will you take these off me, indicating the handcuffs on her wrists.