It was something that we had talked about while having sex numerous times. I would fuck Nikki and whisper in her ear how I wanted to share her with another guy or watch her fuck someone else. Sometimes I would have her stick one of her suction cup dildos to the wall and fuck it while she sucked my cock. All the while telling her to imagine that it was a real cock inside of her.
So finally, after years of just fantasizing about Nikki being fucked by two cocks, we decided to put our money where our mouths were. We looked around, and decided in the end to just scroll through Craigslist and find a willing cock to join us in the bedroom.
With a bottle of wine, we sat down one night and started scrolling through the 'Casual Encounters' looking for a M4MW thread, hoping to find someone open to a couple. There was post after post of old, out of shape, or just unappealing men on there. But every once in a while we would come across a younger guy, with good sized dick, who didn't sound weird. As we went through we got more and more turned on, just thinking about what this was leading to.
Eventually I couldn't take it anymore and I dragged Nikki to the bedroom. With a bottle of wine and a couple hours of pent up arousal, we were both in the mood to fuck. We fucked for an hour, talking dirty the entire time about how she was going to get tag teamed by two cocks.
The next morning I woke up and noticed Nikki was already out of bed. I walked into the computer room and found Nikki back on Craigslist looking for a guy to fuck. I took that as a sign that last night wasn't just drunken fantasizing, we were actually going to go through with it.
"Any luck?" I asked, spooking her a little.
"Oops! I didn't hear you walk in," Nikki said sheepishly. Well nothing really yet. I've found a couple potential candidates, but I wanna make sure I find the best one. I wanna make this count, in case this is the only time we do it."
"Ok, well I'll let ya get back to it, lemme know if you find 'The One'."
I left Nikki to scroll through the hundreds of dick pics and I went downstairs. A couple hours later Nikki came bounding downstairs, "I found him!" She exclaimed.
"You did eh? Can I take a look?" I asked, hoping to see a shot of the guy, and cock that might fuck my wife soon.
"Nope, it's a surprise! I emailed him, and he emailed me back right away. We're gonna meet him for a drink at the pub tomorrow night to feel each other out. If things seem ok then we can come back here, and if not we'll just end it there."
"Tomorrow?! That sure is quick. Wasn't really expecting it to be that soon."
"Well I figured no time like the present! So no fucking me tonight. I want us both to be super horny tomorrow, and I don't want to be sore or anything. I'm actually a little sore from the pounding you gave me last night."
************
The next day was brutal. I spent the whole day feeling a little weird, knowing that in a couple hours, a guy I'd never met might be fucking my wife in front of me. I was walking around with a perpetual semi, with just the thought of this happening. So I decided to head out for a little while and buy some booze and do some running around to get my mind off it.
I came home around 5:00pm, and Nikki was already dressed and ready to go. She was wearing one of her favorite dresses, a colorful tribal print dress that really accented her ass. I noticed that she wasn't wearing a bra, as her big nipples were noticeably hard. That was one thing about this dress. Nikki couldn't wear a bra as it is backless (mostly), so she has to go without. Nikki's nipples are a good half- inch long, so when she gets horny or cold they stick right out.
"You look ready to go," I said while staring at her hard nipples.
"Do I look good?" Nikki asked, giving herself a spin and sticking out her round little butt.
"Good enough to eat!"
"Well isn't that the point?" Nikki replied, winking at me.
"I guess so..." It was still a little hard to believe that we were going out soon to meet a guy that Nikki picked out to fuck her.It made me feel almost sick to my stomach, but my cock was still rock hard.
We decided to have a couple drinks at the house to loosen ourselves up before walking over to the pub. Nikki finished off a rye & coke in a couple quick sips, and I slammed mine just as fast. I could tell we were both a bit nervous. The pub was pretty quiet when we got there, so it didn't take long to find Nikki's mystery man. About 6 feet tall, dark hair, and one of those rugged 5 o'clock shadows that Nikki like. Nikki and I casually walked over to him and introduced ourselves.
"Paul?" Nikki asked cautiously to man she had been emailing with online.
"Nikki! I was hoping that was you when you walked in. And you must be Tim," Paul- extended out his hand and we shook like we were at a business meeting, and not a pre-sex get-to-know-you.
"Nice to meet you Paul," I replied, "Find the place ok?"
