"Innocence can be difficult to define. Is it the absence of guilt? Is it the absence of guilty intentions? Is it being lucky enough not to be caught in the act? Are there levels of innocence? If the tension of hypocrisy is the partition between what exists inwardly in secret and what is outwardly projected, is that commendable or discrediting?"
Mike smiled and paused. He wanted to let the questions marinate in the minds of his students. He never grew weary of fostering a sense of intellectual curiosity in his students, compounded by the moral judgements required to address certain topics. A room full of mid-twenties aged grad students seeking his approval could be intoxicating. Especially when they tried to impress with their own perspectives in the belief that they could impress him, perhaps even debate on his level. He was no egomaniac nor an authoritarian snob, but he did enjoy what he viewed as the sacred honor of contributing to the successful journey of those who were willing to engage.
"Innocence is purity," was the first response. Short. Succinct. An honest attempt. Mike nodded without speaking. Jennifer was not sure if he was agreeing with her answer or patronizing her. She wondered to herself if she should elaborate, but for the moment chose to believe the he was signaling that at least she gave it a good effort.
"Innocence is the antithesis of guilt. Without guilt, there can be no innocence." Maria stopped as if she had more to say but wasn't sure she was willing to risk further investment until affirmed. Mike offered that smile. He nodded, as if inviting her to elaborate.
Maria bit her lip, then pushed a little further. "The moral weight of innocence can not exceed the moral weight of guilt. So innocence is only as robust as the countering, existing guilt."
The class was pensive and quiet. Mike looked directly at Maria, then in an accepting tone replied to her. "So Maria. If there is an absence of consciousness of guilt, would that therefore make innocence unobtainable?"
Eyes focused on Maria. Her soft, warm, brown eyes signaled that she could not respond, so Mike continued. "Let's say, for example, there is such an ignorance of a point of law that one is utterly bankrupt of even the slightest sense of guilt. Wrong has clearly been committed, but there is absolutely no association of guilt for the lawbreaker. If we understand your thought correctly, you would assert that this would define one as neither guilty or innocent; in essence, the absence of all moral accountability."
Maria tried to grasp the concept. Before she could speak, Mike continued. "For example. Person 'A' loves person 'B'. Person 'A' sleeps with person 'B'. Person 'A' believes that person 'B' is both legally and morally fair game. Is person 'A' guilty of anything if person 'B" is indeed married?"
From the back of the class, John quipped, "Guilty of being stupid." The class laughed, releasing some of the stress in the room.
Mike smiled. "Well Maria. It seems that John disagrees with you."
John squirmed as Maria glanced at him. He was simply being a smartass.
Mike pressed on. "So just to be clear John, let me restate what I heard you say. The absence of knowledge - which would set the perimeters for innocence and guilt - condemns a person to being guilty... of lacking knowledge. Is that right?"
John did not understand the question. Mike could tell. "Let me put it this way, in a way perhaps you better understand." Mike walked over next to Maria, stood directly next to her as she sat her desk, creating a dramatic moment. "If Maria would allow me to use her as a piece in this rubric for John's sake." He smiled down at Maria.
Maria nervously returned a smile to Mike while also shooting a glare in John's direction. "Sure, use me."
Mike coolly puffed, "Great. So follow along John. Maria believes I am single and never-married. She believes that my moral code is totally in harmony with a relationship between us. She gives herself to me. We fuck. She never knows that I am indeed married. Of what, exactly, is she guilty?"
The edge of tension increased in the room as each person tried to managed the multiple levels of conflict unfolding. Some were worried for Maria. Others were taken aback at Mike's use of the word "fuck." A few felt sorry for John, who obviously was in over his head. And nearly all were scrambling to mentally gather their own thoughts lest they be called upon to offer their judgment.
With the borderline sexual harassment hanging in the air, the outing of a class clown, and the moral dilemma not going anywhere, not a creature was stirring, not even a mouse.
Then, sensing his students need for an escape route from the moment, Mike announced, "I will let you stew on this. We will pick up here next time." As the sound of students stirring so as to not allow him even a second to change his mind, Mike added, "Reminder; chapters 8-10 next time... AND be prepared to defend your position." As the trail of bodies began to exit the room he added, "Make sure you HAVE a position to defend." He smiled, feeling a sense of accomplishment it gifting his students an opportunity to think at levels that were challenging.
