Yep, another take on 'February Sucks.' I read the original when it was first posted and it was pretty much a "meh" experience. It seemed reconciliation was intended from the jump with nary a deviation along the way. Then, alternative versions started showing up - many taking a harder stance and a few going totally BTB. Some of the alternatives were good, some even compelling, and then there were the neithers.
So I thought 'what the fuck' why not? C'mon in, there's plenty of room in the pool. Dive in and see what you come up with.
I have chosen not to recap the lead in. We're picking this up the morning after the infamous night before. Linda is trying to convenience Jim that nothing in their marriage has changed.
Β§Β§Β§Β§Β§Β§Β§Β§Β§
"Marc (Marc LaValliere) could never love me the way you do. You do that better than I ever imagined it could be done. My body melted for him, it's true, but my body and my heart both melt for you, always."
"Do you even listen to what you're saying?" I shook my head in equal parts amazement and disgust. "You just said my love, the way I love you, the way I have loved you, is you being loved better than you could ever imagined. That's what you said. And you added 'my body and my heart both melt for you, always.' That's how you described the way I love you - right?"
"Yes. I said that and I meant it, every word."
"So by your own heart-felt statement, encapsulating all the love I am capable of giving you and the love you have for me in response to that - in your own words, and certainly by your actions!" Her eyes widen and she took a deep breath. I beat her to the climax. "My love will never be enough to keep you from cheating again. The best I could do, my best effort - it's not enough. On a night that expressed the height of my ability to love you - our special night, a night we planned for and anticipated. It wasn't enough, was it? It wasn't even close, it didn't take him the time needed to finish a drink for Miracle Marc to make you disappear from our marriage. Poof!"
"NO. No Jim, you're wrong. That's not what I meant!" Our argument went downhill from there. I answered her every declaration of love, of commitment, of 'renewed' faithfulness, and of her intention to making every effort she could to prove it with the same simple response, "Linda, I'm saying this based on my own experience, I was there with you and then I was here alone. We were prepared for a night to remember, it was to be OUR special night, and then without a glance back, you went away with another man, you fucked that man, and by your own actions and everything you've said today. It's really quite simple. Linda, I can NEVER trust you with my heart again."
In the days and weeks that followed, she came at me from every possible direction and angle. So I adapted and added to my response, "Yes, in time I can see myself coming to grips that you cheated on me, thereby destroying our marriage." She didn't like that statement. She hated it when I sometimes used, "There may come a time when I can forgive you," But, each and every answer ended with the same sentence, "I can NEVER and will NEVER trust you with my heart again."
What caused her the most trouble was how quickly I learned to state my position in a very calm, and quiet manner. I spoke simple statements of fact. And it did not help the situation that I stopped arguing against her perspective. Apparently she truly believed that her 'one night and let's not forget the next morning stand' fell under the heading; NO HARM, NO FOUL. It was clearly A ONE-OFF, a "fantasy night" one that will never happen again. So I should quit harping on old news, we're good. Let's move forward.
When she declared I will love you forever! I would agree with her and then add my simple statement. If she said, there was never a moment I did not love you. I'd say absolutely, I have no doubt you feel that is true. And then I'd throw in my simple sentence.
Sometimes she would jump in halfway through 'can NEVER and will NEVER' bristling with ferocity "stop saying that! I love you, how can you not understand that? I LOVE YOU!"
Once I really threw her for a loop. She was declaring her love - always and forever, when she asked why couldn't I accept that? And I was just about to reply when she added, "and don't say anything about trust. I get that. Well, get this - I love you - why can't you get that?"
"I do." I paused just long enough for her to react to my matrimonial reference. "I do get that. You love me - past, present, and future. Well Linda don't think for a moment that I don't love you."
Oh man, talk about cueing up the sound of a needle scratching across a vinyl record. I watched hope bloom in her eyes. "Linda, of course I love you...I will always love you. Love is not something that you can turn off. So I can say to you with sincerity and honesty, I love you Linda. I love you. But here's the problem, I'm just not IN love with you anymore. The uniqueness, the specialness that was us - that's gone, it's dead. You kill it. That love that you and I had as man and wife, that love that we vowed before God, family and friends - that love was killed, it's dead and buried. That specialness is gone. So what are you trying to do, resurrect some twisted zombie love? That love couldn't help but be a stinking, rotting corpse of what we once had? Sorry, I'm not interested."
That statement devastated her. It was more than a body blow, it looked like a deep soul smackdown. Linda was a good person, she was a good mom, she just wasn't a good wife. A part of me tried to rein myself in, because the next blow was a killer. I went for the coup de gras, "If I'd been given this script the day we were married, that after a few years of faithfulness, you'd cheat on me without even the slightest concern or consideration..."
"No...no...no...don't say it. Please don't say it..." there was a visceral, terrifying horror in her eyes.
"I'd have turned around and walked away. Not counting the kids, there is not enough good left in our marriage to balance out the evil you brought into it. Our marriage is dead Linda. Period, end of story, our marriage is over. All of this is, all of my efforts since that night are focused on one thing and one thing only - protecting the kids. We owe them that. They are the only future that concerns me. As far as you and I go, we're done."
I suppose the word 'catatonic' best describes Linda's reaction. Unmoving, unblinking, unresponsive.
What didn't surprised me was how my clearly stated position apparently cut the last strings of friendship within our group. Sure, ever since that night those friendships had been strained for many, many weeks. Once this last statement of mine made the rounds, I became persona non grata. I half expected to find my photo on the wall of the local Post Office. I was public enemy numero uno.
The women, many who had flirted with me in one way or another over the years looked at me with undisguised loathing. And I say with no small degree of sadness that the husbands - to a 'man' - meekly toed the line. Friendships were severed, once dynamic relationships withered quickly. Curiously I did not mourn the loss.
Okay, that last part was bullshit. It hurt at first. These were my friends (or so I thought), guys I trusted, yet they casually cut me loose. Over the days and weeks that followed I learned to live without their support. In the passage of time I learned how I could look at them and find myself less than impressed. The simple truth was this, within days of Linda's one night stand I had seen many of the friends who had been with us that night as less than worthy of my friendship or any other consideration. That I looked on them with undisguised disdain was fuel for the fire. To the wives I was a horrible, selfish husband. To the husbands I was at best an unlucky man, at worst a cuckold, and by all someone to be kept at more than arms distance to avoid any chance of contagion.