The story continues from Katie's perspective:
I was so wiped out from what had occurred Sunday that when Jackie and Tina left, I managed to push some of the hay she left for us into a small pile. I then crumpled on top of it, and felt into a deep sleep. For some reason I had dreams where I was a Pony, and Tina was brushing me down, taking extra special care with my long brunette hair. I was tied down to a post, and was chewing on a big carrot which Tina had given me as a treat for being a good Pony.
I awoke abruptly, feeling someone kicking me in my side. When I opened my eyes I saw Tina wearing a black thigh-high boot. Jackie already had awoken Sarah and was getting her ready. Tina stuck a Pony tail in my ass, and told me to stay while she grabbed my bit.
When Sarah and I were prepared, Tina led us up the stairs, out into the garage and into the mini-van, where she tied us down to the floor as she had done the previous day. Tina then left the van for what seemed like 15 minutes, before she returned with Jackie. Tina carried two suitcases, which led me to believe we were all going on a trip somewhere overnight. I was not happy about this, but as Tina's Pony I had no rights of my own.
We all drove in the mini-van for what seemed like a couple of hours. Unable to see anything, I was left to my thoughts, trying to decide how I had become Tina's Pony, her possession which she could do anything with. The van finally stopped, and Jackie got out first, then Tina. Tina came back a few minutes later, untied us, and grabbed our reigns, leading us outside the van, which was backed up to a motel room door.
Tina led us into the room and into a large over sized closet. She tied our reigns to the clothes pole overhead, and then shut the door, leaving us inside. Unable to speak with Sarah, I tried rubbing up against her like real Ponies do. I wanted to feel her warmth on my body, I wanted to feel her touch on my body, and she wanted the same from me. We stroked each other and I started feeling all tingly inside. My pussy was getting wet, and my Pony tail started getting loose in my butt. I spoke as best I could ask Sarah to stop, but all that came out was "Mehrrher."
When we heard the motel room door open with separated, and Tina opened the closet door. She untied our reigns and led us outside the room and into the van. She tied us down in the van, and got into the passenger seat. Jackie was in the driver's seat already, and started driving the van. We stopped about 20 minutes later. Tina led us outside to what looked like a big mansion. She brought us into what looked like a barn. Inside were 20 other girls all dressed as Pony's as we were, and all tied down to posts on the floor. Apparently Jackie and Tina brought us to a Pony show. I hoped we would be the best Pony's there.
From what I could tell Sarah and I were the cutest looking Pony's, each of us having tight and tanned hides, our boobs slightly hanging down, our shapely hips swaying back and four as we walked, causing our tails to sway left to right and back again.
Tina soon arrived and told us there were rules for the competition. Of course we were to follow her every command. Tina pulled Sarah out in front of me to demonstrate what she was talking about.
"When I want you to turn right, I will swat your right ass check with my riding crop," Tina said, taking an extra hard slap on Sarah's right cheek.
"When I want you to turn left, I will swat your left ass check with my riding crop," she said, putting a large red mark on Sarah's left ass cheek.
"When I want you to stay, I will take the riding crop just above your ass," Tina said, once again demonstrating on poor Sarah, who was talking all the punishment with tears running from her eyes.
"When I want you to walk on your hind legs, I will put the riding crop under your chin. If you do not move quickly enough, I will hit you hard in the face. Don't make me hurt your pretty Pony faces," Tina said.
Tina led Sarah back into the holding area with me, and allowed us to nuzzle up with each other for a little bit. I could feel Sarah trembling. I wondered if she had ever been at one of these shows before.
Unable to see the show ring, Sarah and I were kept in the dark, only able to hear applause and swatting of Ponies. Tina opened the door to our stall, grabbed Sarah's reigns and yanked her forward. I could hear Jackie's voice next, so I think Jackie took Sarah into the show ring for her performance.
Some time passed before the stall door opened again. This time Sarah was pushed into the stall with a kick on her ass by Tina. Sarah's head was down, as if she had not done a good job.
"You're next," Tina said to me, grabbing my reigns and pulling me forward. I walked down a long hallway before stopping at an open door. Over a loudspeaker I heard them introduce Tina, and she pulled me forward into the ring. Using the riding crop as she demonstrated, I moved right, then left, then right again. I stayed when Tina wanted me to, and walked slow or fast according to her manual instructions.
I was concentrating to follow and obey Tina's orders, which seemed to work, as after we were finished, everyone clapped and Tina patted me on my face, saying "Good pony" over and over again.
Instead of going back to the stall I shared with Sarah, I was led to a large room, with other girls who had become their owner's Ponies. Each girl was different, which led me to believe we were all winners somehow. There was a blonde, a redhead, an Asian girl, a beautiful black girl, and even an older woman with white hair who looked as if she was in her 40s.
It came time for all of us to go back into the main show ring. Tina led me around and gave me orders which I obeyed. I saw the other Pony's do the same tricks. A large woman watched everything and walked up and down our line, stopping at me. She looked at my owner, handed her a ribbon, and moved on to the next Pony.
Tina gave me a big hug and whispered in my ear, "We did it. We won Best of Show. I am so proud of you."
I felt a real sense of accomplishment, having won Best of Show in my first ever Pony competition. After a brief awards ceremony and photos, Tina led Sarah and me back to the mini-van. She tied us down and off we went back to Jackie's home. On the way I looked over at Sarah and saw how dejected she looked. Also her beautiful body was covered with riding crop marks and bruises. Apparently she had trouble following Jackie's instructions.
The mini-van stopped all of a sudden. I knew we were not home yet as the ride was not long enough. I over heard Tina complaining that she had to pee, so Jackie said she would pull over at the nearest gas station. Tina hopped out, leaving Jackie alone with me and Sarah.
Jackie turned around and said, "You were a very bad Pony, Sarah. You did not do as you were told, and for that you will be punished hard. Your friend Katie did much better. She followed Tina's instructions and won Best of Show. You will pay in punishment in order to do as she did."
Jackie came back to where we were, and pulled on Sarah's reins, forcing her head to rise higher then normal. Jackie then pulled out a long strand with metal clips on either side. Out of the corner of my eye I saw as Jackie clipped the ends of the strand onto Sarah's nipples. Sarah was biting down hard on her bit to control herself. Then Jackie pulled out some small weights. I think she said they each weighed a quarter pound.
Jackie yanked on the strand once to make sure it was solid, and I saw Sarah's eyes widen really big. She then forcibly yanked out Sarah's Pony tail and inserted a much larger one which worked on a remote. At Jackie's whim Sarah's butt would start throbbing from the violently moving orb in her butt, causing Sarah to wince in pain.
Jackie went back to the driver's seat, and after Tina arrived we took off. Every movement of the car and every bump in the rode made the weights hanging from Sarah's nipples go back and forth, making her nipples really swollen.
By the time we got back home, I though Sarah had passed out a couple times from the pain. Jackie left the van, and Tina untied us. She first untied Sarah, but left the weights hanging from the strand clipped on her nipples, and the large butt plug in Sarah's ass. Tina slapped her ass hard with her hand, and said, "Bad Pony has to get going and get more punishment. Go get in the house Bad Pony and prepare for the worst.
Sarah trotted out into the house and down the basement, with the weights dragging against the ground, forcing Sarah's tits to sag. Tina closed the door to the mini-van, untied me and started stroking my boobs. She took the bit out of my mouth, allowing me to breathe fully for the first time in a while.