This is a sequel to Caribbean Awakening and it is primarily about wife sharing as well. I sincerely thank those of you that offered words of encouragement and constructive criticism. Your comments are appreciated.
*
I awoke late the next morning to find Beth in the shower. She was getting out as I entered the bathroom and greeted me with a tentative look in her eyes. She looked even more beautiful now than before.
"Did you get off last night as much as I did," I asked with a grin?
She let out a sigh of relief and said, "Oh God yes! I was so turned on that I worried that I upset you."
"You were fantastic Beth, but I'll bet that Alan had a better time than either of us," I said
"I really doubt it," she said as she turned her head a little and winked at me.
We went to the pool after breakfast. I wasn't sure how to react when we saw Matt and Eileen. They waved us over. I looked at Beth and caught her blushing intensely when she made eye contact with our friends.
"How did you two sleep last night," asked Eileen?
"We did just fine," I answered.
Beth was still blushing and looked nervously my way as I answered.
"Eileen and I enjoyed the evening immensely," Matt said with a beaming smile.
"It was better than we could have imagined," Eileen added while patting Beth on the knee. "It was so much better than our first time. Thank you for allowing us to be there."
Beth looked like a deer in the headlights. She was obviously uncomfortable with such an intimate conversation so soon after last night.
I apologized and said "Beth and I haven't discussed the details of last night yet."
Matt looked at us for a long while and then with a serious look he said, "you two need to talk about this soon. Last night was a sudden change in your relationship. You both wanted the events to happen, and I'll bet that you both are still tremendously excited about it. You need to let each other know how you feel."
I interrupted and said, "we have talked about it Matt. Just not enough that we feel comfortable talking about it with others yet."
"Oh," Matt said with a frown. "I was hoping that Eileen and I could help you overcome some of the awkward emotions that can arise after a evening like we all shared."
"Is Alan staying at the resort," Beth finally mustered the courage to ask?
Matt smiled. "No Beth, Alan was a guest of ours yesterday. He lives nearby but he will not be visiting the rest of the week."
I wasn't sure if Beth was disappointed or relieved as she looked away at the horizon. Matt finally broke the silence and asked if we had enjoyed the evening's adventures. We both nodded and I said that it was almost overwhelming. Slowly we began to talk about what had happened and how we felt about it. I told them how I had felt uncomfortable directing their actions early on. I also admitted that I enjoyed it when things began to happen spontaneously.
Beth listened carefully and said that it was helpful to have me as an icebreaker. She knew that I was OK with what was happening since I was asking her to go further. She added that she just lost control after awhile and forgot that they had an audience. After they had finished she felt a small burst of humiliation that didn't subside until we returned to the room.
I then brought up that I felt that Matt had changed during the course of the evening. Gone was our friend and confidant. A much more aggressive and uncaring person had evolved.
Matt had listened and nodded understanding. He smiled and reached for our hands before speaking. "We all changed roles last night guys. After we had learned of your fantasies and desires, Eileen and I planned last night's adventure."
Over the next half hour we heard how he had taken everything in to consideration. My need for control and to share Beth with another. He also realized that I wanted Beth to enjoy herself and even take control back. He considered Beth's need for coercion. He was delighted when Beth responded so very well and lost herself completely in passion.
Matt admitted that Eileen had recommended Alan. She had known him for some time and felt that he best met our requirements, physically and otherwise. Eileen added that Alan had asked to see Beth again before we left the island. Beth looked up at her and smiled.
"I was so scared that I would run into him sometime this week," Beth blurted out with a sigh of relief. She then grinned and added, "he was quite the gentleman Eileen."
Matt looked at me and asked if I had any feelings of jealousy. I admitted that I did but that I found it intensely exciting. He was relieved and said that if I didn't admit I was at least a little jealous, I was either lying or not in love with my wife.
Matt then posed the big question. "Was once enough or do you wish to continue?"
Beth and I looked at each other in astonishment. We had not considered that yet.
Matt sensed our unease. "Some couples can have this adventure and that is enough forever. Others will repeat it rarely and only as circumstances permit. Others, once introduced, can't hardly wait until the next encounter. It's up to the two of you to decide."
"Well, it's not something we can do at home," Beth thought out loud.
I agreed and admitted that had we not been on vacation, last night would have never happened.
"Can you imagine if our friends and family knew about last night," Beth asked with a wide-eyed grin?
There was an awkward pause in the conversation.
"Will Alan be coming back to the resort this week," Beth finally asked?
Matt got very serious and sat forward as he spoke. "Beth, I know that you would feel more comfortable with Alan or someone else that you had previously been intimate with, but that would not be in your best interest. I would advise against asking Alan to join the two of you for the immediate future. It would be very easy for you to become enamored with Alan or any other sexual partner. That is something you want to avoid. Eileen and I have learned this the hard way."