Twin Seduction

Hello my beautiful readers,

Even though I have for about 10 different stories on my computer at the moment, this is an idea that came to me a couple of days ago. Even though it's less story driven than my usual work, but I felt that it deserved to be put down on paper (well, actually it was typed in a word-document, but you know what I mean).

I also don't want to spoil too much of the story, so I'm just going to say that if you find stories with sexual content offensive, close the browsed now. Naturally, all the characters in this story are 18+. I hope you enjoy reading it as much as I enjoyed writing it.

Xoxo

/Anna

*****

The morning after

*****

I woke up the next morning with a big grin on my face. Yes, there was a definite soreness in my butt from yesterday, but it only served to remind me that I had let my fears and inhibitions go, and thus had the most amazingly intense experience of my life. Thinking back on the previous evening made my body tingle, and it took an effort of will to keep from masturbate. I guess I had been pretty naïve, thinking that if being in a serious relationship with someone implied being monogamous with that person. I knew about polyamorous relationships, sure, but I never imagined myself meeting people like that in real life.

As I lay there in the bed, I realized that I didn't need to overanalyze the nature of Todd's and Sara's relationship. Sure, Todd and Adam played their parts (expertly I might add), but Sara had been the one who had seen the pent up desire in me, and had been instrumental in setting it up. Letting me share her boyfriend for a night meant more than I could put into words, and I giggled as I felt myself overwhelmed by the affection and trust she had shown me.

She had conspired behind my back though, and as I got out of bed, I grinned at the thought of getting back at Sara, and it didn't take long for me to come up with a plan of my own. I don't think I would have considered it, if it hadn't been for the amazing experience I had the night before, but it seemed last night had opened Pandora's box for me, and the tingling sensation between my legs told me to follow through. It would mean breaking at least a couple of boundaries, and I wasn't sure how Todd and Sara would react to it, but if it worked out, it'd all be worth it. I knew I had to speak to Todd, and since I didn't know when Sara would come home, I'd better be quick about it.

I hastily put on a pair of fresh panties and a tank top. I didn't bother with a bra, since I might take it off again pretty soon. Then I walked out into the hallway, and walked over to Todd's bedroom.

Standing outside the bedroom, I took a couple of deep breaths to calm myself. I had never been assertive, at least when it came to amorous matters. Could I actually go through with this? There was a voice inside me, telling me that this was what I had always wanted, even though I hadn't been aware of it. Thankfully I was able to talk to Todd alone first. In my mind, the best plans were those you could discuss with someone else, to get their feedback before proceeding.

I giggled as I finally knocked on the door, thinking that, since Todd was an integral part of my plan, I really did need him to get onboard with what I wanted to do.

*****

The talk

*****

"Come in," I heard Todd say from within the bedroom, and I hesitantly opened the door and walked into the room. Todd was still in bed, and he gave me a warm smile as I entered. He was laying under the covers, though they had been pulled down to reveal his muscular chest and impressive abs. I smiled back, thinking I had never realized what an absolute hunk he was. I suppose positively getting fucked to oblivion by a guy changes how you see them, and it was starting to make sense to me why he and Sara spent so much time fucking.

"How are you feeling today?" Todd asked, and I understood that it was more than the usual greeting people gave. He seemed to be aware that last night had been a life-altering experience for me, and it was heart warming to hear that he cared about how I felt about what we had done.

"A little sure in my butt," I said and giggled, eliciting a chuckle from Todd. "Other than that, yesterday was.. I don't know how to describe it," I added, and blushed hard. I wasn't used to talking about sex with a guy the day after, but thankfully the huge grin on my face spoke for me.

Todd nodded, and got up from the bed and walked up to me, placing a hand on my cheek as he looked deep into my eyes, clearly understanding what was going through my mind, well partially at least.

"I'm glad you enjoyed it, Anna," Todd said softly. For a split second it felt like the way he looked at me, and the way his hand stroked my cheek, was a prelude to something else, as if he wanted something physical. In that split second I knew that I wouldn't be able to say no, and I was sorely tempted to reached for his crotch. I swallowed hard, fighting down the urge, and as the moment passed, I realized that his touch was just as much one of caring about my well-being.

