Chapter 28
Jess
When Beck suggested hair and nails, I thought it was our inside joke. Allie and I laughed, but then she gave me that look, the one that said she actually wanted it, and what was I supposed to do? I had no intention of doing anything with Beck. I don't like her. She's bossy and controlling toward Allie, and she makes me uncomfortable. I get the feeling she doesn't want me around. The way she looks at me when Allie can't see is pure hatred.
"Uh... Al?" I've never fisted anyone but Allie. I don't even know if I want to touch Beck, but Allie's eyes are filled with lust. I saw the way she kissed Beck, like she couldn't get enough. She won't kiss me like that. Fuck, she won't even kiss me at all. I hate this. It's like Beck's moved into my world with the single purpose of taking Allie from me.
"Fuck, yes, Jess. Fist me." Allie takes my hand and guides it between her legs, and how can I say no? I want to lean down and kiss her, show her that I'm better than Beck. I'm only doing this to make her happy because how would she feel if I told her no? It would push her right into Beck's arms.
I feel how wet she is from Beck eating her. She gets wet like this for me too, but I don't want to think about Beck eating her. I don't want think about anything with Beck. I don't want to do this, so as Beck gets into position, seated next to Allie with her legs spread and staring straight at Allie, I almost get up and walk away. I force myself to stay, for Allie's sake, but I'm not happy.
Beck reaches over and forces Allie to look into her eyes and then kisses her. And here I am on my knees between them, both of their pussies spread to me. I can't hide the disappointment on my face, but I don't have to. They're going at it like horny teenagers, making out and grabbing each other's tits, and all I have to do is put my fists in them and it can be over.
I touch Allie first. I'm doing this for her. I have to keep reminding myself of that, or I'll just quit. So I put my hand between her legs, and my other between Beck's and start to put fingers into each of them. First only a few, then all four. When I put my thumbs in and begin twisting and thrusting, I can tell Beck has never done this. Allie is loose, comfortable like a pair of warm gloves in winter, but Beck is tight.
It would bring me great joy to shove my fist in so hard it hurts her, but I'm not that horrible of a person. I put my fist into Allie easily, fucking her as she grinds against me, and Beck touches her clit. I hate that--Beck's fingers touching my best friend--but Allie seems to like it, and if a threesome is what she wants, then it's what she gets. I'm doing this for Allie.
Beck takes it much more slowly, a lot more twisting and pushing, but when it sinks, she comes instantly. Allie touches her clit too while they kiss. Fuck, all I can do is fuck them both with my fists while I watch Allie's lips claim Beck's over and over. Beck grunts and groans, and finally she pulls her mouth away from Allie and arches her head back. She's so selfish she stops rubbing Allie off too, so I lower my lips and suck her clit, but I keep my eyes turned up to watch her face.
Allie stares down at me with a frantic look of panic, as if she's right on the edge but she needs more. I stare up at her and move my lips away from her pussy, lightly blow on it, then mouth the words "you taste so fucking good," and she convulses, grunting and locking her eyes on mine. My lips suck her so good, tasting her moisture even as she massages Beck to completion. I'm spent, my arms are tired, and I feel like crying.
I pull my hands out of their bodies, and though I want to lick Allie's cum from my fingers, I don't. My heart's heavy. Allie watches me as I pick up my t-shirt and wipe my hands on it. She's quiet even as Beck breathes heavily and gropes her tits still. I can't make eye contact with her. I just pick up my clothes and pat her knee.
"I'm going to shower, okay?" Maybe she'll get rid of Beck while I'm upstairs. We need to get Cora out of her place in the laundry room and let her toilet before bedtime. And Shep needs to be walked too.
"You okay?" she asks, standing, but I see Beck take her hand.
"I'm okay, babe. I just want to shower now. I think I got sauce from dinner in my hair." I force a smile. God, do I want to kiss her, wrap my arms around her and hold her close. She'll come to bed soon enough though. Maybe tonight we can have that talk.
"Okay..." She lets me go and has a reluctant look on her face, and I fully expect that while I'm gone they'll fuck more.
My heart feels like lead as I make my way up the stairs. Feet too. I did that for her, because I want her to have anything her heart wants, even if it's another woman. That's how I know I really love her. Because what sort of person would I be to tell her no she can't have Beck when we've already promised each other that nothing between us changes? We'll only ever be friends. I have to push this feeling away. She rejected me over the weekend because she isn't feeling what I do. She isn't in love. This I just hair and nails to her.
I dump my clothes on the floor since there is no hamper in here anymore and turn on the water. I scrub my skin, trying to remove the scent of Beck from my body. Somehow it's permeated every pore on me, and I hate it. I hate Beck. I don't want her here. I'm so jealous. I want Allie to love I. But I will not ruin it for Allie. If she has a real chance at something with Beck then I have to be her friend and let it happen. She deserves that.
I'm almost clean and ready to get out when Allie walks into the bathroom fully clothed. I open the shower door and wipe the water from my eyes, confused. Why is she dressed?
"Hey, girl..." She sounds hesitant to say what's on her mind.
"Everything okay?" I blink back more water sluicing off my hair into my eyes and watch her face contort to a look of sorrow.
"Uh, Beck wants to take me home. She's not sleeping over 'cause she has court in the morning, but she thinks it's not safe for me to drive home." Allie chews her lip nervously.