Bad Neighbors
Loving Wives Story

Bad Neighbors

by Erin2000 18 min read 4.3 (38,100 views)
cucold creampie cleanup cheating wife humiliation smoing reluctance voyeur
🎧

Audio Narration

Audio not available
Audio narration not available for this story

Huge thanks to Litero volunteer editor 'neuroparenthetical' for taking the time and effort to edit this final installment.

Please check the tags before reading: if cuckold stories aren't your thing, feel free to find another story.

-------

The following morning, Andy quietly packed his bag while his wife slept in.  Before leaving, he leaned down to give her a kiss, but she remained fast asleep --  or at least appeared to to him.  He watched her for several moments, feeling even more miserable about what he'd done the previous night: she must be so confused, he thought. With a sigh, he finally left their bedroom, headed downstairs, and went to work, dreading not seeing her again until Sunday night.

----------

-- 7pm at the Emerald Room --

Andy's heart pounded in his chest as he read Jenna's text.  It was almost 5:30pm and he had begun to worry that she'd changed her mind.

The Emerald Room was a posh restaurant on the top floor of a twelve-story building, known for its rooftop dining and lounge area.  Andy had only been there once before, and that had been for a work function.  It wasn't the kind of place he'd typically go to -- the prices were in sharp contrast to its portion sizes --  but he had to admit it was very elegant and had an incredible view.

-- OK, he typed back.

He took his overnight bag to the staff bathroom and cleaned up a bit. He thought about changing, but decided against it, as he was already wearing one of his nicer button up shirts. He took a deep breath and looked at himself in the mirror one last time, feeling more nervous than he'd felt in a long time. Releasing a sigh, he turned and headed to his car.

----

When he entered the restaurant, the hostess asked if he had a reservation. Andy suddenly realized he didn't know, but as he scanned the tables behind her he saw Jenna sitting at the bar.

"Right on time," she said, smiling as he approached her.

Her dress was both stylish and revealing, showing off her toned arms and ample cleavage. Her tattoos were visible, snaking up from her shoulders and disappearing into her neckline.  Andy thought the contrast of her chic dress and her tattooed skin was incredibly hot, making her seem both mysterious and confident in such an upscale environment.

Jenna pulled him in and gave him a kiss on the cheek and a quick hug before sitting back down at the bar. "Our table should be ready soon." She signaled the bartender. "Let's get you a drink, shall we?"

"I'll have a glass of your cabernet," Andy said. "Anything California, please."

The bartender nodded and poured a generous glass of wine before sliding it over. Andy took a sip, savoring the taste, nervous about the evening ahead.

"Good day at work?" Jenna asked.

Andy found it strange to be sitting with Jenna telling her about his day, like they were friends or a couple. "Uh, yeah, I guess it was good."

When the hostess arrived to lead them to their table, Jenna slid from her bar stool and took Andy's hand, guiding him to their spot at the far corner of the outdoor patio.

The sun was setting, casting a warm glow over the city skyline as they settled into their plush dining chairs.  Andy marvelled at the way the evening light shone on Jenna's tattooed arms, and couldn't help but stare at the intricate mix of dark and coloured ink that adorned her silky skin.

He wasn't sure what he'd expected from their dinner, but he was surprised at how much he was enjoying their conversation.  He was careful not to bring up everything that had gone on the past few weeks, deciding there would be time for that later.  For the moment, he wanted simply to enjoy their evening together and let Jenna take the lead.

When they finally finished their meal, the waiter poured the remaining wine from the bottle into Jenna's glass and set the bill on the table.

"So, Andy," Jenna said, smiling widely as she leaned back in her chair. "Have you been good this week? Did you do everything I asked?"

Andy's heart fluttered. "Yes. It wasn't easy, but I followed your instructions."

"Good boy," she said, patting his knee. "So tell me, how did it go when you told Abbie that you've fantasized about her being with other men? Wait, let me guess: I'll bet she was excited about it, wasn't she?"

"Well, maybe," he said, rubbing his chin nervously. "Yes, I guess so. I mean, I could tell it really caught her off guard -- but then she brought it up again later in bed."

"Ahhh, interesting," she said. "So what happened?"

Andy shifted uncomfortably in his seat. "Well, nothing actually.  She was rubbing my -- well, rubbing me, and I was really, you know, ready, but then I told her we had to stop -- that I was too tired."