"Listen," I said eventually. "I've been thinking. A lot," I added, smiling up at Todd, and he took half a step backwards, with a curious smile. I took a deep breath to calm myself after Todd's gentle touch, also to give myself the courage to say what I needed to say.

"There are no words to describe how wonderful last night was," I began, and I couldn't suppress a smile as I saw the proud grin on Todd's face. I guess it never hurt to let a guy know what an excellent lover he was, but a part of me wanted him to know my thought process behind what I was going to suggest.

"You told me that Sara was the master mind behind what happened, and I think last night showed me that our friendship means more to her than I understood before," I continued, and I swallowed hard as I thought back to the feelings I had before falling asleep the day before.

Sara was the yin to my yang, and while I was a stereotypical wallflower, Sara was the life of the party. Time and time again, she had brought me out of my protective shell and shown me what life could be like if you let it happen. Until now I hadn't understood how much it had meant to her as well, to have me as the calm voice of reason when she needed guidance. I blushed even more as I felt myself getting emotional, standing there in front of her half-naked boyfriend.

"She really does love you, Anna," Todd said softly, and I felt a tear welling up in the corner of my eye. I realized I had better get to the point of the discussion soon, or my emotions would get the better of me.

"And I love her too," I replied, taking another deep breath. Todd smiled at me, calmly, letting me take the time I needed to convey my thoughts. "I want to show her just how much she means to me," I added, and I could see the light of recognition in Todd's eyes. He clearly understood that I had something particular in mind, and that he was a part of it. Todd nodded, silently letting me continue. I took yet another deep breath. I knew that this was it. The next few words from my mouth would make or break my plan. He might go along with it, but it was equally possible than I might run out of the room weeping.

"Has Sara ever... You know... with a girl?" I asked, looking into Todd's eyes with a nervous look. I could see his brain processing the implications of my question, and barely a heart beat later, his smile widened.

"No," Todd replied, and for a split second my heart broke. Were my plans foiled already? My mind ran a thousand miles a minute, as my brain imagined Sara rejecting me. "We've been talking about it though," Todd added, bringing my thoughts back from the brink of despair.

Then he took a step forward, standing right in front of me. His smile never left his face, as he reached up to stroke my cheek.

"I know it's something that Sara wants to try," Todd said softly. "I think she's been waiting for the right girl, and if you're suggesting what I think, I know for sure that she wants you to be her first," he added.

My heart skipped a beat as my brain registered what Todd was saying. Had Sara wanted something more than friendship from me? How had I missed it? God, I was feeling so stupid. I just stood there for a moment, processing every time we had spoken, all those clues and subtle hints she had given me. I began to laugh at myself. For all the book smarts I had, I hadn't even realized that Sara might have been sending me signals for the longest time.

I swallowed, curtailing my laughter, as I saw the confused look in Todd's eyes.

"I'm sorry," I said. "I was just thinking that, even a smart a person as I, can be oblivious to a friend's desires," I added.

"I guess so, yeah," Todd said with a smile. "So... what now?" he added, getting to the crux of what I had wanted to talk to him about.

"Well, waking up this morning, I had an idea for making it a reality," I said slowly. There it was. Out in the open. I had just admitted to Todd that I wanted to have sex with his girlfriend. As much as this had been about mine and Sara's feelings for each other, I knew I had to reckon with Todd's feelings as well, and I held my breath, waiting to see how he'd react.

"Is that so?" Todd said, making me giggle as he gave me the same mischievous smile I had seen the day before. "Tell me all about it," he added, and the tone of his voice told me that he was just as excited about it as I was.

*****

The plan unfurls

*****

I left Todd's bedroom, feeling as giddy as I had been when I had gotten into college, or on Christmas morning when I was younger. Then plan was now set in motion, and if it all worked out, Sara would find out that she wasn't the only one who could make secret plans.

Todd had told me that Sara would come over in about 30 minutes, so I went to the bathroom and freshened up with a nice, long shower and brushed my teeth. Just as I was getting ready, I heard Sara's voice from the hallway, announcing her arrival. I snuck closer to the bathroom door, placing my ear against the door, listening intently, and I heard two sets of footsteps walking down the hallway.

"Hey, baby," I heard Sara say in a sultry voice, evidently excited to meet Todd again. "How did it go last night?" she asked. Todd didn't reply, but I heard the sounds of a woman moaning, so it seemed Todd was doing his part in getting her aroused.

