Their meeting was accidental. Paul had tried to keep them apart, but Elaine got the day confused. Each knew about the other because Paul had made no secret that he was dating two women. But seeing each other nevertheless was extremely awkward. So when Ginny opened the door to Paul's apartment and saw Elaine they both were somewhat shocked. Neither said a word until Ginny said, "You must be Elaine. Please come in."
"Thanks," said Elaine. "I wasn't positive Paul and I were meeting today but thought I would come just in case. But I was wrong and didn't know you would be here. I'm very sorry. I realize this is a little bit strange. A lot strange. But -- how did you know it was me? Why would you assume that just because a woman comes to the door it was me?"
"Simple. I asked Paul to go steady and he said he didn't want to. I asked and asked and finally he said that it was because he could not give up seeing you. I asked why until he broke down and told me - because you had the best body he had ever seen. He said you were a 1 in a thousand in terms of your looks - perfect blond hair with a perfect face and a perfect body. Since that does describe you, you had to be Elaine. Simple. I can now see why Paul enjoys ...ahhh, dating you."
Elaine reflected for a minute. She was much less complimented over the praise than she was saddened and surprised that Paul has not mentioned anything about her personality. About her generous nature, all the love she gave him, her devotion to him. She had long suspected that he only dated her for her body. How many times has he left right after they had sex without even pretending to make small talk?
Elaine replied, "I know some things about you too, Ginny. You see, I also asked Paul to go steady, and he also told me 'no'. He at first refused to say why, but I told him that I wouldn't let him make love to me unless he told me. She smiled. He said he wanted to keep dating you because you have most talented tongue on the planet. He said he couldn't give up your tongue - and also your fingers and your overall passionate nature. He said you are, in terms of your lovemaking skills, a wild woman, a 1 in a thousand."
Ginny smiled. The description was spot on, but she was sad that Paul did not mention her sense of humor, her compassion, her caring, her helpful nature. Her artistic side, her brains and creativity. Her ---
Ginny knew deep inside that Paul was only dating her for sex, but she has tried denying it to herself. But hearing it from Elaine made her wonder that maybe she should break it off and find someone she could relate to better. Besides - Paul did not even satisfy her sexually. Her sex drive was much higher than his, and even if he was not also seeing Elaine he would not be able to keep up with her. Why exactly did she keep seeing him? She was being a chump, big time, she told herself. But Ginny soon forgot Paul because, while she was a cute looking girl, she was certainly not in the same league as Elaine. Even being in the same room with Elaine made her feel inadequate. She knew that when it came to men, if they just gave her a chance she could more than compete with beautiful women because of her fire and her talents. But mostly she wished that Paul - or another man - could appreciate her brain and other non-sexual talents as well, and wondered if she had the strength to end it before she found someone else.
Ginny invited Elaine in, and they continued to talk. They compared notes about Paul, getting more and more candid. They also talked about nothing in particular for a long time, each having so much fun that they lost all track of time. After quite a long time they were really warming up to each other. Within a few wonderful hours each had somehow been transformed in the mind of the other from Mysterious Rival, to the warm, compassionate, and friendly woman each in fact was.
But no matter how well they got along, no matter how easily they talked and how much they laughed (at Paul's expense, at Paul's antics, at life in general) there also was at times an air of tension because they were, of course rivals for Paul's attention. And, despite the warm banter, Elaine stared at Ginny - could it possibly be true? What Paul said about Ginny? She decided to be direct.
"Look Ginny, if Paul wanted you for your brains or wit or generous nature I sure could understand it because you are one of the most engaging, intriguing, and fascinating woman - people - I have ever met. If Paul was in love with you I could understand that. But I simply can't believe that you - that any woman - can compete with me sexually, in terms of lovemaking. You are a nice looking girl, cute, fit and trim, great looking in fact. But just take a look at me! (She stood up, thrust out her breasts (which made Ginny's eyes bulge), and turned around.) I can more than satisfy any man. In fact, I am more than any man can handle."
Ginny replied that Elaine was indeed beautiful, gorgeous, ravishing. But Ginny calmly looked Elaine in the eye and informed Elaine that she could do things with her passion, tongue and fingers that Elaine could not even dream of.
"No," Elaine replied softly, but firmly. "Not to sound too conceited, but I know I am not just good looking. I am dazzling. When I get undressed at the gym even the straight girls' nipples get erect when they look at me, and their pussys get soaking wet. I'm talking about straight pussys! The gay girls are paralyzed with lust over me! Even though I have never done anything with a woman, they beg me again and again."
When she saw a look of bemusement fall over Ginny's lips, Elaine decided to show her. Ginny's eyes got wider and wider as Elaine stripped down to her underwear. When Elaine took off her bra, Ginny gasped. They were indeed the sexiest set of breasts she had ever seen. Breasts that would drive any man or - God help her - any woman wild. When Elaine took off her panties Ginny almost forgot that she was straight - so much perfect beauty that all she could do was stare. As Elaine had warned, Ginny could feel her nipples becoming erect through her bra and shirt, and her pussy getting wet.
With a look of triumph Elaine put her two index fingers on Ginny's nipples, one after the other, which continued to show more and more, to Ginny's great embarrassment. Worse, Ginny's nipples became even harder after Elaine touched them.
"Didn't I tell you, Ginny? No one, man or woman, can fight my looks. If I had a penny for every happily married man or woman who has come on to me... Tell me what you think, Ginny."
