Appetite Bigger Than Your Coc

This story contains over the top sexual experiences and cuckold/humiliation themes. If either bothers you this probably isn't for you. Everyone is 18+ years old.

I stood in my bathroom over my running sink, i had decided i wasn't going to throw up and with the running water and the pounding in my chest I finally got the sound of Amanda calling another man 'daddy' out of my head while she was orgasming on his cock.

But it didn't help me wipe the image of his smug grin as he held her quaking legs up out of my memory. Looking up into the mirror was the wrong choice. It reminded me starkly that i was dripping in my own cum. Which i had sprayed all over after lasting a grand total of a few seconds inside of my biggest crush Jessica.

To be fair she had worked me over with her hands and mouth for a few minutes before hand, i reminded myself. And this was my first time with multiple people in bed.

Maybe i hadn't done so bad. Maybe this was to be expected and i needed to get out of my own damn head. Maybe its normal for the love of your life to have what seemed like the best orgasm of her life in front of you and call some asshole 'daddy.

Maybe.

I needed to clean myself up. Jessica had said she wanted a second round with me and my cock more than agreed. My pride needed me to change the image of her in my head from the surprised laugh of me jizzing all over myself to her grunting in pleasure. Maybe i could still get my dream and give her perfect freckled face a facial.

I heard the door open and couldn't imagine what could be happening when Amanda came in a little slowly. She touched my shoulder until i turned to look at her and she kissed me.

"oh honey! your still not clean. Here let me!" and she got to work with a towel and water cleaning my cum off myself. "There we go, now you are ready to get started fucking Jessica!"

I was confused, when i left her a couple of minutes ago she was writhing under Ben. Well under part of him...he didn't really get all in her. Why had she so quickly come here?

She seemed to read the confusion and trepidation on my face. "James, honey you are the reason I am doing this, if your hiding in here i am not going to just stay with them. Let's go back and get you laid."

Amanda's smile was so genuine and sweet. I couldn't even form words in my own head for how much i loved her in that moment, reassuring me and making sure my enjoyment was a top priority. She reached down and grabbed my hand and placed it on one generous tit. Overflowing out of my hand with their size and the soft yet firm texture I adored, I squeezed and groped.

"That is it baby! touch YOUR tits." She egged me on. "I'm going to go out there and blow Ben again, do ANYTHING i can to make him pop so you can be the star of the rest of the evening. Sound like a plan?

I nodded and followed my love out to our bedroom.

Jessica was laying on the mattress with her pussy facing me. Feet resting on the floor but spread slowly toying herself. Ben was next to her also facing us half hard dick resting on his thigh, making no effort to work himself at all. I started to think about how even flagging from lack of attention it looked awfully fucking long and thick.

Amanda was the first to step up and approached Ben before he and Jessica both stood, Ben wrapped an arm around Amanda in a manner that was more comfortable than i liked around my girl and while she leaned up to kiss him he turned towards me as i approached Jessica and slapped me on the back. Hard.

"Don't worry about it Jamie, lots of guys premature sometimes, it happens." He sounded like he was barely holding a laugh as he at least pretended to be polite.

"Actually man its James or Jim. But uhh thanks." I said turning towards him.

He made me wait for his reply. While he kissed Amanda deeply and moved her right hand to his cock and started groping her right breast. Groping might be the wrong word. Manhandling was more accurate. And i noticed she didnt spill out of his large hand. "Mmmm sorry man was enjoying a nice handful. you got it. Better luck on round two. Well...your round two anyway."

Suddenly Jessica was upon me and i was trying not to worry about him anymore. Kissing my neck and stroking me to full mast she had my full attention. "Sorry about earlier James, if i knew you were so on edge i could have given you a break. I hope now you are ready to really get down?"

I could hear the eagerness in her voice and feel the passion in her touch. She was everything i dreamed about and lived up to all of them. All the times i had cum looking at Jessica's bikini pictures or in dresses on social media, either alone or with Amanda encouraging me had led to this opportunity. I had to rock her world.

In the corner of my vision i saw Ben sit down on the edge of the bed and Amanda kneel down, my girlfriend was doing her part. Working hard to make that jerk cum. Soon she was licking the sides and stroking his shaft to help him return to hardness as Ben was squeezing her tits and whispering what i assumed must be naughty things to her.