"Come to the bedroom, and I'll tell you all about it," I heard Todd say, and I covered my mouth with my hand to suppress a giggle, as I heard that he was just as turned on as Sara was. To be honest though, it took an effort of will to keep from touching myself right then and there. My body was shaking with a really potent mix of arousal and nervousness at that moment.

I heard footsteps walking down the hallway, and I knew Todd and Sara would be heading towards his bedroom. I could feel my heart beating thunderously loud in my chest. This was really going to happen, wasn't it? The plan was in motion, and like a train running down the railway track, there was no stopping it now. I suppose I could sneak back to the bedroom where my clothes were, get dressed, and then run out the front door. That would be really weird though, considering what I had said to Todd some 30 minutes ago.

The minutes seemed to take forever to pass, every second giving me time to feel even more nervous. Eventually I imagined what Sara was looking like in that very moment. Was she naked on her back? Was Todd fingering her, regaling to her what happened in the living room last night? The mental image of a naked Sara, in the height of arousal, not only calmed my shaking nerves, but fuelled my own excitement. I felt my cheeks flushing at the idea of what I was about to do.

It didn't take long before I decided I couldn't wait any longer, and I left the bathroom, sneaking as quietly as I could towards Todd's bedroom.

"Oh, god.. I wish I could have been there," I heard Sara say, her voice thick with arousal, and her words were intermixed with moans. I grinned, imagining what Todd was doing to her in that moment.

"Mmmm," I heard Todd mo**. "The look of pleasure on her face was so beautiful, when she came on my cock," Todd added, clearly as aroused as Sara. "Here baby, let me put this on you," Todd continued, following our plan to the letter.

"I like how you think," Sara said, a hint of surprise in her voice. "What about Anna?" she asked, and then began to moan again.

"She's still asleep, baby... We have time," Todd replied, and then there was a moment of silence, followed by the sound of someone moving about in Todd's bed.

"You look amazing, babe," Todd said. "Let me have a good look at you," he added, using our pre-planned words to let me know things was proceeding as I had hoped. I grabbed the doorknob, and my hands were trembling in anticipation as I slowly turned the knob and opened the door. I took a few steps into the room, and I was met by Todd looking up at me with a mischievous grin.

I realize I never described what Sara looked like, so I guess I should describe what I saw when I entered his bedroom.

Todd stood naked beside the bed, and to be honest, the sight of his sculpted muscles and impressively hard cock still amazed me. I tore my eyes away from him and looked at Sara. Sara is almost a head taller than me, almost as tall as Todd. She has long, jet black hair and dark brown eyes. At first glance, you might guess she has Mediterranean descent, except for her pale skin. Her breasts are almost as huge as mine, though I have her beat by a cup size or two. She was laying on her back in the middle of the bed, her arms above her head, an olive green blindfold covering her eyes, rendering the room dark around her. Her legs were far apart, clearly displaying her clean shaven pussy to me. It wasn't the first pussy, other than my own I had seen. For the first time though, I saw one with desire in my eyes, and I couldn't wait to touch it.

Todd wordlessly signaled for me to come closer, and I walked over to the bed, as silently as I could.

"What are you waiting for, babe?" Sara asked, and even though her voice betrayed her arousal, I could tell she was getting a little nervous. I guessed this wasn't something they did on a regular basis, but as I came closer, I pushed that thought from my mind. I had to focus, if this was going to work.

I slowly crawled up onto the bed on all fours, coming closer and closer to the spot between Sara's legs.

"Mmm... I see what you were thinking, babe. It's been a while since I had your tongue inside me," Sara said, still clueless as to what was happening. I couldn't tear my eyes away from Sara's naked body as I came closer, getting a taste for what her pussy smelled like for the first time. From the corner of my eye, I saw Todd walking up behind me, but my attention was focused on the task at hand. I had never considered myself bisexual before, and in that moment, I still wasn't sure. What I do know though, is that I had never seen anything as beautiful and sexually arousing before, and I was more determined than ever before to try my best to make Sara cum.

I inched my way closer and leaned my head down between Sara's legs. As I came closer to my goal, the fragrant smell of Sara's pussy hitting my nose, I regretted not doing this before. Sara let out a slight whimper, as she felt me coming closer, clearly impatient for her boyfriend to pleasure her.

