The following is a sequel to StangStar06's inspiring BTB story for Thanksgiving 2013 Airbag Thanksgiving. It was for me in equal measures dramatic and horrific. And thanks to the devilish suggestion from a fellow author, DFWBeast, I decided to do a gothic horror twist for the sequel. My inspiration for the twist here includes: Edgar Allan Poe's Eleonora, Ligeia and Morella as well as Henry James' The Romance of Certain Old Clothes. Hope you'll enjoy this twisted tale for the holidays!
Ian
I stood in front of my wife's grave in a numb blank. I wasn't sure what to feel or think. I guess I'd loved Selena on some level yet the discoveries of the last year left me wondering if I ever knew what love is. It wasn't some engineering problem that I could solve. It wasn't a car that I could try to fix or understand. Before marrage, I thought I had feelings for Selena but I had been banging her sister for much of the time that I had been hanging with Selena. Yes, Melissa had manipulated me into sleeping with her and later into marriage. However, before the discovery of her longstanding affair with Johnny, we had been happy and I had loved her even though I'd professed to have feelings for Selena. Of course, my feelings for both didn't stop me from being a leading cause of death for both sisters. And now, in a final irony, the two sisters were buried side by side. I wondered if both were spinning in their graves.
And I wondered if I'd soon find out why Melissa had asked me to appear at her graveside on this Thanksgiving afternoon...
A Year Ago
Three weeks before Halloween
Selena rubbed her big belly absent-mindedly with pleasure as she watched Piper and Steve play in the sunshine in the backyard. The kids had adjusted well to the loss of their mother Melissa and were well on their way to accepting that their aunt was now their father's new wife and their new mommy. Neither had called her mommy as yet but she was hopeful that the awkwardness would subside once they accepted that she was a permanent fixture in their lives and that she was going to give them a new sibling.
What had disconcerted her though was the closeness of the housekeeper, who Ian had retained after Melissa died, to the children and how she often looked at Selena with disapproval. Particularly the fact that Selena had moved into Ian's bedroom on the very day he had been discharged from hospital. It had worsened when Ian and her started having sex, the woman had radiated disapproval whenever she had to change the stained and rumpled bed sheets, which was daily.
Actually, now that she thought about it, Selena realised that the housekeeper's hostility and disapproval of her increased before the sex began. It began the day Selena had burnt the pages she had torn from Melissa's diary. A chill still ran through Selena at the recollection of that day 10 months ago. She'd finally read Melissa's diary in its entirety and realised how close she came to losing to Melissa again. That prompted fury that matched what she felt when Melissa had stolen Ian from her all those years ago. Another thought occurred to her, if Ian found and read the last pages, she would lose him to Melissa again, albeit on an emotional level.
'Damn you Melissa! I won't let you get away with stealing Ian again. Not emotionally or any other way' Selena thought to herself.
Those thoughts drove Selena to an impulsive act that she was unsure if she really regretted even now. She tore those last pages of Melissa's diary and ran out of the house. No one else was in the house, Ian had taken the kids to go last minute Christmas shopping. The housekeeper was nowhere to be seen after she'd finished the dishes from brunch. Selena looked around and saw no one in sight, which was hardly surprising considering how cold it was outside. She picked up some stray dried branches of the trees that were now bare and withered in the backyard and dried them meticulously. Then she searched for some lighter fluid in the garage. Failing to find some, she settled on motor oil, the disused can of motor oil that had been meant for Melissa's ill-fated Jaguar.
It gave her pause. She remembered the initial horror when she realised Ian's role in Melissa's death. It had all been swept aside in her rationalising process,centred on the one premise: the bitch had it coming after all her nasty tricks and behaviour.
The same rationalising process had her reaching for the motor oil as an alternative to the lighter fluid. It would just be an added touch of irony to the vengeance she was about to wreak on her dead sister.
Selena poured the motor oil on the branches, there was little of it left and she hoped it would be sufficient for the task. She searched for a lighter or matches but found none. Silently cursing, she wondered why it was so difficult to destroy Melissa's last attempt to win Ian back.
A stray thought almost like a whisper floated across her mind.
Maybe it's meant to be.
She shook her head, wishing to deny that thought because of its implications: that she and Ian weren't meant to be.
'No, damn it! We were meant to be together. It was Melissa who stole him and hurt him. I'm just going to make things right again!' Her jaw clenched in rage at those thoughts.