Jessica was still encouraging me and i decided to get involved. Kissing her back, running my hands across her back and hair. Squeezing her ass and finally reaching down to rub her pussy and twiddle her clit. She was wet and ready and i could feel it in everything she did. And i was no less ready for her.

"Goddamn girl you are really going for it!" Ben's exclamation drew my attention and i saw what he meant. Amanda had pushed him back a bit and had her tongue bathing his balls, her lips sucking them in, and her hands stroking his shaft. He was leaning back and made a disgusting offer. "want to take that little tongue lower baby girl?"

Would she really go that far? She had never rimmed me before, always expressed that just like cum facials it was a line that even devoted and sexually open girls shouldn't cross. Too demeaning and gross for a feminist to consider.

Amanda didn't react at first, just kept working his balls and shaft with the same aggressiveness, but eventually pulled back a bit. And offered him a different prize, a second tit fuck. He gladly accepted. Soon she had straightened up on her knees and had wrapped her tits around his cock. Except that is how i would describe what she did to me.

For Ben it was more like her G cups only wrapped around a decent amount of his cock. Inches of shaft and his head came through the top and rested on Amanda's chin. I understood what I had walked into earlier. She was able to easily suck him off and fuck his tits.

New waves of jealousy flooded me, i had seen that in porn before of course, but my 5.5 inches were always swallowed whole by her impressive chest. Soon she was doing everything he wanted. Spitting on his shaft to allow easier passage, sucking him and bouncing her tits all around his dick. I remembered just a few minutes ago when she told me they were MY tits.

The best hope was that this worked, Ben would cum and then i would have the ladies to myself.

Jessica was taking it fairly slow with me. Stroking me slowly and occasionally kissing my shoulder or neck a little. Keeping me hard and ready to go but not pressing the issue as i watched Amanda and Ben. Until Ben looked towards us. "You gonna cum watching me titfuck your girl? i thought for sure you would be all over Jess by now."

"He just got a little distracted by the show" Jess defended me. "James already came once and all i have done is stroke him a little. From what Amanda says he is about to go all night, isn't that right Amanda?"

She had just kept slurping away at Ben's monster. Not even seeming to notice the discussion until her name was invoked. All Amanda responded with was an absentminded "Yeah, he is the best" before she backed her tits off of Ben and licked him from balls to tip.

"You getting close Ben?" she followed up grinning up at him.

"Yeah i think i will finish quick if you let me take over. Lay down on the bed, head towards me." He stood up and patted where he had been seated. In the process his genitals rested on Amanda's face with her kneeling in front of him. Balls on her chin, shaft longer then her face.

It took a few seconds before Amanda pushes his cock to the side and stood up. And did as he said. Now she was in a position we had never even tried. It wouldn't have occurred to me to put her in such a position to suck me off. Ben winked at us and turned around, squatting a bit to bring his cock level with her and grabbed her by the elbows and pulled her towards him a foot.

Amanda's head now hung off the mattress and i realized her throat was lined up with i don't even know how many inches of Ben. I expected oral to start but he was too far forward. His cock lay between her gravity flattened chest, which he grabbed in his hands and brought around his cock.

Her mouth by his sack Amanda just starting suckling and licking his balls while he fucked her breasts in this new position. His cock coming clear out the bottom of her cleavage and covering her belly. Ben started thrusting and the result being he was fucking her cleavage and dragging his balls all over Amanda's face and tongue. MY Amanda's face.

I saw her before i realized she wasn't touching me anymore. Jessica had crawled onto the bed facing them and looked up and me with a sultry look from her hands and knees before putting her lips around Amanda's pink nipple and sucking it up, stretching it and releasing it and looking back at me. Wiggling her ass.

I don't know if in all the excitement i have mentioned what a fucking ass Jessica has. Amanda has the bigger tits in the room but Jessica had an ass that caused looks. Even from a boob guy like me. Big, juicy, but not grossly large like a fake or fat ass. And i was finally spurred into action. It was time.

i climbed behind Jessica and admired her hanging tits, big enough to hang but perky and perfect enough to still somehow look firm. I squeezed them a bit as i watched Amanda continue to try and finish Ben off. After a few moments of that i slapped Jessica's ass which got another wiggle out of her and lined myself up with her perfect wet cunt.

