There was a biker bar not far from the house my wife Katie and I rented when we were first married. It was the prototypical biker bar, a seedy wooden storefront with one small window, and several Harleys always parked in front.
We were about as far from being bikers as anyone could be. At least Katie had ridden on the back of a motorcycle before, but I don't think I had ever even touched a motorcycle, much less driven one. No, we were straight-laced accountants who would be as out of place there as a librarian at a book burning. But we would always joke about going to the biker bar, and socializing with its denizens. Then at some point, that idea then started to get us a little sexually charged up.
Although Katie was relatively inexperienced sexually (I was her one and only sex partner before she married me), she was enthusiastic and adventurous in bed. She liked role playing, and we played out many of our fantasies. Mine tended toward light bondage, while hers involved pretending to have sex with strangers or with multiple partners. What was the most exciting about sex with Katie was that she really understood me and what turned me on. And she wasn't shy about communicating her desires, either. In other words, she was the perfect sex partner.
One day, Katie came home from her parents' house, dressed in a leather jacket and a jeans skirt that she had found in her old closet. I told her she would fit right in at the biker bar, which, by the way, was called "The Wayside Inn". I told her that if she would go there and have a drink, I would eat her out until she came (her favorite thing). She joked that if she went there, she would be so turned on that she would blow a biker. I said, really, come on, I dare you to go have a beer there.
"Unless, you feel like you can't handle it," I said.
"Really," she said. "You think it's that big a deal? You think I'm afraid to go into a bar and have a drink?"
"Well," I said. "It's a biker bar."
"Do you think they'll rape me when I walk in?" she asked.
"No," I said. "But you'll definitely get hit on."
"I don't even think that would happen," she said. "But if it's going to turn you on, I'll go. And you have to eat me every night for a week."
"Okay," I said. "It's a deal."
Before she could change her mind, we got into the car, and I drove her the mile and a half to the bar. We had never done anything like this, and I was almost quivering with excitement. Katie looked perfectly calm, however. We agreed that I would pick her up in an hour and a half. As I pulled up in front of the bar, Katie took off her wedding ring and handed it to me, and I nervously watched her go into the Wayside Inn, feeling somewhat queasy. I was surprised she didn't seem scared at all.
I drove home to wait, and I had high anxiety the whole time. Images flashed in my head, and I couldn't sit still. Several times I got back into my car to go back to the bar. But I told myself, she was right, there wasn't anything to worry about. Still, time moved very slowly over the next hour and a half, and I got into my car ten minutes before the appointed time to go pick her up. But before I could start my car, a loud motorcycle came up our street, with Katie riding in the back, holding on to a very large biker. She got off, gave the driver a kiss on the cheek, and went into the house.
"What the hell?" I asked her, in amazement.
"That was Vince," Katie said. It turned out that it was a guy she knew from high school. They weren't friends, but knew each other. They recognized each other in the bar, and ended up having a beer and talking for an hour before he drove her home.
That night, we had incredible sex, fueled by Katie's trip to the biker bar. She told me about the men she saw in there, as well as some women. She said a couple of guys had talked to her at the bar-but she said they weren't exactly hitting on her-before she saw Vince.
As I ate her out, per our agreement, she talked about what happened, embellishing on the details for my enjoyment. Katie really knew how to make up and describe a sex scene.
"These big dudes were staring at me, honey," she said. "I could tell they wanted to fuck me. I saw that there was a dark room in the back, and that's probably where they take girls like me and have their way with them. Even when I was talking to Vince, a couple of guys came up to us, and asked Vince if they could have a turn with me when he was done fucking me."
I'm pretty sure she was making that part up, but it almost made me come on the spot.
"There was another woman there that they were passing around, and a guy told me that I was going to be next. They were pawing her and fondling her breasts and they had her shirt undone. I saw a guy put his hand into her panties, and I knew that if I didn't leave soon that that was going to happen to me."
I couldn't wait any longer. I climbed on top of Katie and put my erection inside her.
"I think Vince might have a really big cock," Katie said, and that was enough to make me come, just seconds after I had entered her. "Oh god," she wailed. "I hope Vince doesn't come that quickly when he fucks me."
We did nothing but fantasize about the biker bar over the next month during sex. I came to realize that my fixation with the biker bar before Katie had even gone there had to do with being turned on with the idea of someone else fucking my wife. I had never admitted to myself that I was that guy, but it was true.
I told Katie that the idea of her with someone else turned me on.
"Do you think that's normal?" I asked her.
"I think it's very normal," Katie replied. "I think jealousy and lust are intertwined."
"It feels like a weird thought to me," I said.
"I don't think it's weird," Katie reassured me.
I assured her that I didn't actually want her to have sex with someone else, I just like to fantasize about it. As usual, Katie was a 100% into my fantasy. Once, when we were having sex, she told me that she had accidentally touched Vince's penis while they were on his motorcycle.
"When I put my arms around his waist, his penis was already hard, and it was so long I think I touched the head," she said one day while we were talking about the biker bar during sex. "And his abs were so hard, it made me wonder what it would be like to have someone that big and strong do it to me."
For the first time, the line between fantasy and reality became blurred for me. I started to wonder if Katie wanted to have sex with someone like Vince, or if she was just playing along with my fantasy. It bothered me, but at the same time, her pillow talk was an enormous turn on for me.
Sometimes when I was at work, the thought occurred to me that Katie could be having sex with Vince at that very moment, and that idea would make me a little crazy. While we were having sex, I would ask her if she wanted to have sex with Vince. She always seemed to know what to say to me that would both turn me on and twist the knife.
"Yes, I want to have sex with Vince," she would say. "But I'm afraid he would be an animal in bed and hurt me." Or she would say, "I really don't want to, but I know you're going to force me to." The first time she said this, we were in the middle of intercourse, and it made me come, instantly.
One night, I was on top as we were having sex, and I asked her about how much she wanted to screw Vince.
"You want him so bad, don't you?"