He watched as Maria made her way to the exit, a bit slower than the others. As he tried to gauge her state of mind, closely examining her body language, he enjoyed his own private thoughts inspired by her body. Those eyes were like puppy dog eyes, smoldering and sensual. Her coal-black hair glistened, hanging just above her shoulders. Then there was those curves. Standing no more than 5 feet 5 inches perhaps, a frame he guessed rounded out about 130 pounds, she possessed the salacious curves in both breasts and ass. As she wiggled away wearing leggings and a tee which both complimented that fit body of hers, he discreetly analyzed every inch of her.
During office hours that afternoon, he had three students who had made appointments. Although his office hours were posted as 4-6 pm, his students understood that due to the secretary's workday ending at 5 pm, you had to be inside the office no later than 4:55, as the doors would be locked when the secretary left. Those with appointments after 5 pm were relegated to waiting alone in the modestly furnished (a couch and two chairs) reception area after the secretary left.
The schedule showed Brian at 4:30, Jennifer at 5:00, Maria at 5:30.
As Mike addressed Brian's concerns behind the closed door of his office, both Jennifer and Maria arrived at about the same time and took their places waiting on the couch. Moments later, the secretary bid them a good day. Both Jennifer and Maria knew the procedures, both having had previous office appointments with Mike in the past. Wait your turn. Do not let anyone else into the office. When you leave, make sure the door closes behind you.
The two girls chatted politely as they passed the time. As soon as the secretary exited, Jennifer turned serious and shifted to look Maria in the eyes. "I guess John learned a lesson today, eh?"
Maria giggled, "He had it coming."
Jennifer nodded. "Yeah, but he is a funny guy. I don't think he was really voicing disagreement with you."
"No worries, Jen. It was nothing, really."
"Nothing?" Jennifer raised her eyebrows, extended her hand towards Maria's shoulder, and with a tone dripping in concern repeated, "Nothing?" After a brief pause she added, "Maria. That was a bit edgy don't you think?"
"Edgy?"
"Oh my god, yes. I mean, I know it was just an hypothetical example, but I think it was kind of edgy."
"You mean Mike using me as an example?"
"I mean Mike using you as an example, but not just any example . . ." Jennifer's voice tailed off.
Maria nodded, waited a moment, and then seemed to offer to finish Jennifer's sentence. "...An example our mom's might not be proud of." She smiled to disarm Jennifer. Jennifer smiled back.
The two of them chatted further, as Jennifer seemed to want to relive the moments from class about as much as Maria seemed content to simply move on from those moments. Then Mike's office door opened and Brian stepped into the hallway. He smiled at Jennifer and politely said, "Your turn."
Jennifer leaned in and gave Maria a hug before she got up and walked to Mike's office. Brian felt his own wave of concern for Maria, and sat down in Jennifer's place and rehashed those 'edgy' moments with Maria in his own way, adding his own perspective. Maria deflected the questions and graciously assured Brian that she was just fine. Brian was a great guy, but Maria was a bit on her guard around him. He was one of those people who was just too free with their opinions for her tastes.
After asking a few questions and offering even more opinions, Brian got up to leave. With a glint in his eyes as he headed toward the door he bid her farewell and added, "By the way, clever hoodie there."
Maria smiled, "Bye. Thanks." Brian left. She sat alone. His final comment echoed in her mind as she sat there, gently tugging the front of the hoodie jacket away from her as she glanced down at the printed message and just shook her head at herself, wondering how many people actually read the entire message.
Four lines were embossed in block, white letters across the front on the black jacket. The first three lines, printed across her breasts, each had a checked box bullet point.
--Adorable
--Smart
--Big time student loans
The last line, positioned lower across her flat tummy, was the kicker . . .
Accepting applications for Sugar Daddy
Jennifer emerged from Mike's office and offered Maria a nervous smile saying, "Your turn. See you tomorrow, okay?"
Maria gave her hug. "Thanks, Jen." Then she watched Jennifer exit and took notice that the door shut behind her.
Maria walked to the doorway of Mike's office, peeked in and softly asked, "Ready for me?"
Mike offered a big smile and a sweeping gesture towards the chair next to his desk. "Am I?"