Sliding myself into Jessica, she didn't have the moaning groaning reaction I had hoped for but she kind of gently purred. Soon i was pressing myself inside of Jessica as far as i could and just enjoying the sensation. Ben looked over and saw us.

"Looks like its sex time again" as he stepped back a bit and slapped one of Amanda's tits. "Should we do doggy like them?"

Amanda looked up at me, her chin and cheeks covered in her own spit. I had no idea what to say to her. "Fuck her good baby!" Amanda hyped me up before responding to Ben. "why? worried if you have to see my tits your gonna cum too quick Ben?"

It was a valid question i thought, Ben had been going for 20 or 30 minutes on and off between Amanda's hands, mouth, tits and a brief dip into her pussy. Speaking of pussy, i started actually fucking Jessica. No longer content to just enjoy soaking inside of her.

I closed my eyes to ward off all of the sensory around me, so much tits and ass. And some douche manhandling the love of my life. I just kept pumping into Jessica from behind, focused on making thrust after thrust. Trying to keep from getting overwhelmed like last time.

And Jessica was responding nicely, her ass wiggling and soft moans escaping her lips. Maybe making her cum was closer than i thought. Victory near at hand.

I heard a stifled moan, one that sounded more involuntary than encouraging and grinned. YES!. Thrust thrust thrust and rewarded with another sound like a pained grunt almost. Like Jessica was on the edge and holding back louder unladylike sounds.

Keeping my eyes shut i just listened to the grunts and moans and tried not to focus on the feeling of Jessica on my shaft. So warm so wet so good! "Mmm Amanda why are you fighting it so much? Just relax and it'll go in so much easier." Jessica's voice claimed.

Wait. Shit. That meant the moans were Amanda.

My eyes opened to see first Ben looking smug and happy and as my vision rolled down i saw Amanda on her hands and knees in front of me and Jessica. With Ben's hands on her ass and her head down on the mattress gripping the sheets. I couldn't see her face with Jessica in the way.

"You know what she is experiencing from our first time babe." Ben explained. "When i hit about 6 inches deep she is just virgin tight on my head."

Really 6 was an exaggeration. I wasn't tiny, but i hadn't hit 5.5 when i measured. I need to change the dynamic here before this gets away from me. Slow and steady hadn't seemed to work on Jessica and my soul couldn't take just sitting here and watching Ben work over Amanda.

I slapped Jessica's ass and increased my pace with some aggression in my thrusts, i needed to make her feel me. "OH! there we go!" Jessica cried out as our bodies met repeatedly. I knew i couldn't keep this pace up for long with the way Jessica was making my dick feel but i needed to try damnit!

"That's it James fuck her good! Make her cum!" Amanda nearly shouted.

Ben chuckled before declaring "Oh that is what we are doing? Alright!" He leaned forward and grabbed one of Amanda's wrist with each hand and pulled her back into a more upright position. And used the leverage to pull back on her as he pushed forward.

The result was clearly...effective. Amanda's face shifted from surprise at being pulled up by her wrists, into a twisted expression somewhere between agony and ecstasy as Ben slid to new depths.

"We could make this night even more interesting." Ben pondered aloud. "Whichever guy makes his girl cum first gets them both for rest of the night?"

Jessica didn't hesitate as i kept thrusting into her from behind "Best man wins? I love it!".

Amanda looked me in the eyes for a few moments and stated simply "Of course, James is the better man. This way he can get what he deserves."

Three sets of eyes looked at me as the last vote, I hesitated and Ben sensed my fear.

"Listen, I have done threesomes before so its only fair I offer a handicap." Ben offered. "I have to make Amanda cum twice to win?"

My experience with Amanda put me over the edge on accepting. In the countless dozens of times we had been together sexually she had only cum twice maybe 3? 4? times. It was HARD to get her off multiple times. Besides Ben hadn't cum yet and I had. It was doubtful anyone could get her off again before blowing a load the way he had been stimulated tonight. Twice? no way.

