Debbies New Lover 1

The following story starts off the morning after Debbie's first gangbang and Daniel's surprise. One of the participants of the aforementioned stories is named Tony, aka Horse. He had left his phone number for Debbie with Jim. Jim was the proprietor of the events of that evening. Jim had given Debbie Horse's number, as well as his own.

At the time, Debbie and I had an arrangement. I had started to share my wife with a friend whose name is Steve about a year and a half prior. After a little over a year, Steve had gotten engaged and had to end the relationship we had. A few months afterwards we had our eyes on the lead singer of a local band that we followed; his name was Andy.

We had gone out with our friends Carl and Jen one evening to see Andy's band play. I had hoped to get something started, but to my surprise, my wife as well as Carl's wife got hooked up with a couple of woman. Their names are Cassidy, Cas for short, and Magdalena, Maggie for short.

We ended up going home with Cas. Carl and Jen took Maggie home.

Debbie had her first lesbian experience that night. I also got to participate in bed with her and Cas.

Andy was now temporarily forgotten as Cas became our focus. We had an ongoing relationship where we had threesomes as well as each of us spending time alone with her. Now my wife was sharing me.

The thing is, Cas is actually a fuck-buddy of Andy's. On one of my alone times with Cas, two things happened. One, she asked me to take her anal virginity, which I did with pleasure, and two, I made arrangements for Debbie's birthday. Those arrangements that I made with Cas were setting Debbie up with Andy.

On her birthday she was supposed to hook up with Cas for some afternoon fun, or so she thought. When she arrived at Cas's place, Andy was there waiting.

Both Cas and Andy told her I set it up, and then Cas left them alone. After she left, nature took its course and Debbie took him in all three of her holes.

So now the only issue we had was Andy's reluctance to engage in a threesome. Unlike Steve, who participated in double penetrations and split roasts with Debbie and myself, Andy wasn't so inclined.

Andy was obviously good with a threesome with Cas and Debbie, but apparently not with another guy as the other participant. He participated in two foursomes with me, Debbie, and Cas. But I and he were never on the same girl, or did he share the same hole after I was in it. At least I did get to see him fuck Debbie and give her several orgasms.

Andy on one of his and Debbie's alone times convinced her to be gangbanged by him and seven other guys. She told us about it some time later. She told me that as usual, Andy again was first inside her pussy, and then the second time he climaxed in her mouth. Apparently no sloppy seconds for him.

Debbie had made plans for me that would keep me busy while her gangbang was happening. She had set me up for an evening with Cas and Maggie. We of course had a lot of fun as she was doing the same getting fucked by eight guys.

She came home, and the three of us were waiting, all nude. The girls took Debbie to the bedroom, and I got to watch the three of them go at it. Debbie had semen in her pussy, as evidenced on her panties. I did not know at the time that it was mostly from Jim, who was also the organizer for the band.

Debbie got to go down on another woman's pussy only for the second time ever that night. It was exciting to watch the three of them in a triangle, eating each other's pussies. Eventually I joined in; I had already cum three times: the last time was in Debbie's pussy after she got home. The prior two were in Maggie's pussy and then in her ass.

It turned out that I was the first guy to have anal sex with her, so technically all three woman with me that night got anally deflowered by my cock.

The three girls started out our session, by sucking my cock, all of them side by side, taking turns; it was amazing. I ended up fucking Cas's then Maggie's pussies, finally finishing in my wife Debbie's. I had no idea that several men had cum inside of her just hours ago.

We all slept in the same bed that night, with Debbie and myself in the middle, Cas was next to me and Maggie was next to Debbie.

In the morning I got up and started a pot of coffee. While in our kitchen, Cas came out of the bedroom, still naked, just like I was. She came up to me, hugged me, and kissed me. She then said, "Good morning, lover."

Our relationship with her was very intense. We had grown to have feeling for her. She has told us both she is in love with us. We purchased a bigger bed so it would be easier for her to spend the night with us.

I say to her, "Good morning, babe. Are Debbie and Maggie still sleeping?"

She says, "No, they just started having sex."

"Oh, why didn't you join them?"

"Because I wanted to be with you. You haven't cum inside of me yet."

