"Goodbye, Suzanna" was intended as a self-contained piece, with Jack having expressed exactly what futures he'd allow Tabby and Suzie to have with him. For some, that implication was satisfying, but others would've preferred to see explicit consequences. Both responses are obviously valid, but for those who want more closure, this is for them:
For Suzie, time had become greasy.
She'd blink, and the road was different. The semi in front of her was suddenly an SUV, then a sedan. Road signs she shouldn't be seeing yet leapt out at her. Where did the last twenty miles go?
Nothing made sense.
He'd been so calm, but he was wrong, and she told him so, but he just...he just kept talking and the words weren't what she was expecting. They started making sense, and that was bad, but then they turned into hammer blows. Little slices of fear and pain that she didn't have an answer for. Then she was outside somehow, and he was looking, just looking at her with that face, that terrible face, and she told him it would be okay but then it was unbearable and he was crying, and he'd closed the door and it felt like a judgement.
That's when it felt like she'd done something wrong, something bad, but she hadn't done anything. It would all be okay, if she could just call her mom, but when she tried, the words came out wrong. She wanted to tell her to come home, to help dad, but she didn't answer. The voicemail had beeped at her, so she'd said...what had she said? There was screaming. Why screaming? Why would she do that? Her mom couldn't do anything with that.
She blinked again, and had taken the exit into slow city traffic. Stopping and starting. Had she taken the right exit? Someone was honking the horn and the light was green, but then it was going back to red.
He'd called her Suzanna.
He never calls her Suzanna; Always Suzie or sweetie or darling or love.
Suzie had to pull over for a minute, and haphazardly blocked a bus stop while her fists pounding on the steering wheel ineffectively. Someone was screaming again. She wasn't even sure who they were screaming at, but her phone still hadn't rung. She checked, maybe she hadn't heard it ring. She sent another message. "Call me." It joined the rest; The list was disappearing off the top of the screen.
She was okay. She must be, she was parking by the apartment. She'd got back okay. Everything was fine. That stupid woman, had she lied? Dad said she lied, and Suzie was starting to think he was right, and it wasn't okay. She was unlocking the door, and Maddie was turning to look at her funnily. Her roommate Maddie, sweet funny Madison, and she tried to tell Maddie about the terrible thing, but she was on her knees.
"Come here."
It was a good hug. She was in a blanket and the pain wouldn't go away, but Maddie kept asking her questions with a sad, serious face. Oh god. He said he hated her. At some point, there was soup, but it was hard to eat it with the shaking. It got everywhere. Maddie told her it was okay, but Suzie loved the coat and it was ruined too. Stained, just like everything else. She was there for hours, but eventually she cried herself to sleep on the couch.
It was dark when Suzie woke up, and Maddie was gone. She was alone again. She didn't feel better, but she felt different. Cleaner. No, she corrected herself, not cleaner; She was still tainted, but she could see the filth now. The stains.
That evil, selfish, thoughtless, nasty... That stupid slut. Why did she ever listen to her? Those progress selfies with her hot gym buddy, asking what she thought of Steve's looks. Sharing little details and jokes, just friendly flirting, just a harmless crush, just something your dad doesn't need to know about, something he wouldn't understand. Dad had told her the truth, though.
And she'd met him. She'd wanted to. She'd laughed with mom about how handsome and muscular and fit he was, that smug asshole. And she still didn't tell. Then it was romantic, and our little secret, and a meaningless bit of fun, and finally a fun weekend. Something to relieve the boredom. It wasn't until then, that was when she thought maybe it was going too far. But she still didn't quite say it. She'd trusted her to do the right thing, she said she would. She said she would, and Suzie had believed her.
But Suzie felt different now. There was the fire, and she wondered if dad felt it too. She felt closer to dad than she had in a long time, in years, but then she remembered, and he couldn't be further away. That's when she started to remember yesterday properly. All the things that dad had said came in bursts. How disappointed he had been.
She wanted to cry again, and maybe she was, she didn't know, but she had to tidy herself up and get some proper sleep. She stripped off as she walked, and collapsed into her own bed, but sleep wouldn't come. Well that's fine, she thought, she didn't deserve it.
Instead, she pulled the comforter around herself and stared into space. The soft warmth of the bedding was cold comfort, but it was the only thing holding her at that moment, and it wasn't enough.
Mood blackening by the second, she picked the last year apart in her mind. She'd let him down, and she'd made so many mistakes; Not just this one, either. Every little slight she could remember, all the times mom told her not to worry about what dad thought. Every poisonous whisper. She didn't even think they were deliberate, that was the kicker. Mom...mom had stopped taking dad seriously. He was... well, he was just there. Mom had convinced her to look at him the same way. To take him for granted. It wasn't Suzie's fault. It was her mom's. She knew that wasn't true, not in her heart of hearts, but if she tried really, really hard, Suzie could almost believe it.
When the sun came up, she tried calling, but it went straight to voicemail again. She kept trying, despite her father's advice, even knowing everything was already hopeless. Maybe, just maybe, there would be something mom really could do. If that was true, it needed to happen now, before the last little pieces of dad's love was gone forever. Every hour, straight to voicemail.
Maddie checked in with her at lunchtime, and half-dragged her naked ass out of bed and into pyjamas, insisting she needed to eat something. It was only strawberry jam sandwiches, but it was something, and now that she was calmer, she told her about her talk with her dad. Maddie's judgement was cruel in its simplicity, "Sounds like you've really fucked things up, the pair of you."
Suzie couldn't disagree, at least not anymore, but the fury she felt at herself was nothing compared to the ever-mounting rage she felt for her mother, something she was having to consciously keep control of. After that, Maddie reinstalled her on the now soup-free couch, wrapped in her comforter again and they half-watched a nonsensical reality TV bitchfest marathon while they talked.
Maddie shared some things about herself that Suzie hadn't known before, stuff she said was nobody's business but hers. It turned out the home Madison had grown up in was what she described as a tomb dedicated to her parents' marriage, although it hadn't always been that way. Some time around age nine, her mother moved into the guest room. Young enough, she said, for it to be normal, but old enough to remember what things had been like before that. From that point forward, there had always been a slight chill in air, an undercurrent of polite indifference lurking just under the front of cordiality and idle chatter her parents were making for her benefit. She'd asked many times why, but they were never really willing to go into it, and it was only at a family gathering when she was fifteen that she managed to corner her quite drunk aunt Stacy, her mother's sister, who told her in secret about her father's several affairs. It all made sense after that. They separated the day she moved out to college, and she'd been glad.
So her advice was simple, but a little unhelpful: "Some things are meant to end, so stay out of it. It's best not to meddle." Suzie couldn't do that, but promised her that at the very least, she wasn't going to do anything to make things worse. Not deliberately, anyway. She was going to try to be better.
By the end of that Sunday evening, she'd tried to reach her mother a dozen more times, and the fires of resentment and pain that lapped at her heart had started to temper something inside her. When she finally went to bed, she didn't feel any better and she didn't feel like sleep. The black mood haunted her, settling into her bones. She knew she was going to have to do something, anything, to fix it. She'd told her dad she could fix it. She checked the app, to see if there were any answers to the desperate pleas. All of them were still marked unread. Carefully, one-by-one, Suzie removed every unread message from the chat. Instead, she sent 'You need to talk to dad.'
She made one last phone call to that woman, one last attempt, and just like before, there was no answer. The stupid bitch was still living her wicked, hateful little fantasy. Well, she'd tried. She'd tried too much. She was done.
Something ethereal but important quietly ruptured within her, and a distant and monolithic yet inexplicable tension was released. There was one way left to fix it, even a little, but it would hurt.