I don't think I ever would have imagined this happening to me. I mean, I may have fantasized in some ways about it, but never did I think it would really truly happen. I definitely wasn't thinking of it as the four of us walked home casually from the bar after watching the game. It was the four of us – my friend Becca and her husband James, my wife Elizabeth, and I. We'd all been friends for years, but Becca and Elizabeth and I had been friends for the longest.
We were walking back to their house when it came up. We were talking about how we'd come across this website where you have to guess whether a name is a porn star name or a My Little Pony name. It sounds weird, I know, but it's actually pretty hilarious. Anyway, we had just finished laughing about some of the names we remembered when James brought it up.
"We were looking through the channel guide the other night and we found this show called 'Fuck My Wife, Please.' It's about men who like to watch as other men have sex with their wives."
His comment just sort of sat there in the air for a moment. None of us really knew what to say except to shrug it off and point out how weird some peoples' fetishes could be. But I guess even then I wondered why he'd brought it up.
I found out two days later.
I got a text on my phone from Becca. She was off work for a few days because most of the office staff were away on a conference, so she asked me to call her to chat. Having the day off myself, I did.
"Hey, Becca," I said as she answered.
"Hey, Steve." Her voice is one of a few distinct features about Becca. It's very high, very girlish. She's one of those girls who always had that high squeaky voice as a kid and it stayed that way. For some people that can be annoying, but for Becca it always seemed to convey a cuteness and innocence that fit her character.
"So, what's up? Having fun on your days off?"
"Yeah. You know. Just boring stuff, really. Shopping, getting laundry done, things like that. Actually, though, I wanted to talk to you about something."
"Sure, what's up?" I asked, curious.
"You remember the other day when James brought up that show that we saw?"
"Um, the 'Fuck My Wife' show?" I asked, a little confused.
"Yeah. Well, what he didn't say is that we've been watching it. We watched it that night, and since then we've been watching it online."
"Oh. Okay. Wow. So..."
"Well, James really likes it. He keeps talking about it, and he's been... oh gosh... I guess I can tell you this, right?"
Becca was nervous, I could tell. She and I had been friends for years and talked about a lot of things, but sex was one of those things that never really happened in polite conversation, even amongst friends. Plus, like I said, Becca is the epitome of the innocent girly girl. So, I was flabberghasted when she finally stammered out what came next.
"Okay," she sighed. "Well, the thing is that James has been thinking about it, and he wants to see someone else fu--.... have sex with me."
"Wow." I was floored. I think my jaw literally dropped at hearing that. "Wow. That's... are you okay with that? How did this come up?"
"Like I said, we watched the show. Whenever we watch it, James gets so excited..." I could tell she was nervous, and imagined her coveting her phone close to her ear as she chewed her lip. "He gets REALLY excited, and he has sex with me. We have sex on the couch or on the bed while the show is on. And we've been recording it, so we can replay it at other times of the day and do it again."
"Wow." I was speechless.
"So... anyway... James wants someone to fuck me. He wants to watch as another guy comes over and has sex with me in the bed. He won't stop talking about it. I told him that I'm not sure, but he said that I could pick who the guy was and he wouldn't care. He wants me to feel comfortable if we do this. So... I picked you."
Silence. I didn't know what to say or how to respond. Me? She picked me? Why?
"Why? Why do you want me to be the one?"
"Because, Steve, I know you. We've been friends for years, and I can't think of anyone else that I'd trust to do this with." I could hear her pleading, and her voice was quiet.
"Are you okay with this?" Now I was worried for her. Was this something that she really wanted, or just some sicko fantasy that James had and was trying to push off on her?
"Yeah," she said softly. Then louder, "Yeah. Yes. I want this. I've been thinking about it, and I do. As much as it seems weird, I get excited by it too. I mean, James and I haven't been this active in months. And, this really turns him on, and... it turns me on too. I want this."
"Wow..." I swallowed. "Okay." I flopped into the couch in our apartment, sighing and running my fingers through my hair. "What about Beth? I mean, I don't know if I feel comfortable cheating on my wife. Even if it is with a friend. And, what am I saying? It's with a friend! How am I ever going to look at you and James the same? This could change everything."
"I know, Steve. I know. But... please?" Pause. "I want you." Her voice was pleading, and the last three words had stirred even more my already rigid cock. As shocking and earth shaking as this conversation was, it wasn't an unwelcome one.
I'd fantasized about being with Becca before. Even imagined making love to her or fucking her when she was around or when I was with Elizabeth. It's almost impossible not to fantasize about her. The cute chubby girl in high school, Becca had turned into the drop dead gorgeous redhead after graduation.
She was short. 5'1" at best. Her size was only emphasized by the massive breasts she sported on her frame. A lot of times I know men exaggerate and fantasize about enormous boobs. But, whenever I fantasize or close my eyes, I imagine Becca's breasts. Perfectly round, big enough to stick out in all of her shirts, and out past the sides of her silhouette when you look at her straight on. I found one of her bras on the floor once, and quickly checked. 36DD. Huge breasts run in the family. Becca's younger sister Samantha had a breast reduction at 19. That was a sad day indeed.
In addition to her shapely frame, petite size, and girlishly cute voice, Becca was also the reddest redhead I'd ever known. Natural, orange locks contrasting against perfectly smooth, pale white skin.
She was striking. And all the fantasies I'd entertained myself with in the past now came rushing back, and I found my hand slowly massaging my cock as I thought about what this would mean.