All parties are over 18 years old and is a mix of truth and fiction. Please keep any snarky comments to yourselves.
If you've read "Who was I in Love with?" this continues the tale of my girlfriend, Donna, and I, Alex, exploring our relationship boundaries and expanding our sexual horizons. That story contained a gangbang/train and interracial sex. I was a freshman at the University of Florida in Gainesville and Donna was a high school senior in Miami. The year was 1971.
Part 2
Wednesday:
I had made dinner reservations for 8pm at an Italian restaurant in Coral Gables. I was showered, dressed and ready to go when she arrived at 7:20. I opened the door just as my dad came into the entry hall to see who had arrived.
Donna was wearing a white blouse, lavender bra, black flared miniskirt and mid-sized heel sandals- the same outfit she wore in Gainesville when she did her strip tease for Tommy and me. She knew this would get a rise out of me.
The blouse was not tied under her breasts and was buttoned up demurely. She had not worn the thigh high stockings from that day. That would have been too risquΓ© around my folks or at the restaurant. Dad was pleased to see her and gave her a hug and asked her to sit and stay a bit before we had to go. I sat next to Donna on the couch and dad was in a chair across from us. I knew why he chose that chair.
My dad was a very good-looking man. He had aged well and had distinguished salt and pepper sideburns worn in the day. Donna had previously told me she thought both of my folks were very good looking. Once, when we were talking about this, she had even said, "I'd sleep with him."
Dad loved to have his boys bring our girlfriends to the house. I remember overhearing a call he made to a neighbor friend one weekend afternoon telling the neighbor to come over because John and a buddy had their girlfriends over to swim. The two "dads" sat in the family room "watching TV" while the girls, in their bikinis, played in the pool and lay in the sun. The drapes were open and with the glare of the pool deck you couldn't see into the room. The girls couldn't see the two 40 somethings ogling them with drinks in hand.
Anyway, we visited for about ten minutes while I watched my dad's eyes. He was trying to be careful with my mom and I there, but I could see him, occasionally, drop his eyes to her legs as we talked. Donna was careful to keep her legs together as we all chatted. It wasn't until we were getting up to leave that she, first, squeezed my hand and then coyly "shot him the beaver", as we called it back then, as she slid off the couch to stand. His eyes widened but he kept his composure as we said our goodbyes and he gave her a hug. I'm sure he had just seen the lacy lavender panties that went with the bra.
Donna handed me the keys to her car, and it wasn't until I opened the door for her to get in that I saw what my dad had seen. Donna was not wearing panties! Her blonde bush and wet slit met my gaze.
"Shit!", I said, "You just showed your naked pussy to my dad!"
She looked up at me giggling and said, "I think your mom is going to have a good time tonight. I doubt he'll say anything. After all, it was just an accident.", she said innocently. "I thought you liked me to be a tease?"
"I do", I started, "but don't flash your naked pussy to my dad. Can you do that, please? Grabbing Larry's dick today is another thing. Were you flashing your bush at the guys at work before you came over, too? We need to talk about how far this game goes. There need to be limits, babe."
"Yes sir!", Donna said sitting up straight and adding a salute.
I got the envelope out of the shrubs and handed it to Donna as I got in the car. "No peeking. Let's look at these together at dinner," I said.
"Ok," Donna answered. "I'm dying to see how they turned out."
Snuggling up close to me she had her tongue in my ear and her hand on my cock before we were out of sight of the house. Listening to an 8-track tape of "What's Going On" by Marvin Gaye, we made the drive to dinner.
As we drove, I opened by asking Donna the big question on my mind, "Are you fucking anybody else?"
"NO," Donna said pulling back from me. "I haven't had sex with anyone else since I met you, well, except for Gainesville."
"Ok. OK. I believe you," I responded. "It just seems like you've changed since then. Larry even told me that you seem preoccupied with sex."
"What did you expect? That weekend was pretty wild.", Donna answered. "I have NEVER felt so alive or felt the rush I did being ganged up on in your dorm. Remember, I started liking boys when other girls still thought they had cooties.", she added.
Donna paused a bit and then said, "I think I might be a nymphomaniac... After we make love all I think about is when can we do it again. I get a rush out of getting you all excited and seeing the way you look at me when you cum. An orgasm is the best feeling in the world to me. I crave them and masturbate every day, sometimes twice. I enjoy the feeling of knowing guys want me and I feed that by teasing them. The feelings are hard to resist. Oh god, I'm getting wet just thinking about it."
I looked at her and then back at the road. What I saw in her face was a lustful girl who genuinely loved me but was a bit out of control. I knew I played a part in releasing that in her. The sex I was getting was great and, I had to admit, I got off on hearing her stories and watching her drive men crazy. She exuded sex, and I was the recipient of her all-consuming desire. I recognized I was the same way. I was a typical horny 19-year-old kid with sex on my mind A LOT. I was just realizing that girls, particularly Donna, could feel that way, too.
My hope was that her desires wouldn't turn her into "the class slut". I really didn't want to be with a girl with that kind of reputation with my friends and family knowing it, too.
There was a long pause before I said, "Donna, I love you and want to be with you. I think we both know that what happened in the dorm and with Tommy is not an everyday thing. And the truth is, I got off watching you getting fucked. I like that you're mine and that other men think you're hot. Your stories about teasing teachers or guys at school or the guys at work make my dick so hard. You're so damn beautiful and sexy."
"So, you don't mind that I'm this way?", she asked. "Are you saying I can fuck whoever I want?"
"No! I didn't say that.", I answered.
"OK. Good.", she started. "Then, what are you saying?"
"I think we just need to take a step back. Think about who you're teasing and the consequences. And no fucking anyone without me being there." I added. "The fact that you are an exhibitionist makes me horny as hell. The fact that you love sex makes me horny as hell. Truth be told, I love you just the way you are."