I nodded at the group and Amanda grinned fiercely at me and mouthed an 'i love you' before nodding at Jessica, telling me to get to work.

My thrusts sped up and i tried to add as much power to them as i could as well, making the sound of my groin hitting Jessica's ass the music of the moment.

Ben added a different sound as he took a measured pace at Amanda's pussy and the only sound from their bodies was a wet slurp that i didn't recognize but assumed was a too-thick cock pulling a soaking pussy apart. Listening for a minute i realized i never heard Ben's body connect with Amanda's ass.

It turned out I had both girls in my corner. Jessica put her shoulders to the mattress and started playing with her own clit and explaining her choice. "James you have always been so good to my BFF as a boyfriend and to me as a friend. comforting me during my break up with my fiancé, helping me heal and build my confidence back."

Amanda looked at us with a scowl that I think had everything to do with the cock inside of her and not what she was hearing as Jessica continued.

"I know about how much you want me and your chief fantasy of having us at the same time. I believe the quality of sex should be more about affection and emotion and passion then any physical attributes or skills."

During her speech i had never wanted her more. Never wanted Ben to be gone more. Feeling appreciated as a human being while also pushing myself into her willing (and perfect) body was better than any high I had experienced.

The interruption hurt more because of it. Amanda had failed to keep quiet. "Fuck. Fuck. Fuck. Fuck. Shit! SHIT!".

It was Jessica who responded to her. "Don't cum Amanda! For James's sake!"

Ben for his part just kept a measured pace, thrusting with purpose and withdrawing, no urgency in his movements.

My loving girlfriend continued. "I don't...I cant...its just...fuck...its just SO thick." She put her head down briefly and tried to endure in silence for a moment before admitting. "It is just touching everything on each thrust. I...I...I'M CUMMMMMMMMINNNNGGGG"

She fought against Ben's arms and after a moment he relented and let her fall to the mattress on her face. His cock springing free of her with a PLOP sound and as it rebounded upward it flicked drops of Amanda's essence forward. Small drops of my girlfriends cum landed on Jessica and I.

Looking at Ben i could see his cock proudly hard as ever. Its size shocking every time i saw and this time up close for the first time. It had to be as thick as MY wrist. and it's natural resting place seemed to be upwards instead of hanging down as it raised to be nearly pointing upwards along Ben's abs.

Most disturbing was the ring of white froth that clearly had come from Amanda's pussy. Not the quantity or even its existence (which was a new ability of her body to my knowledge) But that it was maybe slightly past halfway down his shaft. He had not been close to ball's deep and had made Amanda cum while she actively resisted its power.

I tore my eyes away from it and looked down at Jessica and focused on thrusting and changing my angles and tempo. Anything to get her to the finish line. The urgency was not really because Amanda had cum once, i really believed a second would be much harder. But because i could feel myself reaching my edge.

I was more racing myself than Ben and Amanda at this point. Ben didn't wait for more than 10 seconds of Amanda riding out her orgasm before he crawled up the bed and mounted her in her prone position. Putting himself into a near plank above her and beginning to reinsert.

After a minute of Ben working himself back to halfway inside of Amanda and beginning to pump her body again, i felt myself losing control. I was racing toward an orgasm and needed a break. I knew from experience i was unlikely to get hard again for at least 20-30 minutes if i blew a second load.

I came to a pause resting inside of Jessica. She looked back at me in confusion from the mattress and did something i didn't expect. She started twerking herself on my dick. "James I am getting close!" she cried out as she worked my dick.

"Stop Jessica! I need a second!" I shouted as I backed away from her and pulled my dick into the open air. Raising my hands to not touch myself it held for a few moments then my nightmare happened. Jessica's ass working me when i relaxed was too much. Cum started dripping out of my dick onto the mattress.

The blissful agony of a no touch ruined orgasm for the second time was nothing compared to the realization I had gotten two chances with Jessica and both times had cum before her. Instead of claiming her and painting her angelic freckled face with lines of cum like i had dreamed of doing, I was dripping cum onto my own bed.

All while Jessica pushed her ass into the air hoping a man would make her cum and my girlfriend was speared on half of a monster cock.