I don't say anything, I just go up to her and kiss her while picking her up. She spreads her legs around me as I carry her to the kitchen table and sit her down. I go down on her pussy first; she is very wet. As I eat her out, I hear Maggie having an orgasm in the bedroom. Debbie is once again enjoying a new pussy.

Soon I have Cas climaxing and squirting in my face. I take most of it in my mouth, but some ends up on the table and the floor. I stand up and I move my torso between her legs and kiss her; my cock is now against her pussy. Cas takes hold of my cock and places it against her pussie's entrance. I slide into her and start to fuck her on my kitchen table.

I hear Debbie climaxing from the bedroom. Her and Maggie are clearly enjoying themselves, as I am enjoying Cas.

I fuck Cas for a couple of minutes and we kiss. She moves her mouth to my ear and whispers, "I love you, Daniel."

As mentioned earlier, she has said this to us both several times now. The truth was we both had feeling for her that ran deep. Also, as mentioned earlier, it is complicated.

Before I could say anything, Debbie and Maggie walked into the kitchen. Maggie says, "Well, it looks like you two are busy."

She laughs, and Debbie says with a smile, "Mind if we watch?"

I say, "Sure."

Cas lays back on the table, her legs spread apart, giving the girls a great view of my cock fucking her pussy.

Debbie, stands on my left, she starts to kiss and nibble on my ear. She asks, "Does her pussy feel good babe?"

I say, "Yes, her pussy feels real good. I am going to cum in her pussy soon."

I pick up the pace, and Cas moans loudly. She has another orgasm, squirting more fluid on me and my table.

She feels so good, and it becomes too much for me to hold. I start to moan, "I'm cumming, ladies!"

I shoot my load deep into Cas as Debbie and Maggie watch. As I thrust in and out of her, my cum appears around my cock and her pussy.

When I pull out, two things happen: first, Debbie takes my cum and pussy-juice covered cock into her mouth to clean it, and second, Maggie went down on Cas's pussy for the same reason. They both get to enjoy the taste of our combined sex.

Afterwards we all went out on our deck with coffee cups in hand. Debbie told us about her time with Andy. Her story wasn't even close to what had actually happened the prior evening, but she did tell a good story, even though it wasn't the full story.

Cas and Maggie eventually showered and left, but not before some more hot lesbian loving took place in our bed between the three of them. I joined in at some point and wound up leaving another load in Maggie. This time Debbie ate my cum out of her pussy, and Cas's mouth cleaned my cock.

When they left we all exchanged hugs, and Maggie tells me, "Cas is right. You are good in bed."

I smile saying, "Thank you Mags. You're pretty good yourself."

Cas then comes up and hugs me. I whisper in her ear, "I love you too, Cassidy."

She pulls back, looks up at me and smiles.

Cas and Maggie leave, and now Debbie and I are alone.

We hadn't showered yet, so we decide to jump in and shower together. After some groping and mutual washing of each other's private areas, we get out, staying nude. We decided to go back out on the deck with some fresh coffee.

I told her about my time with the girls before she got home. I then asked her for more details about her evening with Andy.

She tells me he took her in all of her holes, and he climaxed for the first time down her throat. Two out of the three would end up being true.

She seemed a little distant when it came to talking about her evening. I ask, "Was everything okay last evening between you and Andy?"

She said, "It was, but I am thinking of ending the relationship with him. Mostly because he isn't into spending time with both of us. Don't get me wrong; the sex with him is good, but he is a selfish lover.

I ask her, "He hasn't done anything bad to you, has he?"

"No, he hasn't. I just know it has to be a disappointment for you.

"Well, I do wish we had a situation like we had when Steve was involved in our relationship. At the end of the day, I like sharing you, but what I mostly want is for you to be happy and have fun."

Debbie is quiet for a moment, then she says, "I still think It would be best to end it with him. After we should find someone to replace him, if that is okay and you would want to, that is."

I think, wow, even though she wants to end it with Andy, she then wants to find another guy to take his place. I find it so hot that she still wants a guy on the side.

I say, "Honey, anything you want to do is okay with me."

She smiles and appears like she wants to say something. She again looks deep in thought.

When she starts to speak again, she changes the subject, and she says, "Are we still going to see Andy's band next week?"

