[This was originally an erotic story I wrote for my wife. It's my first attempt at a submission on literotica.com, so please vote. Big thanks to KiaraNightshadow for help with editing!]
I had met Shelly at work about six months ago. We co-worked a couple of cases, so spent a fair bit of time talking about personal stuff, just to avoid continually focusing on the stress of the job. Shelly was a fitness fanatic, so would fairly often turn up at work in a bit of a sweat, having run from home. Or, she would go to the gym at lunchtime and put her exercise gear on before leaving the office. I can't deny that it was impossible not to look at her firm arse when she was wearing tight jogging bottoms, but beyond that she just wasn't my type at all.
(I've always preferred women like you. Curvy, brunette. Big boobs. And a bum so squeezy I could just take a bite out of it!)
It turns out that Shelly is married, but is pretty convinced that she is gay. She's told her husband and she says that the only reasons they are still together is because they are still pretty good friends and they have a daughter together. "Besides", she said, "if I close my eyes it's not too tough to imagine that it's Angelina Jolie down there. A tongue's a tongue, after all!" She laughed, but then looked embarrassed and blushed a little.
I added, "Sure, a tongue's a tongue, but I'm pretty sure I'd prefer Angelina down there, to Brad Pitt, no matter how good my imagination was!"
The reality was that I actually had thought about a guy "down there". I'd thought about it ever since I saw some soft-core porn in the 80's. There was a scene set in a swimming pool, with half a dozen men and half a dozen women all naked. One of the more erotic scenes involved a guy sitting on the edge of a pool, with his legs in the water. A gorgeous blond woman with full breasts and stunning eyes sat down next to him and they began kissing straight away. He began caressing her breasts, whilst they snogged and her hand worked its way down his body towards his balls, under the water. She cupped and gently rubbed them whilst spreading her legs.
Someone under the water then swam towards him and came up between his legs. His head titled backwards and it was obvious that he was being sucked off. The blonde next to him continued to kiss him whilst someone else swam in between her legs and began licking her and sticking a finger inside her. The two bodies in the water swapped places after a while, with the man and woman oblivious as to who was doing what, both lost in the decadence of being pleasured by a stranger under the water. The guy continued to squeeze her tits with one hand, whilst the other held the head between his legs firmly in place. He then let out a sudden shout of ecstasy and shot his load into the mouth of his Pleasurer. It was only at the point that he looked down and was shocked to discover that it was another guy.
I was shocked as well, but mainly by the realization that I still found the entire scene a real turn-on. I'm thoroughly straight, but it was difficult to avoid the logic that if you can't see the person sucking you, what does it matter if it's a guy or a girl?
Shelly said, "Well, that's why I only *think* I'm gay. You'd never get me pushing Brad away!"
"A tongue's a tongue", I laughed.
"Exactly!" said Shelly.
Over time, Shelly and I became good friends and would often have a laugh on the way to meetings. Our conversation became more natural and less personal, but every now and then one of us would tease the other about 'Brad' or 'Angelina'. Shelly even said to me at one point, "Look, you know full well that you wouldn't turn Brad Pitt away any more than I would to Angelina!"
I brushed it off by saying, "Sounds like a pretty glitzy foursome to me!" and left it at that.
******
Tonight was the night that Shelly was due for dinner. She had been through a rough patch at work and confided that she was on the verge of breaking-up with her husband, so without thinking I invited her round to spend Friday night with us.
It had taken a couple of hours for you to get over the idea of me inviting Shelly without checking with you, but you seemed to be coming round to it. When you came out of the shower, you brushed past me on your way to the bedroom. "You know how I said you owe me, for not checking with me first?" you asked.
"Yeah?..."
"Well, I've devised the perfect punishment", you said with a smile.
"Okay, this sounds a little scary."
You looked me dead in the eyes and said, "I am going to make this night torture for you." I looked at you suspiciously and you continued, "I've still not decided if I'm gonna go commando or not, but I'm definitely going to be wearing that skirt that you like. Oh, and the boots!"
There was no denying that you had come up with a pretty painful punishment. You only ever went commando when you had already decided to be a little freaky. And as for the boots... damn, they drove me crazy! I began to suspect that this would be a night I would remember for some time to come.
There was then a knock at the door and you rushed upstairs, telling me to open the door and pour some glasses of wine. I opened the door to see Shelly there in a tight, shoulder-less blue dress that ended quite a way above her knees. I couldn't help looking up and down, whilst thinking that no one would be in any doubt that she worked that body hard at the gym. I invited her into the lounge and asked if she fancied a drink.
"Oh, yes! Anything very strong," she said with a smile.
I guessed that she had already had a few drinks, but didn't think another would hurt. So, I poured a couple of long white wines into our goblet-sized glasses and got myself a beer. "Take a seat", I said.
At that point you walked into the room and Shelly gave a long low whistle, "Ooh, I love those boots." I was surprised by how appreciatively she was looking at you, but figured that girls compliment each other like that all of the time, so could get away with being more blatant than guys.
"Thanks", you said and sat down next to her. "So, you must be Shelly?" you asked.
"I am, but I've gotta tell you that in boots like that you can call me whatever you like!" You both laughed and I wondered why I was the only one feeling a little bit awkward.
You looked at Shelly's long smooth legs and said, "I normally feel too conscious of myself to wear skirts, but the boots kinda cover-up quite a bit."
"What have you got to feel self-conscious about?" Shelly asked. I nearly spat my drink out when she stroked her way up your boots, over your knee and onto your thigh, saying, "I love your legs."
"You're kidding me?" you said. "I would die for legs like yours!
"Well, it's amazing what a bit of fake tan and a close shave can do." she said. At that, she put her leg across your lap, as if offering you to stroke it. You did so and nodded, saying, "Feels pretty perfect to me!"
She left her leg resting across your knee and then explained that her legs should be much smoother than they were as she'd had plenty of practice at shaving, because she shaved practically every hair on her body. I coughed back my drink and the two of you laughed.