"Oh yeah, it was easy, and I made damn sure that I wasn't going to get lost, or be late. Not for this!" And with that Paul beamed huge smile at Nikki, which she returned with a laugh.
We all sat down, had some drinks and chatted about regular things. What we did for a living, relationship history, and sports. It all seemed quite normal, and for a while I forgot that this was the guy that Nikki picked out to fuck her. Eventually we had enough courage to decide it was time to walk back to the house.
When we got back to the house Nikki wasted no time in getting the party started. She quickly ran downstairs and grabbed a joint. She lit it up and passed it around, and soon none of us were feeling any pain. The weed quickly took effect, and Nikki turned on some music and pushed us each down onto the couches. Nikki began gyrating her hips and dancing in the middle of the room, rubbing her tits through her dress and slowly pulling it up so we could see the bottom of her ass. She slowly removed the dress and like that she was dancing in nothing but a pair of booty shorts and high heels.
She took turns going from couch to couch giving us each lap dances and rubbing her tits on our faces. It was way hotter than I expected to see my wife giving another guy a lap dance. I wasn't even jealous, I was just turned on.
"Well are you two boys ready to get this going?" Nikki asked, even though I know she wasn't gonna take no for an answer.
And with that Nikki dropped down to her knees in front of Paul, so her back to towards me. Paul made eye contact with me, and I gave him a thumbs up to let him know I was cool with it. And right after his head rolled back on the couch, and I knew that Nikki had just put his cock in her mouth. I could hear her moaning and the sounds of very sloppy blowjob.
My cock felt like it was going to burst through my jeans, it was so fucking hard. All I could see still was Nikki's head bobbing up and down and Paul reaching down to pull her nipple while she sucked him. Finally pulled her mouth off his cock, and got up on the couch on her knees to get a better angle. And that's when I saw it.
Gripped in Nikki's tiny hand was the biggest cock I had ever seen. It must have been at least 9" long, and looked to be as thick as a beer bottle. It all made sense now why Nikki chose Paul and why she didn't want me to see beforehand. Nikki was bouncing her head on his cock and slobbering all over it, all the while jerking the base of it. I noticed Paul had a hand on Nikki's pussy and he was slowly pushing a finger in and out.
Nikki rose her head from his cock, with a line of saliva still attached, and looked at me with complete lust in her eyes. "I need you to lick my pussy right now." I didn't need to be asked twice. I quickly went over to the other couch and positioned my head right in front of her pussy. I could see she was sopping wet, so I stuck my tongue out and drew it up from her clit to her asshole. This drew a large moan out of Nikki, but she never stopped sucking.
I put two finger in her pussy, and they slid right in with how wet she was. I pulled them out, spread her lips and began tonging her clit, tasting the cum coming out of her pussy.
"I need to fuck this thing now," Nikki stated loudly as she stood up. I took the hint and sat back down on the other couch to get a good view. Paul pulled his pants off and Nikki turned to face me, all the while rubbing her clit and squeezing one of her tits.
"Are you ready for this?" She asked me. "Are you ready to watch your little wife fuck this huge cock? Mmmmm, I bet you are." Nikki then backed up, never breaking eye contact, and reached for Paul's dick. She put a leg on either side of his, and began to slowly lower herself down to his horse dick. I watched as the head made contact with her opening and Nikki smiled at me. She then pushed herself down and the head popped in.
"Oh fuck this is big," Nikki said biting her lip, never losing eye contact. She then pushed down harder and took in another couple of inches. Her pussy was stretching wider than I had ever seen as she slowly pushed herself down onto his pole. She stopped when it was about 4" inside and then raised herself back up until only the head was inside. I could see her creamy pussy juice around his cock, the telltale sign that Nikki was very aroused.
My cock was rock hard and straining to get out my pants. I didn't expect to get hard so fast watching my wife fuck another man. But I don't think my dick had ever been this stiff. I unzipped my pants and pulled my cock out to stroke it...slowly. I didn't want to cum before they did.
Nikki was now fucking herself faster on the first 4" of Paul's dick, the bottom 5" were still untouched. Her eyes were closed as she bounced up and down, her tits shaking with every stroke. I was dying to see her go deeper, and I know Paul was too. His hands were on her hips, lifting her up and pulling her down in tune with Nikki's rhythm.
