I stared at Natalie, trying not to look too guilty or let any facial movement give me away. But, really, how do I answer that question?
"So, want to tell me what happened?"
I certainly couldn't say "no."
"I don't know what you're talking about." I said, turning my head to break eye contact. I'm also fairly sure my face got a little flush.
After a moment, I looked back at Natalie, who was ever so slightly leaning toward me, still looking at me sideways, and I could see one eyebrow flick up, ever so slightly, then back down. This couldn't' be good for me.
She took a deep breath and exhaled slowly.
"There are three reasons I know you're not telling the truth." She held up her fingers as she slowly walked back and forth in front of me. Either staring at me or looking upward.
Crap! This was Courtroom Natalie. She used to go into this when she had something on someone and wanted to draw it out. Last time she did it to me was that summer at Grandma's house where I broke her antique vase and tried to blame it on the dog.
"Firstly," she began in a confident tone, striding confidently, because, I have to say, she was very confident, "when I came in both you and Brianna had flush cheeks. You with your upper cheeks nice and pink and Brianna with a horizontal splash from her nose almost to her ear."
She stopped and looked at me for a response. I didn't have one so I blinked twice. Not in response, just because I had to blink.
"Secondly, you and Brianna both had hard nipples when I came in. Her, subtly under her thin sweater, and you, much more obviously, pushing against, and stretching out, MY tanktop!"
I looked down, and sure enough I was doing a hell of a job stretching out her tanktop. And, yes, my nipples were still hard. Maybe I enjoyed being yelled at? Jeez, it was getting hard to tell what I was into now.
I smiled and exhaled through my mouth with a little laugh. Trying to express the idea of "I think you're wrong" but really doing no such thing.
Natalie continued. Her pace became more strident as she walked in a semi circle around me.
"Thirdly, it doesn't take a keen eye to see that you have some wetness on your panties."
I craned my neck and moved my hips out to see and, as wet as I get, it was no surprise that there was more than a small spot of wetness on my panties.
"Ummm"
"And lastly, unless we're still in Mrs. Hill's English class, you don't wear bubblegum flavored lip gloss." Natalie paused here and walked up to me, placing her finger lightly on my lips. It was warm and soft and though I wasn't sure where this was going, part of me tingled.
I tried to compose myself.
"That was four." I managed to say, in an attempt to distract.
"Huh?"
"You said three reasons. That was four."
Natalie got even closer, her eyes narrowing, staring at me. Not blinking, which might have been the most unnerving thing.
"Nope." She said quietly, and quickly. "Not going to distract me."
Her whole face softened, her eyes became warm and she let a smile crawl across her lips as she pressed into me and gave me a soft, sensual, warm, wet kiss. It lasted for days and felt heavenly. I could feel her breath on me and her hands on my cheeks, holding my head in place. There was no sound other than the kiss and I let that sound surround me like a warm blanket. Then she backed up, looked at me as if gauging me. There was a hint of a smile on her face.
She then turned and stood in front of a chair.
"With this evidence, the prosecution rests."
She sat down, crossing her legs and intertwining her fingers, never for a moment breaking eye contact.
Despite myself, I smiled. It was a wonderful performance. She was brilliant and sexy as all hell as she let her smooth leg bounce lightly as she sat there.
I had to tell her everything. Well, except for the part where Brianna cupped my breast. I'm not sure why, but I didn't think that needed to be out there.
"So she couldn't kiss?" Natalie asked after I told her. Both of us sitting down now.
"Well, you remember kissing grandma?" I asked.
Natalie made a sour face, "With the tight lips and weird pressure?"
"Yup," I nodded, "that's the one. That's why guys didn't want to see her again. They were put off by it. As anyone would be."
Natalie stared off for a moment.
"I'm guessing you helped her, judging by the reaction I saw."
"She's a fast learner," I laughed, "she'll be a heartbreaker, if she figures it out."
Natalie pursed her lips and moved them around a bit, thinking. I could see the wheels turning.
"Not learning too fast, I hope," she said as she leaned forward and touched my hand. Her hand was warm and I definitely could feel the little ridges on her fingertips, including the tiny scar she got from cutting her finger at the cabin that one summer.
I stared into Natalie's eyes as she stood up and took my hand, silently guiding me to the bed. I was being led, and I absolutely loved it.
Next to the bed, Natalie kissed me again. A deep meaningful kiss. It was as if her entire essence was kissing me. Her hands once again on my face, caressing me. It was so light and tender and so unlike Natalie and yet so very arousing. She pushed me back onto the bed, somehow it seemed in slow motion. I wonder now if it was actually in sepia tone.
Natalie gave me a wicked little half smile, then grabbed the edges of my panties and pulled them slowly down my legs. I was getting goosebumps as she looked into my eyes while doing it.