Jenna's expression was a mix of surprise and amusement. "Right, because no sex, like we agreed. And did she seem upset?"

"Well, yeah," Andy said, scratching the back of his neck. "Quite upset, actually and then a couple of nights later the subject came up again, and she was really getting into it, asking me more about my wanting to see her with another man.... and, well, it kind of happened again.  She got me really worked up and offered to... you know... go down on me.  And I told her I had to get up early -- that I couldn't have sex." Andy's face was bright red. He finished his last swallow of wine, feeling Jenna's eyes on him.

"Oh, wow," she said. Her lips spread into a sly smile, and she started running her finger around the rim of her wine glass. "So tell me if I got this right: you asked her to sleep with another guy. She quickly got turned on by the idea and tried to have sex with you... and then you rejected her -- not once, but twice."

Andy sat up straight, visibly frustrated. "Now, wait a minute. I didn't ask her to sleep with another man. I just said... well, I'm pretty sure I just said I've imagined it -- you know, the idea of it -- not that I definitely wanted her to."

"I see," Jenna replied, "and you're sure that's how she understood it? I mean, you were there. I guess you'd know better than I would -- you know, that you were very clear that it was just a fantasy, and you'd never ever want her to be with someone else. Right?"

Despite the cooling night air, Andy felt a bead of sweat forming on his brow as his mind raced to remember exactly how the conversations had gone with Abbie the previous week.  He was sure... well almost sure, that he didn't say he wanted it -- just that the idea of it was a turn-on.  Thinking back, he'd been so nervous he couldn't remember exactly how he had phrased it. He did however, remember how quickly she had seemed to recover from her surprise -- how she'd seemed almost excited by his admission.

Andy looked over at Jenna, who was typing something on her phone, as if she'd completely lost interest in their conversation.  He stared at her for several seconds before she finally looked up at him. "Oh, sorry," she said, tossing her phone into her purse. "I didn't mean to be rude. Anyhow, I'm sure it all went as you said it did. I'm sure she understood what you meant. And thank you for keeping your end of the bargain." She stood up from the table and reached for his hand. "I need a cigarette. Are you ready to go?"

After paying the bill, they made their way to the elevator and when the doors closed, Jenna leaned back against the mirrored wall, hands on the railing behind her waist. The seductive way she looked at Andy made his knees weak. Fuck, she's sexy.

"Come here," she said, head tilted slightly and biting her bottom lip.

Andy took a step forward, standing directly in front of her. The smell of her perfume was heavenly, and his cock began to stiffen.

"Kiss me," she said.

He only hesitated for a moment before he leaned into her and pressed his lips to hers. The kiss was soft, their mouths opening slightly at times, but with very little tongue. Jenna didn't even put her arms around him, just held tight to the railing behind her.

"That was nice," she said as he stepped back away from her again. As the elevator door opened, Jenna locked her arm through his and they crossed the lobby floor and stepped outside. She led him down the sidewalk and around a corner into the parking lot.  "I'm just over here. We can take my car."

When they reached her car, Jenna fished her cigarette pack from her purse.  Andy stood a foot or two away, anxiety building in his chest as he watched her light the tip, inhale, and exhale a cloud of smoke up into the air. She took another slow drag, her eyes never leaving Andy's, but said nothing.

He shifted nervously as he watched her smoke in silence, as if putting on a show for him. His cock was rock hard, protruding almost painfully against his pants. He glanced down at Jenna's barely hidden cleavage and swallowed hard. He saw her raise her cigarette again, and his gaze quickly shifted back to her face, entranced by how sexy she looked when she smoked.

He finally broke the silence. "Umm, so what are we doing now?"

Jenna took one last drag, her cheeks hollowing deeply, before dropping her cigarette to the ground and grinding it out with her shoe.  She moved into Andy, her breasts pressing hard against his chest.  She slowly exhaled the stream of smoke from the corner of her mouth, her eyes still fixed on his.

Andy couldn't stop himself.  He grabbed her hips and leaned down, kissing her soft lips, his tongue exploring her smoky mouth while he pushed her body against the cold metal exterior of the car.

Jenna moaned softly as they kissed before pulling finally away from him, a mischievous grin playing at her lips.  She reached up and ran her finger down the bridge of his nose. "So cute," she said, as an adult might compliment an adorable child. She walked around to the driver's door, leaving Andy standing there with a raging hard on and feeling a touch of humiliation.  Finally, he reached for the door and slid in beside her.

