"I'm sorry Don. I know I'm going to miss you but it's for the best."
I was ending my 3 month affair with Don Miles. He was a lovely guy and great in bed. He had brought a new zest for life to the bored, fed up woman that I had been when I met him.
In fact my weekly afternoon trysts with Don had been the best possible therapy I could have had. They had put a sparkle into my life and I was a better woman, wife and mother for it. Because I was a better wife, my husband Josh had picked up on it and was giving me the love and attention that I needed. It made me see how much I loved my boring, predictable, stick in the mud husband and how much I needed him. And of course I loved my two kids and certainly I wanted to keep our family together.
So before anything went horribly wrong I had decided to end it with Don.
"Do we really have to end it Carol? Our Thursday afternoons together have been wonderful."
"And for me too," I told him. "But I don't want to risk my marriage and family."
Don nodded acceptance. "Yeah, I suppose you're right."
I felt bad doing this to Don. He had done wonders for me and had even helped to improve my marriage. He was a decent man. I suspected he was on his way to falling in love with me which was another good reason to end the affair. Then Don could find a girl of his own and marry her. I found myself getting a pang of jealousy just from the thought. Don wasn't mine and I had no right to be jealous of him. Perhaps I was becoming too fond of Don.
"You know, Carol, we might not have to end it."
Interesting. What did Don have in mind?
"You know there are quite a lot of husbands who like their wives to go with other men."
I did know that. Some women I knew had husbands with that trait. Most of them had other men 'just to please their husbands'. Until Don I had disapproved of them. I didn't think Josh had that trait. Certainly he had never mentioned it. I said that to Don.
"You could sound him out on it," Don said. "Didn't you say he got turned on when you told him about your old flames?"
I'd forgotten about that. Yes he had. At the time I was embarrassed about my past and the topic had become off-limits between us. Just possibly Josh might have that trait. I knew he wasn't possessive or controlling. He'd even once told me that he liked me being my own person. It made me a better wife for him. But I didn't think he'd include my affair with Don in that.
I felt sad leaving Don's flat for the last time. I was missing him already, and I feared that my marriage would fall back into that same rut it had been before Don. I promised myself that I wouldn't let that happen. That I would keep it exciting and interesting even without Don in my life.
From Don's place I collected the kids from their play dates, got the older one started with his homework and let the younger one help me with getting the family dinner ready for when Josh came home. This used to be a boring chore before I met Don. Now it was good fun and I loved the mother daughter relationship I had with my younger child.
When Josh came home from work he gave me a kiss, played with his kids for a while then laid the table. We all sat around it for our dinner and the conversation flowed freely. Josh believed that getting our kids to tell us about their day and us telling about ours developed the kids' language skills. I'd been wrong to think of Josh as boring and predictable, he was absolutely committed to his family and was only predictable in the sense that he could always be relied on to do his best for us. It almost brought tears to my eyes as I thought how beautiful our family life was. Later, after the children were in bed Josh read them their bed time story.
In bed that night Josh was in the mood for some nooky. I'd already had my quota for the day but I knew better than to deny Josh. In fact I confess to getting a kick out of having two men in one day. It brings out the inner slut in me and I thoroughly enjoyed it as my husband slid into me and started pumping. I came quickly and often. It occurred to me that two men a day was an extremely pleasant arrangement.
It was nearly a week later that the topic came up. It was something on the news about a famous sports star who confessed to enjoy cuckolding. I thought I would sound Josh out on whether he would like me to have another man in my life.
"What do men get out of it?" I asked Josh. I was trying to tread lightly here and phase in the topic so that it came up naturally.
"They get turned on by it," Josh told me.
"So why do some men get all angry and jealous and other men get turned on?"
"The men who are ok with it know all about it so there's no cheating or deceit, I suppose. And they enjoy it."
"How would you feel about it?"
"What you having another man?"
"Yes and you knew about it?"
Josh looked puzzled. "I thought you already were. Don't you see your Don Miles chap on Thursday afternoons?"
Oh my God! Josh knew about me and Don. I was taken completely by surprise. I couldn't think what to say. "How did you find out?"
"You told me."
I certainly didn't tell him. That was the last thing I'd have done.
"Don't you remember? You woke me up in the middle of the night and told me you fancied a man called Don Miles. You said it was some sort of need you had. I was too sleepy to argue and just said 'okay' and went back to sleep.
I was still in a state of shock, getting worse if anything.
"I broke up with him today," I told Josh. "I'm not seeing him anymore."
"That's your decision. It seemed to me that what you had going there was good for you. You've been a lot more relaxed and cheerful. The whole family benefitted."
"You aren't cross with me then?"
"How could I be? I'd said it was okay so you weren't actually cheating. I expected you to tell me about it but when you didn't I supposed you were shy or something. Like you never wanted to talk about your old flames."
So I still had a marriage. Josh seemed to have taken it all in his stride and wasn't concerned. But my heart was still pounding and there were butterflies in my stomach.
He didn't seem at all upset so dare I try total honesty? That would be easier. I knew I was confused and my mind in a turmoil. I needed time to think. "Let's have some tea, Josh, and we can talk about it."
"All right. I'll make it." Josh went out to the kitchen. I sat and tried to get my mind working again. Josh knew I'd been seeing Don and he didn't seem to mind. Did he really not mind? If he'd been seeing another woman I'd have killed both of them. But that's me. And he knew about it but he hadn't said anything or even given any hint that he knew. How the heck did he know? I was sure I hadn't told him. I thought I was keeping my guilty secret.
Josh came in with a tray of tea things. "Let it brew for a while," he said putting it down.
"Josh, you seem to have taken my thing with Don very calmly. How is that? Is it that you don't care?"
"I remember thinking before it started that you were looking and acting a bit ragged. Like you were depressed and fed up with it all. I was trying to think of something exciting for you that we could afford and the kids would enjoy too."
He was right. I remembered I had been feeling run down.
"Then you came up with this Don Miles thing and it seemed like an answer. You picked a damned good time to tell me about it though. I don't think I'd have agreed if I'd been fully awake."
"I still don't remember telling you. Was I talking in my sleep?"
"You spoke clearly and articulately, like you normally speak. I assumed you'd been lying awake thinking about it. Sometimes you talk in your sleep and it's meaningless babble."
I poured the tea to gain thinking time. "How did you feel about it?"
"I was concerned that it would be bad for our marriage but I couldn't see you running off and breaking up the family. Also I felt a bit humiliated that I wasn't enough man for you. Against that I thought it might be good for you and restore you to your normal happy, loving self. So on balance I thought to risk it."
I was impressed by Josh's insightfulness. He seemed to understand perfectly. He knew me better than I knew myself. "Josh you don't need to feel humiliated. It was just some excitement and novelty that I needed. That's all. It is no reflection on you as a man."
"Well, it does seem to have done the trick. You are a much better person for it. More loving to me and our children and happier in yourself." Josh paused, then added as an afterthought: "But I am pleased you've stopped seeing him. I wasn't happy about it."
"You didn't get that turn-on effect that some husbands have?"