Those that needed to went to the bathroom. It took about five minutes for everyone to cycle into the bathroom. Everyone also refreshed their drinks. I was probably the only one not drinking. I had wine with dinner but switched to club soda. Once we were all back sitting in the living room, everyone looked to me. I shrugged.
"Bridget, you get to ask this time."
"Oui," she said. She looked around the living room and her gaze settled on me. "Mr. Don?"
"Yes."
"Same question you asked your wife," she said. And here I thought I would have to wait until it came around to Judy again.
"Well, let's see. Now don't rush me...I haven't had any other pussy except Judy's since we were married until we came to this resort."
"Truth?" everyone shouted.
"Truth," I said.
"Oh my god," Judy whispered.
Then she was sitting on my lap her lips pressed to mine in a passionate kiss that nearly blew the top of my head off. Then she was whispering between soft gentle kissed to my face, "I'm so sorry, so sorry."
"No need to be sorry, sweetheart, I survived," I whispered back.
"Don?" Bridget said.
"Melissa, truth or dare?" I asked.
"Truth."
"Melissa, same question," I said.
"I knew it," Melissa said. "What's the punishment if I don't tell?"
"I get to spank you unless of course, you enjoy that, then us three guys get to fuck you up the ass, at the same time."
"Fine. It was when I was out of town and Slater was fucking my sister. A guy I worked with was always bragging how good he was in the sack. After the meetings one night we all went out for drinks. I had a little too much and when he started bragging again, I grabbed his hand and pulled him out of the bar and up to my room.
"He was so nervous he couldn't get it up. I had to suck him off to get him hard. Then his cock was nothing to brag about. He fucked me once, came inside me and was done. I told him if he ever told anyone about what we did, I would tell everyone he couldn't perform at all. I also told him if he ever started bragging again, I would tell everyone he couldn't get it up at all."
Slater didn't say a word, he just smiled at his wife as he sported a hard-on.
"My turn. Carlo, truth or dare?" Melissa asked the chef.
"Dare," he said.
"Okay, go get the biggest dildo...just kidding. Have you ever fucked your wife in the ass?"
"No." He wasn't smiling.
"Okay. I won't make you do that. Fuck me in the ass until you cum."
Melissa stood, turned around and bent forward in front of her husband. They were eye to eye as Melissa waited. Bridget was whispering to Carlo and nodding toward Melissa. Carlo shrugged and got up. He stood behind Melissa, his cock already hard. Judy got up and went to them, licking Melissa's asshole until it was all wet. Then she sucked Carlo until her saliva coated his hard cock.
Judy then took his cock in hand and guided him to Melissa's asshole. Then he gently pressed into her bottom. She was groaning as he entered her. Then she started shaking as he pressed farther into her. Once he was all the way inside her, she told him to wait. Once she was comfortable with his cock in her, she nodded. Carlo began to fuck her ass. He fucked her slow and easy, taking full, long strokes into her.
"Oh my god! That big cock of yours is touching places no one else has, baby," she told Carlo.
Then Melissa was coming. She was coming hard. Carlo watched as his cock slid in and out of her body. Then he groaned as he pushed in one last time. His cock pulsed as he shot his cum into Melissa's asshole. He just pressed against her ass as he jerked with each spurt into her. Bridget was fingering herself as she watched them. She came shortly after they did.
"Go clean up and we will continue if you want?" I said.
Melissa climbed to her feet. Carlo helped her to the bathroom. Bridget closed her eyes, her fingers still inside her pussy. Judy went over to her.
"Are you okay Bridget?" she asked.
"Huh? Oh yes, yes. Oh god," she said shaking with another orgasm.
"I want to talk to you later dear," Judy told her. Bridget just nodded.
After a ten-minute break, everyone was ready for another round. Bridget was whispering in Carlo's ear. He nodded as she spoke.
"Miss Judy?" Carlo finally asked.
"Yes?"
"Truth or Dare?"
"Dare," Judy said, surprising me.
"I want you to make love to my wife," Carlo said. Bridget squeaked but didn't say anything.
Judy stood, she pulled a large fluffy comforter from the side table and spread it on the floor between the two couches.
"Bridget, if you will join me?" Judy asked
"Of course Miss Judy," Bridget said rising and moving to the comforter.
"Lie down."
Bridget did, then Judy lay next to her. Judy propped herself up on her elbow and leaned in and kissed Bridget. Almost immediately, Bridget kissed her back. Then the two women were making love. Soft, sensuous love. Judy moved until her mouth was over Bridget's pussy and her pussy was over Bridget's mouth. The two women then started licking and sucking each other. The licked each other for twenty minutes, they each cum multiple times. Judy fell to the side and lay there looking up at the ceiling. Bridget sighed as she shook with her orgasm. Then Carlo was down beside his wife, kissing her. She kissed him back. Judy looked at me.