They were quiet for the entire drive, with just the faint music from the radio playing in the background.  Andy glanced at the clock on the dashboard and noted it was just after 9pm.  He wondered at first where she was taking him, assuming they would be pulling into a hotel parking lot soon, before he eventually realized they were exiting the downtown area.  Minutes later, Andy began to recognize their surroundings, but stayed silent right up until they pulled into Jenna and Dean's driveway. Wait, what? She wants me to stay here? Right next door to my wife?

"Shit," he muttered, looking into her backseat. "I left my overnight bag in my car back at the restaurant."

Jenna patted him on the knee before opening her door. "Not to worry. We will figure something out."

As Andy followed her up the walkway steps, he glanced next door at his own house, then around their neighborhood, hoping no one would see him following Jenna into her home.

"Go wait in the bedroom," she instructed him as she strolled toward the kitchen. "I will get us a night cap."

Andy took a deep breath before heading down the hallway, wondering what Jenna had in store.  He carefully crossed the bedroom floor to the nightstand and turned on the lamp, which cast a warm glow over the room.  He wondered where Dean was, and if he would suddenly come in and find Andy there.  Finally, after standing there for what felt to him like an eternity, Jenna came in the room, holding a half-full bottle of whiskey and two low ball glasses with ice.

She crossed the floor and set them down on a small table in the corner of the bedroom opposite the bed. "Can you close the door?"

Andy pushed the door closed while Jenna sat down in one of the soft arm chairs on either side of the table.

"Come sit." Jenna patted the chair next to hers. She poured them each a generous amount and handed one glass to Andy before raising hers in a toast. "To new experiences."

Andy clinked his glass with hers and took a sip. The gold liquid burned his throat, but he welcomed the sensation.   He could hear music coming from somewhere, and Jenna seemed to sense his curiosity. "Don't worry, it's just Dean. I think he has a couple of friends over; they're in the back yard." She noticed Andy glance nervously toward the door and chuckled. "Don't worry; he knows you're here --  with me.  Everything is fine, I promise."

Andy still felt uneasy, the sound of the music reminding him that Jenna's husband wasn't far away.  "So, what are we doing?" he finally managed. All week, he'd imagined himself and Jenna in a hotel room out of town or at some bed and breakfast. The last thing he'd expected was to end up back here at Jenna's house, with her husband just outside. He tried to mask his disappointment.

"Well, Andy," Jenna purred as she reached and poured him another drink, "let's get back to what you and Abbie discussed this week."

-----

At that very moment, Andy's wife was beginning to feel very intoxicated. After spending the day frustrated and confused by the roller-coaster Andy had put her through all week, Abbie welcomed the numbing feeling she was getting from her third glass of wine. She was still shocked by Andy's confession about getting turned on by the thought of her with another man. It seemed so out of character for him. But she didn't judge him for it, in fact had been excited by it and tried to engage with him on the topic. But both times he'd abruptly shut her down. It had been humiliating and that humiliation had gradually morphed into anger.

Just as she finished her glass, her phone chimed. For a moment she ignored it, assuming it was Andy checking in on her. She wasn't ready to let him off the hook so easily. When it chimed a second time, curiosity got the best of her.

-- Hello neighbor. You should come by for a drink. --

It was Dean. Abbie could feel the butterflies begin to flutter in her stomach.

-- Sorry, Andy is away for the weekend. Maybe another time. --

She waited several minutes for a response, her heart pounding. After almost 2 minutes she got up and rinsed out her glass, disappointed that he'd so easily accepted her rejection. Finally, she heard her phone notification once again and had to force herself not to rush to check it.

-- So I guess it will be just you then, that sounds great. Jenna is out with a friend but should be back soon. See you shortly? --

Abbie's heart raced. Was she really going to go next door while Andy was away? She was fully aware what happened in the past when she was drinking around Dean. But Jenna will be there as well, she thought, and realized that somehow made her feel worse not better. Maybe this was just what she needed to take her mind off how angry she was with her husband.

She finally typed her response and after several seconds of hesitation, pressed the send button.

-- OK --

She went to her closet and scoured her wardrobe several times, indecisive about what outfit to wear.  Dean hadn't been clear on if there would be others joining them.  Will it just be the three of us? she wondered.

