"Think about it, will ya Sam? You can't tell me the thought never crossed your mind."
That was Julie, my wife of six years, trying to convince me that we should entertain the thought of swapping with another couple. I wasn't so keen on the idea; sure, there were times I thought it might be fun to get a strange piece of ass. Between the year of courtship and the six years of marriage, it had been seven years of exclusivity with one woman.
And during those seven years there were a number of women who made it very clear that their bodies were available for my pleasure; and I admit to being tempted, but only tempted. Too many of my friends' marriages went into the crapper because one (or both) of the spouses who had vowed fidelity couldn't resist when a bit of strange came their way.
I have to admit I'm not a total saint; my virtuous behavior was partially due to the simple fact that Julie is an absolute knockout. Pretty face, eyes you can get lost in, a body that belongs in Playboy, and a libido that still made my head spin - why tempt fate? Besides, although the one aspect of swapping might have some allure, the half where I get to fuck another man's wife; the other half just left me cold - the part where the other man gets to fuck my wife. Definitely not one of my fantasies.
But here was my wife trying to convince me that swapping might be fun. Obviously, all the work I'd put into making Julie happy and content with our sex life was all for naught. So, I was doing my best to give Julie reasons why this wouldn't work. My arguments weren't the best, this had come out of nowhere, I had just finished my second IPA; and I admit, I may not be my best at providing counter-points when I'm emotional (or after two high octane ales).
"Julie; I have no desire to watch some asshole fuck you!"
"OK, then we'll do it in separate rooms."
"I don't want some guy fucking you in our bed!"
"You take the master bedroom; the other guy and I can use the guest room."
"What about diseases?"
"We'll make everybody have tests and get the results before the swap."
"Julie, you seem to have an awful lot of the answers. How long have you been thinking about this?"
"Only a couple weeks now, Sam; but I've been reading up on it. I wouldn't want to do anything to jeopardize our marriage."
"You don't think fucking another guy isn't going to jeopardize our marriage?"
"Not if we both agree to it beforehand and we both get something out of it. It's sharing, not cheating."
Julie saw my hesitation. Damn, I can't believe she's bringing this up after I finished that second ale. It wasn't fair, or maybe that was the reason for her bringing it up now.
"Tell you what Sam. We'll take it slow. I'll put an ad in the Real Detroit Weekly; we'll meet some prospective couples. If it doesn't feel right, we'll cut it off. No harm, no foul. Now, let's go to bed."
Like a lamb to slaughter I allowed my wife to take my hand and lead me upstairs into our bedroom. The combination of the beer, the emotions, the sight of my wife stripping her clothes (yes, even after all these years that sight could make a fool out of me), and the blood following south to my little head guaranteed I was a sucker for Julie and her grand designs.
I did my best to rock Julie's world that night. I played with those perfect C cup breasts, light love bites on the nipples, a good fifteen minutes kissing her clit and shoving my tongue up her vagina. I tried to remember past Super Bowl scores since the first Packers' victory just to hold off cumming too early as I fucked Julie in at least seven of the Kama Sutra positions. I made her scream and gyrate, twist and shout. I did everything I could until she begged for mercy at three in the morning; everything and anything to make Julie understand she didn't need another man for sexual satisfaction.
Call me stupid, naïve, whatever; but imagine my surprise when the next week Julie sat down for dinner and gave me the news.
"We've already received fourteen decent responses to our ad."
Yea, like I said - stupid. "What ad?"
"Our ad in the Real Detroit, silly."
Julie got up from the table and pulled the latest issue of the Real Detroit out of her briefcase. She handed it to me opened at the Personals. There, circled under the heading 'couples seeking couples':
"Late 20's buff, attractive, clean, non-bi white couple, seeking same for swap of mates."
I read the damn thing at least three times.
"Julie, I don't remember saying 'yes' to this. What the hell?"
"Sam; I just figured it got you so worked up last weekend that you were on board. Damn, you were hard for hours. I could tell you were thinking about it the entire time you were fucking me; your eyes had a glassy, far-off look to them; I knew you were picturing yourself with somebody new."
"I was not! Dammit; I was trying to remember football scores so I wouldn't cum too fast."
Julie actually had the nerve to start laughing at this. I began to pout, Julie quit laughing, sat in my lap and gave me a kiss.
Julie pulled my cock out of my pants and stroked it until it was hard. She used the other hand to hike up her skirt and move the fabric of her thong panties aside. She dropped down on my cock and continued down until our pubic bones met. Damn, she was wet! Looking into my eyes, Julie returned to her counter-point.
"Well, in that case, thank you. I must have cum a half-dozen times that night. I take it you were trying to impress me with your virility and stamina."
"Damn right I was."
"Look Sam, I didn't bring up swapping because I'm dissatisfied. I thought it would add an element of fun and excitement. I figured we could have a little fun with it before we started our family and became the typical suburban family with the minivan and strollers." Julie hesitated for just a moment before continuing her spiel, "Tell you what. Let's just try it and see how it goes. It will give us a chance to bust through conventionality, just for a while."
Didn't I say it already? Stupid, naïve me. I didn't say 'no' and the train kept a rolling.
It didn't take long for Julie to arrange a meeting with the couple she chose from all the responses. The following weekend Julie and I were preparing the house for an evening of entertainment with our new 'friends'. There were two trays of hors d'oeuvres, plus open bottles of Merlot and Pinot Blanc on the table in front of the fireplace. Two love seats sitting on either side of the table. Everything was ready to meet the lucky couple, everything but me. I kept wondering how pissed Julie would be if (or when) I threw the would-be swappers back out the door.
But I didn't. The doorbell rang and both Julie and I answered the door together. Kyle and Susan were standing there; Kyle with a great big smile on his face, Susan looking like I did, as if a guillotine would suddenly appear and we were the condemned. Kyle had a dozen roses in one hand and a bottle of Burgundy in the other; Julie waved them in. No sooner did the door close than Kyle handed the bottle to me, then with the free hand he hugged Julie. Susan stood there frozen, obviously unsure how to greet me.
They were an attractive couple. Kyle was at least five inches taller than my 5'10", obviously a gym rat or some sort of athlete, and he had that handsome, rugged look that women seem to cream over. Susan was a babe, though she'd be prettier if she smiled. She did give Julie a run for her money in the body department, maybe a bit smaller in the bust, but the entire package was something most men would drool over.
Introductions were made, the wine was poured. We sat and chatted, each of the couples on their own loveseat, but Julie sat across from Kyle and Susan was opposite me. I was about to refresh the wine in everyone's glass when Julie stood up and announced, "Well, we all know why we're here." She reached across to grab Kyle's hand and pulled him up off the couch, "Let's take this into the bedroom, Kyle." She looked over to me with a smile on her face. "See you two in the morning."
Stunned, incoherent, I just sat there watching the two of them walk back to the guest bedroom. I finally snapped out of it and looked over at Susan.
"What just happened?"
"I'm surprised they lasted that long. I've never seen Kyle so excited; he's practically walked around all day with a hard on."
"Have you two done this before?"
"No, Kyle came home last week with a copy of the Real Detroit and told me he answered your ad. Said we were going to 'open' our marriage. I didn't get a choice in the matter. You don't seem too keen on this; why'd you place the ad if you're so hesitant?"
"I didn't, Julie did. Like you, I got blindsided by this whole thing. Look, don't take this wrong, because you're a very attractive woman, but if it's OK with you, I'd just as soon spend some time getting to know each other. Would you mind if we held off before heading to the bedroom?"