It was supposed to just be a fun weekend getaway with my wife's college roommates. This year was the 20th reunion from their college days and it was four couples renting a beach house. I had first met each of the other three girls -- Nicole, Brie and Amber -- at our wedding as each was in my wife's bridal party but didn't know any of them too well and our wedding weekend was kind of a blur. At the time all three were already married so I met their husbands as well that wedding weekend. One of the girls, Nicole, had recently gotten divorced and brought her new boyfriend, Ted, to the reunion. Ted, who had just turned 53, was a decade older than anyone in the group but seemed to fit in well even though he was pretty quiet. Bill was Brie's husband and John was Amber's husband and they had both been married about 15 years.
The first night everyone was unwinding and the drinks were flowing. We were out on the porch with the water and the moon in the background, little bit of music and a lot of conversation -- which over time started to get sexual in content.
The girls started busting each other's chops about their college days and each of the guys had some good laughs at their expense. My wife, Jill, wasn't overtly sexual but was no prude either. I didn't complain about our sex life though it wasn't anything I would consider noteworthy.
One of the husbands had the idea that the men should ask questions about their college days and the girls would all write down the answer and reveal at the same time. It seemed like harmless fun and after some back and forth they all agreed. I was somewhat excited because I didn't know much about my wife's college days and she wasn't one of those women that shared a lot about her past -- just wasn't her thing.
John had the first question for the girls.
"Which of you had the most one-night stands?"
They all giggled and immediately wrote down their answers and all revealed Brie's name who was now slightly embarrassed.
The next question came from Bill who asked what the kinkiest thing they did as a group was. They again all answered the same though in different words from each other -- but bottom line is they all liked watching and sneaking peeks when the others were getting fucked. I didn't see that one coming. In fact they said every once in awhile someone needed to have a couch night where they fucked out in the main room and told the guy the rest of the girls were in bed asleep so it was no big deal if they asked and then the others could get a look.
I was next and who had slept with the most guys. Two answered Amber and two answered Nicole and some conversation ensued before Nicole accepted the fact it was probably her.
Ted was up next and asked if any of them had hooked up with each other. To our dismay none said yes and all admitted they just liked the men. It was a good question though all the men agreed had a disappointing answer.
It was back to John and he wanted to know which of them liked the longest sex sessions. Laughter broke out immediately and I saw my wife look down and was the only one not laughing with the others. I couldn't believe the answer would be her and our sessions were always pretty quick. When the cards flipped over I was stunned as not only did they each say Jill but the other three girls wrote "Jill the All-Night Thrill" an apparent nickname she had earned.
The girls enjoyed my wife's sudden discomfort as they reveled in saying how Jill would fuck through the night right up until time to go to class the next morning. I couldn't believe it.
The next question from Bill brought more new information, as he wanted to know who was the biggest size queen in the group. The three girls all smirked again and wrote down Jill and Jill tried to say it was Nicole but none of them were buying it though Nicole said she had a newfound appreciation for it. My guess was that had to make Ted feel good inside.
I could tell my wife was embarrassed that I was learning things about her for the first time in such a way but not wanting to make her feel bad I just played along best as I could.
Over the next hour we learned the Nicole was the first to sleep with a black guy, loved fucking in high heels and liked anal the most. Brie was the only one to sleep with someone on the football and basketball team and was far and away the biggest masturbator in the group. Amber had cheated the most on boyfriends, was the only one to sleep with brothers and liked to role-play.
As for my wife it was a laundry list of things I learned about her that night. Not only was she the size queen that liked to fuck all night but she also was the only one to fuck a professor (two of them), had the most 3-ways, gave the best oral and was by far the loudest and the one that could talk the dirtiest during sex.
I wasn't sure which reveal floored me most as none would have been things I would have guessed. Our sessions weren't long, I rarely got oral, I was maybe a little under average in the size department and she barely ever made a noise when we had sex let alone talked dirty. My head was swimming with this new information and I was wondering why our sex life didn't resemble this former woman at all.
The alcohol was also having its effect on all of us and Bill blurted out, "Damn I am horny as hell, so who are we going to watch on the couch?"
Everyone kind of giggled but there was also an awkward silence after like we all wondered at the same time is that really going to happen.
Brie finally spoke up and said she wanted to watch one of them and that she missed that. Amber said we should all draw straws to see who had to perform for the group. There was another silent pause as everyone kind of looked at each other again.
Bill broke the ice, "so how do we do this?"
Nicole said she had an idea and she'd be right back. She went inside and after a minute or two she came back out with four straws.
"I've got four straws in my hand and I cut one straw, whoever draws it goes to the couch," she said.
"Are the men or the women drawing?" asked John.
Nicole stunned us when she said; "Men draw first and then the women. Whichever man gets short straw eliminates their partner."
Now it really got quiet and I looked at my wife who was looking nervous and she finally spoke up.
"Wait a minute did any of us actually agree to any of this?" she asked.
After a brief silence Brie said, "I'm in."
He husband followed, "Me too."
John and Amber followed suit and Nicole was holding the straws and it was her idea so had to figure we had her answer. She was looking at Ted to respond and he finally nodded. That left my wife and I as the only ones. I looked at her and felt trapped and thought she did to. I gave her that unspoken up to you look.
She sighed and said, "Ok, fine, I'm in."
At that point I had no choice. Even though I thought Brie, Amber and Nicole were all hot and under different circumstances I'd love to fuck them this was one of those times when I just hoped my wife and I both would be watching this unfold.
"Ok boys, line up," said Nicole.
Bill was surely the most excite and picked first. He held it up but no one knew if that was a long or short straw until the next draw. John went next and when he held it up it was same size as the straw Bill picked. That meant either Ted or me would get the short one. I was dreading this and my heart was pounding but I nodded for Ted to pick first. He did and to my great relief he held up the short straw.