She finally settled on one of Andy's favorite summer dresses. She hadn't worn it outside of their own home, as she'd always felt it was a bit too revealing -- especially for someone her age. It was white with soft pink cherry blossoms scattered about, had a very low-cut neckline that showed off a lot more cleavage than she was used to, and was shorter than any of her other sundresses.

The couple of times she had worn it for Andy, he'd been almost drooling, and both times it had ended up at the foot of their bed rather quickly.

Thoughts of Andy only brought back her sense of frustration.  She didn't want to think about it any longer. Not about him. I need a distraction; we'll hash it out when he gets home.

She pulled the dress off of the hanger and brought it into her bedroom.

--------

Abbie arrived next door just before 9pm. She pushed open the back gate and was surprised to see Dean and another man sitting around a small fire in the backyard. She scanned the yard, but saw no sign of Jenna.  She closed the gate and strolled over to the fire-pit trying her best to look casual and at ease.

"Hi," she said softly, not wanting to startle them.

"There she is," Dean said, standing and pulling her into a strong hug. "Glad you made it."

Abbie returned his embrace, feeling the warmth of his body against hers. "No other offers. I'm not exactly at the top of everyone's speed dial when it comes to fun on a Friday night."

"Abbie, this is my friend, Chris," Dean said.

Chris stood up and gave Abbie a quick hug. "It's great to meet you, Abbie."

She could feel his broad shoulders and strong arms tighten around her for a brief moment and it took her breath away.  He stood back and looked at her with a warm smile. Abbie couldn't help but notice how his short sleeves strained around his large biceps. "You too, Chris." Then she turned her attention to Dean. "So where is your beautiful wife?"

"Not home from her date yet," he chuckled, as he threw two large logs onto the fire. "She texted me a bit ago and said she would be running later than she thought. So I guess you're stuck with a couple of boring guys like us for now."

Abbie didn't know Dean all that well, but boring certainly wasn't how she would describe him.

"What can I get you to drink?" Dean asked. "Wait, let me guess: red wine. Am I right?"

"How good of you to remember," she teased.

"Coming right up," he responded, starting toward the house. "And don't believe any stories Chris may tell you about me. None of them are true, I promise."

As Dean disappeared into the house, Abbie glanced at Chris and then back at the fire as she took a seat on a chair next to him. "So Chris, how long have you and Dean been friends?"

"We met in college," he replied. "We were both on the football team and lived in the same dorm."

The two of them chatted for several minutes, and Abbie was surprised at how relaxed she felt, given that she'd just met him. There was something about him that made her feel at ease. He struck her as a gentle giant -- soft-spoken and easy to talk to. Abbie felt an instant attraction.

Dean soon returned from the house carrying a glass of red wine for Abbie along with the opened bottle. "Here you go."

Abbie sipped her wine, enjoying the taste of it on her tongue. She'd already had three glasses at her house while getting ready and she knew she was starting to get drunk. She looked over at Chris, who was carefully looking her over. "So, Chris, what do you do for work?"

Chris smiled and leaned back in his chair. "I'm in construction. I own a small company with my dad."

"Really?" she said. "That's impressive."

As they talked, she saw Dean immersed in his phone, typing a message to whom she assumed was Jenna.   She couldn't see the screen, but she saw him grin and chuckle softly before putting the phone back in his pocket. He reached over for the wine bottle and topped Abbie's glass up.  "Sorry, guys. Looks like Jenna may not be home until late tonight."

Chris leaned back in his chair and winked at Abbie. "No worries. I'm sure the three of us can find something to do."

Abbie felt her pulse quicken at Chris's words. "Well, her loss," she replied, taking another sip of her wine. "You guys aren't the worst company, I guess."

The younger men both laughed at that. "Sounds like the wine is making someone a little bold." Dean shot back.

Abbie blushed under his gaze, feeling the effects of the alcohol coursing through her veins. She felt the tension from the past week begin to melt away. This is what I needed, she thought. Good company with a couple of attractive younger guys... and wine, lots of wine! The two men were both very attentive, and she was quite enjoying the not-so-subtle glances and flirty banter she was receiving from both of them.

She took a big drink from her glass. "Oh, I'm feeling it alright -- but then again, I think you guys are falling behind by my count." She teased, putting her hand on Chris' knee, and giving it a gentle squeeze before standing up. "But .... I do have to pee. Mind if I use your bathroom?"

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like