I knew I had a limited amount of time before Sara would realize who it was in bed with her. I'm sorry to say this guys, but it's not really hard to tell the difference between when a guy is touching you and when a girl does it, so I knew I had to get going. I placed a soft kiss on the inside of Sara's right thigh, her skin so soft and smooth against my lips, eliciting a moan from her mouth, and my whole body shivered in delight. My eagerness to make her scream my name rose with every heart beat, and I continued to place tender kisses every centimeter up her leg, until I came face to face with her beautiful pussy lips.

I looked up towards Sara, and I could see the impatience writ large on her face. I could tell she was eager and willing, desperate for the sweet release her orgasm would give her.

Time seemed to slow down, my heart pounding in my chest as I leaned my head in closer and kiss her pussy lips for the first time, making her body tremble with arousal.

"Oh, my god, babe," Sara whimpered, as she grabbed her breasts with both hands, caressing the beautiful mounds. It was pretty clear her need to cum was growing with every touch of my lips. I wanted her to reach the brink of orgasm before revealing who I was, so I reached up with both hands, caressing the insides of her thighs, before slowly moving my hands up towards her pussy. I gently pulled her pussy lips apart, and placed the tip of my tongue at the bottom, slowly running it along the slit, until I reached her pretty little clit. When I flicked the tip of my tongue against the sensitive little nub, Sara let out a loud moan, her body starting to tremble.

"Oh, yes... oh fuck... don't stop babe," Sara whimpered, her voice rising several octaves. "H-have you... oh god... god... have you been practicing?" Sara asked, as I continued to use my tongue on her.

I wasn't sure if Todd was still in the room, and if he heard her question. I had already lost myself in the moment, and the world around me had been reduced to the wonderful, sexy girl I had in front of me.

Her moans rose in volume and frequency, and I felt my heart swell. Both from pride at being able to bring pleasure to a girl for the first time, but I also realized that this was what I had always wanted to do. I loved Sara, more than a friend, and I wanted her to know that there was nothing I wouldn't do for her.

A part of me sensed that the moment was fast approaching when she would sense something being different in how I pleasured her, and when I'd have to make my presence known. I realized I had planned everything perfectly, but at that moment, I had no idea about how to let her know that it wasn't Todd making love to her, but me. Was I just going to say something, and let her make the discovery based on my voice? Shit.

At that moment, I was so turned on by the vision of perfect beauty laying before me, that I couldn't think clearly. Instead I acted on instinct, thinking of what I'd like if the roles were reversed, so I pulled my head back, so I could put my index finger and middle finger in my mouth, to moisten them up a little, before placing them against her pussy lips. Then I rose up, resting on one arm, hovering above Sara, and slowly slid my fingers inside her.

"FUUCK! I'm gonna fucking cum!" Sara screamed, her body trembling, her cheeks flushed, as she grabbed the bedsheets on either side of her. I used the opportunity to lean my head down, placing a tender kiss on her left nipple, as my fingers slowly slid deeper and deeper inside her.

"Do it, Sara," I whispered. "Cum for me," I added, unable to remain quiet any longer, the mix of love and arousal too overwhelming. The sound of her voice, and the softness of her skin was intoxicating, and I no longer cared that speaking would reveal my presence to her, as I slid my fingers back and forth inside the soft warmth of her pussy, faster and faster with every thrust.

Sara immediately reached up and tore the blindfold off, and our eyes met. For split second beat I regretted announcing myself, thinking she might see this as a betrayal, wondering what the hell I was doing, but it only took a heart beat to know I was wrong. Our eyes met, and I saw all the emotions running through my mind echoed in her eyes. In that heart beat, our minds met, and I knew she saw the same love in my eyes.

I found myself lost of words as I looked deep into Sara's eyes, but thankfully she spoke for us, by reaching up and grabbing my head. She pulled my head towards her, and our lips met in a passionate kiss. It all happened so fast, and I was barely aware of the kiss, before I felt our tongues meeting in a fevered dance. A part of me registered Sara moans rising, the trembling sensation inside her rising to a furious crescendo. Neither of us wanted to break off the kiss to breathe, and I felt her pussy clenching down hard around my fingers.