"If you would like to, of course we can."

She says, "Yes, I would. I think that is when I should tell him."

"Okay, that sounds like a plan. Is Cas still going?"

"I would imagine she is."

"We should pick her up that night and bring her home with us."

Smiling, she says, "What do you have in mind?"

Well, the usual, but I think we should also address the elephant in the room, so to speak."

Debbie asks, "Did she tell you she loves you today?"

"Yes, she did."

"She told me also, and I told her the same back."

"I did too."

"Is it weird, that we are doing this?"

"It is different, no doubt about it. I feel wrong about it and also right about it. I just don't like feeling as though I am betraying you."

"I understand; it is a little easier for me and her, as we are both female, and woman wear their emotions on their sleeves. I admit I do have feeling for her. Shit, who am I kidding? I am in love her, and I am okay with you having those same feelings for her too, and it is okay for you to show them. You are not betraying me.

I think for a second about what Debbie just said. I have to admit, I do love Cas. It may have started out as just something sexual, but it has blossomed into something so much more than that.

I just simply say, "I guess its okay for the both of us to love her."

"I agree, and just so you know, she doesn't fool around with anyone else on the side unless you or I are with her.

"Really, she doesn't? I did not know that."

"Yes, she said she is ours now. Tell me, what would you think about her living with us?"

"You know, to be honest with you, I have thought a lot about that, and I would really love it. The two of you are very romantic lovers, and I love it when I get to join in. I am pretty sure we would love Cas living with us."

"I know I would, and I would want us to be equal though; she wouldn't be here to be our toy to play with when we want. I will treat her like we are married, and I want you to do the same; she will be our wife. I want you to openly say you love her, because I will be doing it all the time. Do you think you can love us both equally?"

I thought about that, and I have to say I really do and can love them equally.

I say, "Yes, babe, I will be both of your husband, and she will be our wife. I promise I will be loving to you both. Do you think she will go for this arrangement?"

"I hope so; I am going to ask her later today."

We spent the rest of the day recuperating, and I had been thinking about the situation with Cas. I know we wouldn't be able to be legally married, but I still wanted to buy her a wedding ring. Debbie liked the idea, and we decide to hold off on asking her till the following weekend.

Cas came back over in the evening. We hung out, had some dinner, and had some drinks. We, of course, ended up in bed, and she spent the night with us. She left in the morning.

It was difficult not to tell her what was on our minds, but we wanted it to be special. We were now 100% sure about what we wanted to do; we only hoped she would say yes.

On Sunday we went shopping for a ring. Debbie knew her size: she and Cas had gone shopping at our local mall and happened into a jewelry store and wound up trying on rings among other items. It turned out they have the same ring size.

We found a beautiful ring with a fair amount of diamonds. The sales man was confused since my wife had a wedding ring on her finger, but he was sure happy to make the sale.

We decided that Debbie should propose first. We may have been in unexplored territory, but still we were very excited about doing this. I even researched doing a ceremony. I had found a place that did unconventional and unofficial marriages for people of alternative lifestyles. They said they would be happy to do a ceremony for the three of us.

Now all we had to do was wait until next Saturday.

---------------

Saturday finally arrived, and it was time to go pick up Cas. We went to dinner at a local eatery. I thought Debbie was going to ask her at the restaurant, but it didn't happen. After dinner we headed to the venue where Andy's band was playing.

The girls were drinking, and I was the designated driver. Cas was looking real good, and so was Debbie. Several guys and some girls were checking them out.

The band came out and started to perform. Cas wanted to go up to the stage, but Debbie was hesitant. She finally went up with her, and I stayed at the table and just observed.

The girls seemed to be having fun, but something was a little off with Debbie. She seemed distracted, probably because of Andy and also her intentions to propose to Cas.

l notice all of the band members seemed to be looking at her and Cas, but one of them, the one who was playing bass, seemed very intent on Debbie. Maybe he was aware of Andy's extra activity with her or possibly both of them.

There also was an older gentleman nearby whom I had seen at many of these shows. I believe he is associated with the band. He was also staring at Debbie occasionally.

I started to think I was imagining more to it than it there was. Debbie and Cas are after all the hottest pieces of ass in the place tonight; it's no wonder they were being stared at.

