This is my first erotic story, ever. I hope you enjoy it and, should you ever run into MerlinMagic or SynSlave, give them a huge thanks for editing!
*
"You have got to be kidding me," I said aloud.
I had just finished packing for my week long business trip to Mequon, a small Wisconsin town slightly north of Milwaukee, when I saw a new email from Thom. After 5 weeks of emails about setting up a threesome with him and his wife Audrey, Thom said he couldn't do it. I had specifically arranged to fly out on Saturday morning so we could get together this evening. I mean, why the hell else would I go to Wisconsin for more time than I had to in December.
It was too late to cancel my hotel and my boss would never approve the $150 change fee for my airline ticket so, disgruntled, I headed to the airport for what would undoubtedly be a dull evening. At least they have plenty of beer in Wisconsin. Maybe once I got in I would find something fun on a dating or fetish site, though most of my dates from there ended with mere make-out sessions at best. To me it always felt like there was less pretense with meetings arranged from the fetish sites; everyone knew it was about some form of immediate sexual gratification. Of course it was on one that I had met Thom and Audrey a few weeks back, so I was feeling a little bitter towards the site. At the time, I was thinking what the hell—Audrey's pictures were hot and we would have had an awesome time fucking her together.
Shortly after my boss told me my next consulting gig was going to be in Mequon, I headed to my favorite fetish site to find something a little more enjoyable to add to the work trip. It had been over a year since my last threesome so I thought perhaps I could find a couple up for a little excitement. Quickly, I found a posting for a couple looking to try their first threesome, and more interesting (at least to me) they were looking for the third to be a guy. Soon after, the three of us were emailing and it seemed like a great match. They were both happy that I was not local, so there could be no awkward random meetings in the future. I liked that they were both really fit, as evidenced by all their pictures of running, surfing, and froliking on the beach from their vacation pictures on their profiles. And they were in their mid thirties as well, so we could at least relate a bit at the pre-event drinks. There were none of the requests for more and more nudes, as the jackass picture collectors do. We made it through the normal beginnings, with Thom being extremely relieved after nervously asking about my bisexual tendencies (I have none, incidental contact happens but it doesn't bother me) and Audrey sounding excited that I was taller than her. Both of them are 5'6" and 130 lbs as opposed to my 5'9", 165 lbs frame. She complimented me with what she called classic manliness—facial and chest hair (Thom apparently had a few wispy hairs on his chest and couldn't grow a beard to save his life). After a few more weeks of flirting and setting out some boundaries (pretty basic for a first time couple: use a condom, be gentle, Audrey sets the pace, no guy on guy action, they will decide/bring any toys, and no anal), I was excited to meet up.
I arrived at the airport a little more resigned and slowly made my way through security (No Mr. TSA agent, I didn't forget to take my watch off, those are screws in the bone in my wrist as I tell you every week flying through here) to the gate. I sank down on an empty seat in the corner and pulled out my cell phone. I started browsing another Milwaukee Personals group on Fetlife with only one ad catching my eye. I put together a message, without great hope of a response, given the popularity of the ad, and sent it off before boarding the plane. As the flight attendant began closing the door and started the safety presentation, I surprisingly saw an email pop up from Thom.
From: Thom Ash
To: Dan
Dan,
I apologize about my earlier email; I accidentally hit send before completing the rest of the message. I know Audrey and I had both been very much looking forward to tonight but I just don't think I can perform with another man present. I know Audrey had been eager to experience all of the attention and the third penis of her life, particularly after 12 years with me. I really wanted to see and hear her as we took turns and then took her together but I am afraid of my ability to perform, of what I would do seeing you with her. Would I get more turned on? Would I get jealous and try to attack you, which admittedly would be foolish seeing how muscular you are compared to me. Would I ever be able to look at my wife the same after watching you with her? I am afraid and I cannot have a threesome. I know you booked the hotel and added an extra day to your trip for us. I am sorry. These fears came on this morning and I just cannot go ahead. I will let Audrey know shortly.
My most sincere apologies,
Thom
Again, are you fucking kidding me? I had only moments before being forced to turn my phone to airplane mode for takeoff.
From: Dan
To: Thom Ash; Audrey Ash
Thom,
I just boarded the plane. We have been discussing this for 5 weeks and you only started thinking about this now? How about Audrey and I just duct tape you to a chair so you don't have to watch?
Dan
"Fuck him," I thought as I sent the message under the stern eyes of the flight attendant.
-------------------------------------
A few hours I arrived at my hotel for a week, one of those nice ones with a kitchen and a separate bedroom, I finally remembered to turn my phone off airplane mode. I was surprised to see three messages from Thom and Audrey
From: Audrey Ash
To: Dan; Thom Ash
Dan,
We just had a long talk about Thom's issues and fears and I think we can work through them. I would like us all to at least still meet up for drinks tonight, if that is OK with you. If you don't have any other plans.
Yours,
Audrey
Well that was unexpected.
From: Thom Ash
To: Dan; Audrey Ash
I agree with Audrey. If we make it through drinks and I get uncomfortable, strapping me to a chair might work. I will be able to hear Audrey, hopefully enjoy herself, and not have to worry about wanting to attack you. Hopefully we can all play together though.
Thom
This guy is a piece of work. He seriously wants to me to tape him to a chair while his wife and I fuck each other silly? And attack me? I had done a little research on the two of them, off of their names as neither had bothered to create an anonymous email address for our communications. Audrey was a nurse at a birthing center and Thom had an IT consulting business; neither had anything on their public Facebook profiles to indicate any chance of aggression, or for that matter physical strength. Attacking me? I would destroy Thom in a fight.
From: Audrey Ash
To: Dan
Please let me know. I really want this. I am tired of gentle sex; Thom is so passive all the time it drives me up the wall. I was really hoping this might bring Thom to be more aggressive. I want you, anyway I can have you, tonight.
Yours,
Audrey