I smiled and nodded as I slipped off the couch and onto the floor next to her. I kissed her on the lips, hard. She kissed me back with a lot of passion. The only thing I could think was how much I loved her.
"Okay, break it up, you four," Melissa said clapping her hands.
Carlo, Bridget, Judy and I started laughing. We slowly got up, took a big slug of our drinks and sat back down.
"Judy, go," Melissa said.
"Melissa, truth or dare?" Judy asked her.
"Hmmm...truth," Melissa said this time.
"When did you eat your first pussy after you were married and who was it?" Judy asked.
Melissa turned a bright red and put her hand over her mouth. She looked at Slater with tears in her eyes but blinked them back as she calmed down. Then she nodded.
"Well you got me, Judy," she said. "It was the day we got married at the reception. My maid of honor, Carol, you don't need to know her last name, Slater knows who I'm talking about. Well, she came up to the suite we had booked for that night to help me get out of my wedding dress. When I was in my bra and panties, she pushed me back onto the bed and pulled my panties off.
"She told me she had wanted to do this since we first became friends in college. Then she smashed her face down on to my pussy. After I started to cum she moved herself around and pushed her naked pussy onto my face. She had her dress on but no panties. I just started eating her like I liked to be eaten. She came, I came, multiple times. I quickly got dressed when we were done and we went downstairs laughing
"It wasn't until later that I found her again. We met several times over the years."
"Why didn't you tell me," Slater growled holding his crotch.
"Because I thought you would divorce me at the time. I know I should have told you once we started to see other people together, but I couldn't bring myself to do that."
"That's okay darling, we'll talk later and no, I'm not mad at you."
"Thank you, dear," Melissa said.
"Melissa," I said. She looked at me and nodded.
She sat there with her face in her hands murmuring to herself.
"Judy, truth or dare?" Melissa asked her.
"Truth!" Judy said sticking her chin out boldly.
"Before coming to the island and after you married Don, have you ever eaten anyone's pussy?"
Judy closed her eyes and covered her mouth with her hand. She opened her eyes to slits, took her hand from her mouth.
"No, never," she said with conviction.
"Really?" Bridget and Melissa both said at the same time.
"Really," Judy responded. "In fact, before this weekend, I had never even thought of wanting another woman. Even before Don and I married."
"Do we break and go to bed now or..."
Nobody said anything.
"Judy?" I said.
"Don, truth or dare?"
"Truth," I said.
"Damn, I thought for sure you would pick dare. Oh well. Have ever sucked a cock or thought about sucking a cock, ever?" Judy asked me.
"Not really," I said.
"What do you mean "Not really"," Judy asked.
"I have never thought about sucking a man's cock, ever," I told her.
"Then what, dogs?" she was being sarcastic.
"No, a transsexual. You know a pretty almost a female with a cock. And it will never happen, I know that, so that's probably why I thought about what it might be like."
The room was suddenly quiet and everyone was staring at me. My wife's mouth was open her eyes wide.
"I would pay to see that," she said, eyes still wide.
"I know someone," Bridget said then shut up.
Judy looked at her nodding.
"It will never happen," I told Judy.
"Are you homophobic?" she asked.
"NO! You know I'm not, but I am not bi nor am I homosexual."
"Okay, sweetheart, okay," Judy said softly.
"It's late, I think I'll go to bed. Carlo, Bridget, you are welcome to stay here. There are the couches or pick a bed to join someone," I told them getting up and heading for my bedroom.
Judy got up and hurried after me.
"Don?" she asked.
"No, I'm not mad at you," I said turning toward her and wrapping my arms around her.
"Good. I love you so much," she croaked.
"And I love you just as much," I told her.
"I'm going to ask Bridget to sleep with us tonight. I know Melissa wants Carlo to go to her bed."
"That's fine dear. I know you wanted to talk to her anyway."
"We'll be right back."
"Okay," I said climbing into bed.
A short time later, Judy and Bridget came into the bedroom laughing and giggling. I just smiled as they got into bed with me. Somehow Bridget wound up between Judy and I. I sat up, leaned over Bridget and kissed Judy.
"Goodnight my dear. I love you."
"I love you too. Are you going to sleep?"
"I am, but don't let that bother you two," I said. Then I leaned down and kissed Bridget gently on the lips. "Goodnight to you my lovely Bridget."
"Goodnight Don," she said softly. I nodded at her, lay back down and rolled so my back was to them.
I was asleep within minutes of my head landing on my pillow. Several times during the night I woke to sex noised and being jostled. I just closed my eyes and fell back to sleep.
* * * *