The night went on, the band played, and drinks were served. When the band stopped for a break, Andy went straight to Debbie and Cas. She said something, and Cas came back to the table by me. I asked her, "What's going on?"

She said, "Debbie wants to talk to Andy alone."

As we watch, words are said, and after a minute or so, they hug and walk away from each other.

Debbie came back to the table, and I asked her, "Is everything okay?"

She says, "Yes, everything is good."

I know that my wife just broke up with her boyfriend. I know it's weird, but I feel sorry for her.

I don't know if Cas knew, but by her non-reaction, I assume she did.

I ask them, "Do you want to stay or go?"

Debbie answers that she wanted to stay, and Cas agrees.

I say, "Okay, next time the waiter comes by, do you two want more drinks?"

They both say, "Yes, they would."

Andy and the band start to play again, and the girls decide to head back up to the stage. I sat at the table and once again observed the goings-on. I notice the same guy from the band that plays the bass guitar has resumed watching the girls. He is particularly interested in Debbie. From my point of view, he appears to be smiling at her from time to time.

Debbie does not seem to notice his stares and smiles. Unbeknownst to me, it was intentional.

The band was on their last song for the night, and Cas and Debbie are up by the stage. I see Debbie take hold of Cas's hands and then face her. Debbie starts speaking to her; she is proposing. Cas is looking emotional and is smiling. After some more words are said, Debbie puts the ring that we purchase on her finger. After a few seconds or so, they hug. Some people look, but it is not uncommon that woman sometimes hug.

Debbie has just confessed her love and proposed to Cas, and it looks like she accepted.

The band finished up, and Debbie had told Cas something which caused her to come back to the table.

The first of two big events that occured that night had just happened. The second event was soon to be upon us.

As Cas walks towards me, I take in her lovely beauty. Her smile is enchanting, her flowing hair adds to her beauty, but mostly, I love the way her hips sway. When she gets to me she says, "Debbie asked me to come talk to you."

I say, "I know, babe."

I obviously know why she is here, but I am a little distracted. I notice up by the stage area, Debbie is talking to that guy from the band. I put that aside for now, and I look back at Cas. I smile at her, and I say, "Cassidy, I really love you."

Before I can say anything more, Cas says, "I love you too, Daniel, and I love Debbie also. I want to be yours and hers exclusively; I won't fool around with anyone unless you give me permission. I want to live with you both if that is what you want. You can share me with any man or woman you would like to. I just want to say I love you when ever I want, and wake up with the two of you every morning. I want to be yours and Debbie's forever."

I think wow this is amazing, that is everything we had hoped for and then some. I say, "I love you so very much Cassidy, and I know Debbie does too. I would love to have you live with us. I want you to be my wife. It would be so wonderful to wake up every morning with both of you in bed with me. If I could have two wives I would want you and Debbie and nobody else. Cas you are so wonderful my answer is yes and forever babe. I love you, Cassidy!"

She smiles and says, "I love you, Daniel, and I'm yours forever."

She is actually tearing up. She comes up to me and hugs and kisses me.

I hug her back, and I tell her again, "I love you, Cas."

I see Debbie coming to the table. She smiles and says, "I guess she said yes to you too."

Cas then goes up and hugs and kisses Debbie, not caring if anyone is looking. As I look at my two woman I think to myself I am the luckiest man in the world.

Now the second thing that I mentioned earlier was about to make his face known.

I notice the band guy is standing nearby. He is a good-looking fellow. He is slightly taller than me about 195lbs, muscular with long black hair and blue eyes. He was wearing jeans and a muscle shirt. I hate to say that I noticed, but he had an impressive bulge in those jeans.

I wonder what Debbie has in mind with him. I think to myself that this day may become even more interesting than I have imagined.

Cas and Debbie separate, and Debbie motions the guy over. He approaches and reaches out his hand to me and says, "Hello, my name is Tony,

I shake his hand and say, "I'm Daniel, and this beautiful lady is Cas."

I really want to say our fiance, but it was too soon.

He says, "Nice to meet you both. Debbie wanted me to come over and introduce myself. I had asked her if she had plans tonight, not knowing she was married. She said we could still hang out if you two are okay with it."